matthew mcglynn
You have two microphones and two hours. How many ways can you mike a drum kit?
I had a good idea of my choices, but I wanted to hear them all together so I would know what works in my room. It's no different from getting to know your own mic locker; each stereo mic placement technique is a tool, and like any tool it is only useful if you know how to use it.
I made a list of seven stereo mic techniques for drum recording, then recorded myself playing the same thing on the same drums in the same room, as heard through the same pair of microphones — in seven different configurations. Following is a detailed comparison of Spaced Pair (omni and cardioid), Coincident Pair (omni and cardioid), ORTF, Mid-Side and
Recorderman.”
The mics in question were a pair of
SE Electronics' 4400a The 4400a is an incredibly versatile large-diaphragm multipattern FET condenser in a very small form-factor. (We are liking this mike a lot; watch for a full review soon.)
The audio samples below are stereo 320kbps MP3s. I recommend listening in headphones, as the differences among the tracks are easiest to hear if the sound of your own monitoring environment is well-controlled.
Listening with the proper mindset
All the following are legitimate stereo miking techniques (well, except maybe for XY-omni). While you might find a favorite here, be aware that the appropriate technique for any session depends on the drums, the room, the player, the song, and the arrangement. As always.
Nonetheless, this test reveals characteristics of each OH miking technique — such as the width of the stereo field, the intimacy of the kit, the amount of room sound in the mix, the susceptibility to phasing or comb-filtering problems — that bear consideration for every session.
XY (Coincident Pair)
XY is one of the two most common stereo overhead miking techniques. For my test, the mics were in a 90° spread, about 55'' from the center of the snare head and 80'' above the floor.
I recorded samples in both Cardioid and Omnidirectional modes.
Neither of these clips presents a wide stereo image. Listen to the closing tom fill — there is little discernible lateral movement.
The image collapses to mono gracefully; this is expected, given that the mic capsules were close together. Listening in mono also reveals that, in stereo, both clips do present a sense of space — it's small, but it's there. If you don't like hearing tom fills that go from one corner of the room to the other, or if you're recording a song for which the drums play a background role, then XY is a reliable choice.
For me, both these tracks have too much boomy low end. I don't much like either of them.
The omni clip has far too much room sound for my taste. In a space that is either deader or tuned, I think omni is a more viable choice for drum overheads; for example, listen to the omni tracks in my old drum overhead shootout , in which an omni mic brought depth and LF without excessive boom or smeary HF.
Note, too, that the height of the XY pair will alter the sound of the result. I think I would have liked this pair better if I'd lowered the mics to a height of about 60 inches (instead of 80" this would have reduced the apparent volume of the room sound, and provided more stereo separation too.
Update:
Reader Malcolm Paterson posted a comment suggesting a stereo widening” technique — subtracting ~6dB worth of the inverted L signal from R, and vice-versa. Here's the result… we'll be playing more with this soon.
The spaced pair is the other of the most common overhead drum miking techniques, although there are an infinite variety of ways to do it.
Perhaps more than any other method tested, the spaced pair approach requires care to avoid phasing problems. As an example, let's say the snare drum resonates at 400Hz. The wavelength of a 400Hz tone is about 33 inches. If one of a pair of haphazardly-placed OH mics is 16.5 inches closer to the snare than the other, then the snare sound will arrive out-of-phase at the two mics, and in mono the 400Hz tone won't be heard.
While it's true that drums resonate at multiple frequencies, phasing problems can nonetheless cause drums to sound thin.
The easiest way to avoid screwing up the snare sound with phasing problems is to put the two capsules of the spaced pair at equal distances from the center of the snare head. This has the added benefit of centering the snare in the stereo image, which is most likely where you want it anyway.
To be fair, this arrangement may well introduce phasing problems with the kick or toms, which is why the OH mic position should always be tested before recording.
The 3:1 rule suggests that the mics should be three times farther apart than their height above the drum kit. In practice, I see engineers worrying more about the distance from the snare than the distance between the mics. Use your ears (and a tape measure too).
Should the mics' capsules be pointed straight down, angled in, angled out, or aimed directly at the snare? It's a matter of taste. Any drums or cymbals that are on-axis — meaning, in the mics' line of sight” — are going to be more clearly heard and probably louder too. Adjust the OH position with an ear toward your final mix.
In this test, the mics were 69'' from the floor, 52'' from the center of the snare, and 58'' apart, with the capsules pointing straight down. I recorded samples in both Cardioid and Omnidirectional modes.
The Cardioid clip gives a wide stereo image. The hi-hat is firmly on the left. The tom fill has some movement, although it seems to start in the middle move to the right. (The panning of close tom mics could of course alter this perception.)
I like the sound of the Cardioid pair; the drums retain their presence without losing the sound of the room. I can hear the space, but I can hear the drums too. It's a good balance.
In Omni, the mics bring in more of the sound of the room, but not so much as in XY. This is probably a result of the fact that in XY, the mics were mostly pointing past the drums. But while this Omni track doesn't offend me, I'd be more likely to choose Cardioid for most applications, and rely on room mics for the room sound.
ORTF is a curious stereo technique with specific positioning requirements: 17cm between capsules, angled 110° apart. I fudged this slightly, owing to haste and my unfortunate reliance on the World's Worst Stereo Mic Bar (produced by On-Stage Stands). Note that the 4400a stereo kit includes a far superior stereo bar that I wish I'd used instead. Alas.
My ORTF pair was 77'' above the floor, 53'' above the snare, positioned so the snare was equidistant from the two mics' capsules.
The sound of this track grew on me over repeated listenings. The drums sound big, but not excessively boomy. The cymbals are well-represented without taking anyone's face off.
The stereo image is not as wide as on the Spaced Pair track, but ORTF sounds more realistic — see below for a head-to-head comparison of ORTF vs. Spaced Pair.
I don't hear any drastic volume changes when I monitor the ORTF track in mono; this suggests a lack of significant phase problems.
I think I'd like ORTF even better if the mics were lower.
Mid-Side
The following two clips are of the same performance; the only difference is a mix-time gain change.
Mid-Side is a stereo technique that promises perfect mono compatibility. It employs a mid” Cardioid mic pointed at the source, and a side” figure-of-8 mic whose null is pointed at the source. The stereo left” channel is the mid plus the side, while the right” channel is the mid minus the side… more or less. (See this video to learn more about mid-side technique)
One of the benefits of mid-side is that adjusting the relative gain of the two signals can alter the perceived width of the stereo image. The louder the side” channel is, the wider the stereo image is. That said, the side channel is comprised entirely of off-axis sounds, which might not sound very good, depending on the instrument and room.
My MS pair was located 71'' above the floor, with the mid” capsule about 52'' from the center of the snare. I produced two samples; the difference between narrow” and wide” is about 8dB worth of gain on the side channel. (The mid channel is about 9dB (RMS) louder than the side channel in the wide” mix, and about 17dB louder than the side channel in the narrow” mix.)
The narrow” mix sounds a lot like XY! The XY track contains more of the sound of the room, due to the height of the XY pair. But the stereo image is similar in size.
Flipping to mono, the narrow” track sounds almost the same as in stereo. There is not much side-channel information in this mix.
The wide” track communicates a greater sense of space, but the change is subtle. And it's not true stereo separation to my ear; rather, the size of the space seems to grow, and the size of the kit seems to grow, but I don't hear the high-hats or floor tom move farther to the outside of the mix.
Mono compatibility is excellent for both these tracks, as expected.
But I'm not fond of this sound. Part of the problem is that the side” channel sounds like a room mic, not like an overhead; I'd rather my stereo image not come at the cost of trashing up the sound of the kit. But as with the Omni samples above, Mid-side would likely work better in a treated room.
The Recorderman” technique is a close-overhead technique that attempts to put both mics equidistant from both the snare and the kick drum. One mic stands about 32'' above the snare, pointing straight down, while the other sits over the drummer's right shoulder, pointing at the snare. Here's a video tutorial
I panned the two tracks hard R/L in this clip, which maximizes the width of the stereo image at the cost of leaving a hole in the middle. Listen to the closing tom fill; it sort of jumps from left to right. But of course this is easy to adjust at mix time.
This clip sounds unlike every other clip on this page. It's punchy, clean, and very dry. All that room sound from the other samples is gone, because the mics are nearly half the distance from the drums as before. (Hello, inverse-square law!)
This sound puts me in the middle of the kit. I love the presence of this sound. The kick drum is tighter-sounding here than in any other clip.
But is it too dry?
Head to head
XY
Mid-side
Recorderman
ORTF
Spaced Pair
The tonal difference is eye-opening. Compare the sound of the cymbal in the first two sections; the XY clip contains much more cymbal ring than does the MS clip. Then hear how the cymbals drop away in the third section (Recorderman) — a much drier, more drum-centric OH configuration.
The ORTF clip sounds tonally similar to Recorderman, but has a wider stereo image. The spaced pair clip is wider still, but introduces a tonal change that I'm not fond of.
XY vs Spaced Pair
The next comparison illustrates the stereo field differences between XY and spaced pair, with both mics in Cardioid mode. This clip contains a 1-bar excerpt from the XY sample, then Spaced, and then the whole thing repeats.
I far prefer the spaced-pair approach. The drum kit, unlike just about every other instrument on stage, is naturally a stereo instrument. (And personally, I do like those big Neil Peart tom fills that go from one corner of the room to another!)
ORTF vs Spaced Pair
The next comparison reveals the stereo field differences between ORTF and Spaced Pair. Just to keep things confusing, this time the excerpts are 2 bars long: a 2-bar clip in ORTF, then Spaced, then ORTF again, then Spaced again.
As mentioned above, the sound of ORTF grew on me. It's not as wide as the Spaced Pair image, but it sounds more realistic. Although I liked the Spaced Pair track in isolation, when I compare it to ORTF, it seems unnatural.
Personal Preferences
The Recorderman” technique has been my go-to OH technique for years, so it is familiar, and a welcome change from what was sounding like excessively room-y overhead tracks. I really like the sound of it, and I like that the mics can be close to the kit without being in the way.
But the ORTF results sounded really good, too, and promises an easier setup. Two mics on a single stand can easily be moved around in space to quickly find a sweet spot for height and angle. I'll definitely be trying ORTF more in the future.
What about Glyn Johns?!
The most obvious missing drum mic technique here is the Glyn Johns” method, about which more can be read here I skipped it primarily because it is not a stereo overhead technique — it's a 4-mic approach for the whole drum kit.
Certainly any of the OH techniques I tried would likely be augmented by close mics on the kick and snare, and possibly tom mics and ambient mics too. But all the techniques I tested give a usable representation of the kit. I'm not sure that would be true with one-half of the Glyn Johns approach.
I also didn't try a Jecklin disk. I've never seen anyone record drums that way, but it sounds like fun. Maybe next time.
Conclusions
A few useful lessons emerged from this process:
A pair of cardioid mics provides several distinct, viable OH sounds.
If the mic placement puts the whole drum kit off-axis, the OH sound will be primarily the sound of the room.
The closer the mics are to the kit, the less room sound you'll hear (and the less preamp gain you'll need).
Avoid phase issues by keeping the snare and kick centered between the mics.
XY and mid-side create the narrowest stereo image; ORTF and spaced pair create a wider image.
Reduce cymbal volume (and room sound) via Recorderman.
As always, the main takeaway is Test and listen!” But you knew that already.
I'd like to hear your lessons, too: is your go-to OH technique dependent on the room, the size of the kit, the style of music? Are there gotchas” not already listed here? When the drummer can't stop pounding the hell out of the cymbals, is it acceptable to simply move them out of his reach?
Showing posts with label miking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label miking. Show all posts
Thursday, 27 October 2016
Tuesday, 18 October 2016
Five Techniques For Stereo Miking Drums
By Matt McGlynn
A single pair of multipattern condenser microphones can provide at least five distinct overhead drum miking choices with surprisingly different sonic characteristics.
To demonstrate these different sounds, we recorded a drum kit with a pair of KSM44A overhead microphones five different ways. The drums, the room, the preamps, cables, and composition remained the same. The only variable was the position of the microphones (and in one case, the polar pattern).
How different can a single pair of microphones, in the same room with the same drums, really sound? As you listen to the tracks below, consider the following:
Width of stereo field
Ease of setup
The XY or coincident pair approach wins points for its guaranteed mono compatibility. Because the two capsules are so close together (coincident”), sound waves from every drum and cymbal impinge upon the two mics' diaphragms nearly simultaneously, avoiding any risk of comb-filtering due to partial cancellation of out-of-phase waves when the two OH tracks are heard in mono.
A consequence of coincident positioning is that the resulting stereo field is narrow, even when the two OH tracks are panned hard L/R. This is a good choice for arrangements in which the drums play a supporting role, or when mono compatibility is critical.
Overhead microphone height is an important consideration in this and every technique. If the mics are very high, the capsules will point straight over the sides of the of the kit, essentially putting the entire instrument off-axis. This will result in an overly roomy sound.
Lowering the microphones, or using an angle less than 90o can result in a more direct sound, although the kick and snare will always be off-axis.
Regardless of height, I recommend mounting the XY array directly above the snare drum, to ensure that the snare is centered in the stereo image.
The M-S technique, like XY, ensures mono compatibility. And like XY, it produces a relatively narrow stereo spread.
A primary benefit is that the perceived size of the space can be changed at mix time, by varying the amount of side” channel in the mix. This is often described as adjusting the stereo width,” but to my ear the drum kit doesn't get any wider. The high and low toms don't get farther apart. The room gets bigger, but the drums sound less direct.
The challenge of M-S is that one of the two microphones is not pointed at the drum kit. The figure-of-8 mic is positioned so the drums are in the mic's null point; the microphone hears only reflected sound. If you are recording drums in a small or untreated room, chances are this reflected sound is not what you want on your record.
But if the room does sound good, M-S is a great way to combine a dry, direct sound — the Mid mic — with as much room ambience as suits the rest of the production.
The Recorderman technique is probably the newest and least-known technique here, although it is conceptually similar to the overhead configuration of Glyn Johns' more-famous approach.
It requires two Cardioid microphones. One is suspended 32” above the center of the snare drum, pointing straight down. The other is positioned near the drummer's right shoulder, pointing directly at the snare drum from 32″ away.
This technique requires that the kick drum is also equidistant from both microphones. This can be checked by taping the two ends of a length of string to the center of the snare and kick drums, respectively. Pinch the string together at the point where it touches the mic above the snare, so that both legs of the string are taut. Move that point of the string in an arc toward the drummer's right shoulder to find the perfect location of the second microphone — at a point where it, too, is 32” from the center of the snare, and equally distant from the kick as is the first microphone.
The two tracks are panned L and R, although not necessarily 100%. Extreme panning of Recorderman overhead tracks can leave a hole in the middle of the stereo field.
Mono compatibility is not guaranteed, except for the kick and snare.
Because the microphones are relatively low, they will hear primarily the drums themselves. Cymbals will be understated, as will the sound of the room.
This is therefore a great way to combat some of the problems that plague live drum recording in home or project studios:
Small, untreated rooms that don't sound great
Untrained drummers who bash their cymbals
Even in large, purpose-built studios, the Recorderman technique is a useful way to capture dry overhead tracks that can be supplemented with more-distant ambient microphones, should the arrangement call for a roomier sound.
With a stereo bar, ORTF becomes very easy to use. Once the two microphones are locked into position — with capsules 17cm apart, at 110o- the single stand can easily be raised, lowered, or angled to tune the array to best suit the size of the kit, the sound of the room, and the desired amount of ambience in the recorded track.
Due to the wide spread of the microphones, it is likely that most of the drum kit will be between them, off-axis. This approach, like mid-side, is less likely to succeed in a small or untreated space, because the microphones will mostly hear reflected sounds. Moving the array closer to the drum kit, whether from behind or over the top, will result in a drier sound.
The ORTF stereo image is wider than XY, MS, or Recorderman, but not unbelievably so. Perhaps because the microphone position simulates human ear position, the resulting stereo field seems very natural and realistic, and generally collapses to mono without significant problems.
AB/Spaced Pair
The AB or Spaced Pair approach is among the simplest stereo techniques to understand, but it presents the most problems in practice.
Because the microphones are far apart, AB arrays are susceptible to comb filtering. The risk can be mitigated somewhat by keeping the two microphone capsules equidistant from the center of the snare drum — but even then, the mic placement should be auditioned (in mono) to reveal possible problems with the kick, toms, or cymbals.
Aside from phase-coherency challenges, AB is a powerful technique, with a large palette of sonic colors. By lowering the array, or angling the microphones in toward the center of the kit, room sound can be minimized. Conversely, there are numerous ways to use an AB pair to capture a roomier, indirect sound: by raising the microphones, moving them further out toward the sides of the kit, angling them to point straight down, or changing from Cardioid to a wider polar pattern.
AB arrays can produce a wide stereo image, simply because drums or cymbals very near one of the two microphones will be perceived to come from only that side of the stereo field.
This can result in an unrealistically large-sounding drum kit, if the overhead tracks are panned 100% L/R.
Head to head Comparison
Drum Miking Cheat Sheet
To minimize room sound, lower the OH microphones and point them toward the center of the kit.
To maximize room sound, raise the OH microphones, angle them away from the drums, or use wider polar patterns.
To minimize cymbal sound, try Recorderman.
To ensure mono compatibility, use XY or MS.
For the widest possible stereo spread, use AB.
Avoid phase coherency problems with kick and snare by keeping them centered between the OH mics.
Dry overhead tracks can be optionally supplemented with room mics.
A pair of cardioid mics provides several distinct, viable OH sounds.
Multipattern LDCs provide even more options.
A single pair of multipattern condenser microphones can provide at least five distinct overhead drum miking choices with surprisingly different sonic characteristics.
To demonstrate these different sounds, we recorded a drum kit with a pair of KSM44A overhead microphones five different ways. The drums, the room, the preamps, cables, and composition remained the same. The only variable was the position of the microphones (and in one case, the polar pattern).
How different can a single pair of microphones, in the same room with the same drums, really sound? As you listen to the tracks below, consider the following:
Width of stereo field
Ease of setup
The XY or coincident pair approach wins points for its guaranteed mono compatibility. Because the two capsules are so close together (coincident”), sound waves from every drum and cymbal impinge upon the two mics' diaphragms nearly simultaneously, avoiding any risk of comb-filtering due to partial cancellation of out-of-phase waves when the two OH tracks are heard in mono.
A consequence of coincident positioning is that the resulting stereo field is narrow, even when the two OH tracks are panned hard L/R. This is a good choice for arrangements in which the drums play a supporting role, or when mono compatibility is critical.
Overhead microphone height is an important consideration in this and every technique. If the mics are very high, the capsules will point straight over the sides of the of the kit, essentially putting the entire instrument off-axis. This will result in an overly roomy sound.
Lowering the microphones, or using an angle less than 90o can result in a more direct sound, although the kick and snare will always be off-axis.
Regardless of height, I recommend mounting the XY array directly above the snare drum, to ensure that the snare is centered in the stereo image.
The M-S technique, like XY, ensures mono compatibility. And like XY, it produces a relatively narrow stereo spread.
A primary benefit is that the perceived size of the space can be changed at mix time, by varying the amount of side” channel in the mix. This is often described as adjusting the stereo width,” but to my ear the drum kit doesn't get any wider. The high and low toms don't get farther apart. The room gets bigger, but the drums sound less direct.
The challenge of M-S is that one of the two microphones is not pointed at the drum kit. The figure-of-8 mic is positioned so the drums are in the mic's null point; the microphone hears only reflected sound. If you are recording drums in a small or untreated room, chances are this reflected sound is not what you want on your record.
But if the room does sound good, M-S is a great way to combine a dry, direct sound — the Mid mic — with as much room ambience as suits the rest of the production.
The Recorderman technique is probably the newest and least-known technique here, although it is conceptually similar to the overhead configuration of Glyn Johns' more-famous approach.
It requires two Cardioid microphones. One is suspended 32” above the center of the snare drum, pointing straight down. The other is positioned near the drummer's right shoulder, pointing directly at the snare drum from 32″ away.
This technique requires that the kick drum is also equidistant from both microphones. This can be checked by taping the two ends of a length of string to the center of the snare and kick drums, respectively. Pinch the string together at the point where it touches the mic above the snare, so that both legs of the string are taut. Move that point of the string in an arc toward the drummer's right shoulder to find the perfect location of the second microphone — at a point where it, too, is 32” from the center of the snare, and equally distant from the kick as is the first microphone.
The two tracks are panned L and R, although not necessarily 100%. Extreme panning of Recorderman overhead tracks can leave a hole in the middle of the stereo field.
Mono compatibility is not guaranteed, except for the kick and snare.
Because the microphones are relatively low, they will hear primarily the drums themselves. Cymbals will be understated, as will the sound of the room.
This is therefore a great way to combat some of the problems that plague live drum recording in home or project studios:
Small, untreated rooms that don't sound great
Untrained drummers who bash their cymbals
Even in large, purpose-built studios, the Recorderman technique is a useful way to capture dry overhead tracks that can be supplemented with more-distant ambient microphones, should the arrangement call for a roomier sound.
With a stereo bar, ORTF becomes very easy to use. Once the two microphones are locked into position — with capsules 17cm apart, at 110o- the single stand can easily be raised, lowered, or angled to tune the array to best suit the size of the kit, the sound of the room, and the desired amount of ambience in the recorded track.
Due to the wide spread of the microphones, it is likely that most of the drum kit will be between them, off-axis. This approach, like mid-side, is less likely to succeed in a small or untreated space, because the microphones will mostly hear reflected sounds. Moving the array closer to the drum kit, whether from behind or over the top, will result in a drier sound.
The ORTF stereo image is wider than XY, MS, or Recorderman, but not unbelievably so. Perhaps because the microphone position simulates human ear position, the resulting stereo field seems very natural and realistic, and generally collapses to mono without significant problems.
AB/Spaced Pair
The AB or Spaced Pair approach is among the simplest stereo techniques to understand, but it presents the most problems in practice.
Because the microphones are far apart, AB arrays are susceptible to comb filtering. The risk can be mitigated somewhat by keeping the two microphone capsules equidistant from the center of the snare drum — but even then, the mic placement should be auditioned (in mono) to reveal possible problems with the kick, toms, or cymbals.
Aside from phase-coherency challenges, AB is a powerful technique, with a large palette of sonic colors. By lowering the array, or angling the microphones in toward the center of the kit, room sound can be minimized. Conversely, there are numerous ways to use an AB pair to capture a roomier, indirect sound: by raising the microphones, moving them further out toward the sides of the kit, angling them to point straight down, or changing from Cardioid to a wider polar pattern.
AB arrays can produce a wide stereo image, simply because drums or cymbals very near one of the two microphones will be perceived to come from only that side of the stereo field.
This can result in an unrealistically large-sounding drum kit, if the overhead tracks are panned 100% L/R.
Head to head Comparison
Drum Miking Cheat Sheet
To minimize room sound, lower the OH microphones and point them toward the center of the kit.
To maximize room sound, raise the OH microphones, angle them away from the drums, or use wider polar patterns.
To minimize cymbal sound, try Recorderman.
To ensure mono compatibility, use XY or MS.
For the widest possible stereo spread, use AB.
Avoid phase coherency problems with kick and snare by keeping them centered between the OH mics.
Dry overhead tracks can be optionally supplemented with room mics.
A pair of cardioid mics provides several distinct, viable OH sounds.
Multipattern LDCs provide even more options.
Sunday, 16 October 2016
Miking The Drumset In Your Home Recording Studio
If you're like most musicians, getting great-sounding drum recordings seems like one of the world's great mysteries. You can hear big, fat drums on great albums, but when you try to record your drums, they always end up sounding more like cardboard boxes than drums. Fret not — here are some solutions for you.
The room
The room influences the drums' sound more than it influences other instruments'. If you're looking for a big drum sound, you need a fairly live room (one with lots of reflection).
You may be thinking, "But I just have a bedroom for a studio and it's carpeted." No worries, you can work with that. Remember, you have a home studio, so you potentially have your whole home to work with. Here are a couple of ideas to spark your imagination:
Buy three or four 4-x-8-foot sheets of plywood and lean them up against the walls of your room. Also place one on the floor just in front of the kick drum. This adds some reflective surfaces to the room.
Put the drums in your garage (or living room, or any other room with a reverberating sound) and run long mic cords to your mixer. If you have a studio-in-a-box system, you can just throw it under your arm and move everything into your garage or, better yet, take all this stuff to a really great-sounding room and record.
Set up your drums in a nice-sounding room and place an additional mic just outside the door to catch an additional ambient sound. You can then mix this in with the other drum tracks to add a different quality of reverberation to the drums.
Kick (bass) drum
The mic of choice for most recording engineers when recording a kick drum is a dynamic mic. In fact, you can find some large diaphragm dynamic mics specifically designed to record kick drums.
No matter where you place the mic, you can reduce the amount of boominess that you get from the drum by placing a pillow or blanket inside the drum. Some people choose to let the pillow or blanket touch the inside head.
That said, you can place your mic in several ways (all conveniently illustrated in Figure 1):
Near the inside head: If you take off the outside head or cut a hole in it, you can stick the mic inside the drum. Place the mic 2 to 3 inches away from the inside head and a couple of inches off center. This is the standard way to mic a kick drum if you have the outside head off or if a hole is cut in it. This placement gives you a sharp attack from the beater hitting the head.
Halfway inside the drum: You can modify the preceding miking technique by moving the mic back so that it's about halfway inside the drum. In this case, place the mic right in the middle, pointing where the beater strikes the drum. This placement gives you less of the attack of the beater striking the head and more of the body of the drum's sound.
Near the outside head: If you have both heads on the drum, you can place the mic a few inches from the outside head. If you want a more open, boomy sound (and you have the drum's pitch set fairly high), point the mic directly at the center of the head. If you want less boom, offset the mic a little and point it about two-thirds of the way toward the center.
The kick drum responds quite well to a compressor when tracking. For the most part, you can get by with settings that allow the initial attack to get through and that tame the boom a little. A sample setting looks like this:
Threshold: -6dB
Attack: Between 40 ms and 50 ms
Release: Between 200 ms and 300 ms
Gain: Adjust so that the output level matches the input level. You don't need much added gain.
Snare drum
The snare drum is probably the most important drum in popular music. The bass guitar can cover the kick drum's rhythm, and the rest of the drums aren't part of the main groove. A good, punchy snare drum can make a track, whereas a weak, thin one can eliminate the drive that most popular music needs.
Because the snare drum is located so close to the other drums, especially the hi-hats, a cardioid pattern mic is a must. The most common mic for a snare drum is the trusty Shure SM57. The mic is generally placed between the hi-hats and the small tom-tom about 1 or 2 inches from the snare drum head (see Figure 2). Point the diaphragm directly at the head.
You may need to make some minor adjustments to eliminate any bleed from the hi-hats. This position gives you a nice punchy sound.
Adding compression to the snare drum is crucial if you want a tight, punchy sound. There are a lot of ways to go with the snare. The following settings are common and versatile:
Threshold: -4dB
Attack: Between 5 ms and 10 ms
Release: Between 125 ms and 175 ms
Gain: Adjust so that the output level matches the input level. You don't need much added gain.
Tom-toms
The tom-toms sound best when using a dynamic mic. For the mounted toms (the ones above the kick drum), you can use one or two mics. If you use one mic, place it between the two drums about 4 to 6 inches away from the heads (Figure 3 shows this placement option). If you use two mics, place one above each drum about 1 to 3 inches above the head.
Floor toms are miked the same way as the mounted tom-toms:
Place a single mic a couple of inches away from the head near the rim.
If you have more than one floor tom, you can place one mic between them or mic them individually.
If you want to apply compression to the tom-toms, you can start with the settings that for the snare drum in the preceding section.
Hi-hats
The hi-hats are generally part of the main groove and, as such, you want to spend time getting a good sound. You'll probably have problems with a few other mics on the drumset picking up the hi-hats, particularly the snare drum mic and overhead mics. Some people don't bother miking the hi-hats for this reason.
Hi-hats often sound too trashy through the snare drum mic. If you mic hi-hats, make sure that the snare drum mic is picking up as little of the hi-hats as possible by placing it properly and/or using a noise gate (a dynamic processor use to filter unwanted noise).
You can use either a dynamic mic or, better yet, a small diaphragm condenser mic for the hi-hats. The dynamic mic gives you a trashier sound and the small diaphragm condenser mic produces a bright sound. You can work with either by adjusting the EQ. Try adding just a little bit (4dB or so) of a shelf EQ set at 10 kHz to add just a little sheen to the hi-hats.
Place the mic about 3 to 4 inches above the hi-hats and point it down. The exact placement of the mic is less important than the placement of the other instrument mics because of the hi-hats' tone. Just make sure your mic isn't so close that you hit it.
Compression isn't usually necessary when tracking the hi-hats unless you have a drummer whose volume level is inconsistent. In this case, try using the same snare drum settings.
Cymbals
You want to know one secret to the huge drum sound of Led Zeppelin's drummer, John Bonham? Finesse. He understood that the drums sound louder and bigger in a mix if the cymbals are quieter in comparison. So he played his cymbals softly and hit the drums pretty hard. This allowed the engineer to raise up the levels of the drums without having the
cymbals drown everything else out. Absolutely brilliant.
Because the drums bleeding into the overhead mics is inevitable and the overhead mics are responsible for providing much of the drums' presence in a mix, playing the cymbals softly allows you to get more of the drums in these mics. This helps the drums sound bigger.
Ask (no, demand) that your drummer play the cymbals quieter. Also use smaller cymbals with a fast attack and a short decay. Doing these things creates a better balance between the drums and cymbals and makes the drums stand out more in comparison.
Small diaphragm condenser mics capture the cymbals' high frequencies well. You can mic the cymbals by placing mics about 6 inches above each cymbal or by using overhead mics set 1 to 3 feet above the cymbals.
The whole kit
Most of the time, you want to have at least one (but preferably two) ambient mics on the drums if for no other reason than to pick up the cymbals. These (assuming you use two mics) are called overhead mics and, as the name implies, they are placed above the drumset. The most common types of mics to use for overheads are large and small diaphragm condenser mics because they pick up the high frequencies in the cymbals and give the drumset's sound a nice sheen (brightness). You also may want to try a pair of ribbon mics to pick up a nice, sweet sound on the overheads.
To mic the drumset with overhead mics, you can use either the X-Y coincident technique or spaced stereo pairs. Place them 1 to 2 feet above the cymbals, just forward of the drummer's head. Place X-Y mics in the center and set up spaced stereo pairs so that they follow the 3:1 rule (the mics should be set up 3 to 6 feet apart if they are 1 to 2 feet above the cymbals). This counters any phase problems. Point the mic down toward theFigure 4: Overhead mics capture the cymbals and the drums. drums and you're ready to record.
The room
The room influences the drums' sound more than it influences other instruments'. If you're looking for a big drum sound, you need a fairly live room (one with lots of reflection).
You may be thinking, "But I just have a bedroom for a studio and it's carpeted." No worries, you can work with that. Remember, you have a home studio, so you potentially have your whole home to work with. Here are a couple of ideas to spark your imagination:
Buy three or four 4-x-8-foot sheets of plywood and lean them up against the walls of your room. Also place one on the floor just in front of the kick drum. This adds some reflective surfaces to the room.
Put the drums in your garage (or living room, or any other room with a reverberating sound) and run long mic cords to your mixer. If you have a studio-in-a-box system, you can just throw it under your arm and move everything into your garage or, better yet, take all this stuff to a really great-sounding room and record.
Set up your drums in a nice-sounding room and place an additional mic just outside the door to catch an additional ambient sound. You can then mix this in with the other drum tracks to add a different quality of reverberation to the drums.
Kick (bass) drum
The mic of choice for most recording engineers when recording a kick drum is a dynamic mic. In fact, you can find some large diaphragm dynamic mics specifically designed to record kick drums.
No matter where you place the mic, you can reduce the amount of boominess that you get from the drum by placing a pillow or blanket inside the drum. Some people choose to let the pillow or blanket touch the inside head.
That said, you can place your mic in several ways (all conveniently illustrated in Figure 1):
Near the inside head: If you take off the outside head or cut a hole in it, you can stick the mic inside the drum. Place the mic 2 to 3 inches away from the inside head and a couple of inches off center. This is the standard way to mic a kick drum if you have the outside head off or if a hole is cut in it. This placement gives you a sharp attack from the beater hitting the head.
Halfway inside the drum: You can modify the preceding miking technique by moving the mic back so that it's about halfway inside the drum. In this case, place the mic right in the middle, pointing where the beater strikes the drum. This placement gives you less of the attack of the beater striking the head and more of the body of the drum's sound.
Near the outside head: If you have both heads on the drum, you can place the mic a few inches from the outside head. If you want a more open, boomy sound (and you have the drum's pitch set fairly high), point the mic directly at the center of the head. If you want less boom, offset the mic a little and point it about two-thirds of the way toward the center.
The kick drum responds quite well to a compressor when tracking. For the most part, you can get by with settings that allow the initial attack to get through and that tame the boom a little. A sample setting looks like this:
Threshold: -6dB
Attack: Between 40 ms and 50 ms
Release: Between 200 ms and 300 ms
Gain: Adjust so that the output level matches the input level. You don't need much added gain.
Snare drum
The snare drum is probably the most important drum in popular music. The bass guitar can cover the kick drum's rhythm, and the rest of the drums aren't part of the main groove. A good, punchy snare drum can make a track, whereas a weak, thin one can eliminate the drive that most popular music needs.
Because the snare drum is located so close to the other drums, especially the hi-hats, a cardioid pattern mic is a must. The most common mic for a snare drum is the trusty Shure SM57. The mic is generally placed between the hi-hats and the small tom-tom about 1 or 2 inches from the snare drum head (see Figure 2). Point the diaphragm directly at the head.
You may need to make some minor adjustments to eliminate any bleed from the hi-hats. This position gives you a nice punchy sound.
Adding compression to the snare drum is crucial if you want a tight, punchy sound. There are a lot of ways to go with the snare. The following settings are common and versatile:
Threshold: -4dB
Attack: Between 5 ms and 10 ms
Release: Between 125 ms and 175 ms
Gain: Adjust so that the output level matches the input level. You don't need much added gain.
Tom-toms
The tom-toms sound best when using a dynamic mic. For the mounted toms (the ones above the kick drum), you can use one or two mics. If you use one mic, place it between the two drums about 4 to 6 inches away from the heads (Figure 3 shows this placement option). If you use two mics, place one above each drum about 1 to 3 inches above the head.
Floor toms are miked the same way as the mounted tom-toms:
Place a single mic a couple of inches away from the head near the rim.
If you have more than one floor tom, you can place one mic between them or mic them individually.
If you want to apply compression to the tom-toms, you can start with the settings that for the snare drum in the preceding section.
Hi-hats
The hi-hats are generally part of the main groove and, as such, you want to spend time getting a good sound. You'll probably have problems with a few other mics on the drumset picking up the hi-hats, particularly the snare drum mic and overhead mics. Some people don't bother miking the hi-hats for this reason.
Hi-hats often sound too trashy through the snare drum mic. If you mic hi-hats, make sure that the snare drum mic is picking up as little of the hi-hats as possible by placing it properly and/or using a noise gate (a dynamic processor use to filter unwanted noise).
You can use either a dynamic mic or, better yet, a small diaphragm condenser mic for the hi-hats. The dynamic mic gives you a trashier sound and the small diaphragm condenser mic produces a bright sound. You can work with either by adjusting the EQ. Try adding just a little bit (4dB or so) of a shelf EQ set at 10 kHz to add just a little sheen to the hi-hats.
Place the mic about 3 to 4 inches above the hi-hats and point it down. The exact placement of the mic is less important than the placement of the other instrument mics because of the hi-hats' tone. Just make sure your mic isn't so close that you hit it.
Compression isn't usually necessary when tracking the hi-hats unless you have a drummer whose volume level is inconsistent. In this case, try using the same snare drum settings.
Cymbals
You want to know one secret to the huge drum sound of Led Zeppelin's drummer, John Bonham? Finesse. He understood that the drums sound louder and bigger in a mix if the cymbals are quieter in comparison. So he played his cymbals softly and hit the drums pretty hard. This allowed the engineer to raise up the levels of the drums without having the
cymbals drown everything else out. Absolutely brilliant.
Because the drums bleeding into the overhead mics is inevitable and the overhead mics are responsible for providing much of the drums' presence in a mix, playing the cymbals softly allows you to get more of the drums in these mics. This helps the drums sound bigger.
Ask (no, demand) that your drummer play the cymbals quieter. Also use smaller cymbals with a fast attack and a short decay. Doing these things creates a better balance between the drums and cymbals and makes the drums stand out more in comparison.
Small diaphragm condenser mics capture the cymbals' high frequencies well. You can mic the cymbals by placing mics about 6 inches above each cymbal or by using overhead mics set 1 to 3 feet above the cymbals.
The whole kit
Most of the time, you want to have at least one (but preferably two) ambient mics on the drums if for no other reason than to pick up the cymbals. These (assuming you use two mics) are called overhead mics and, as the name implies, they are placed above the drumset. The most common types of mics to use for overheads are large and small diaphragm condenser mics because they pick up the high frequencies in the cymbals and give the drumset's sound a nice sheen (brightness). You also may want to try a pair of ribbon mics to pick up a nice, sweet sound on the overheads.
To mic the drumset with overhead mics, you can use either the X-Y coincident technique or spaced stereo pairs. Place them 1 to 2 feet above the cymbals, just forward of the drummer's head. Place X-Y mics in the center and set up spaced stereo pairs so that they follow the 3:1 rule (the mics should be set up 3 to 6 feet apart if they are 1 to 2 feet above the cymbals). This counters any phase problems. Point the mic down toward theFigure 4: Overhead mics capture the cymbals and the drums. drums and you're ready to record.
Sunday, 7 August 2016
Miking The Grand Piano
By Nathan Rosenberg
I started recording pianos before recording anything else, probably because I am a pianist. It is a notoriously difficult instrument to record, so when the editors of Recording asked me to write about miking acoustic pianos, I began by asking myself What if I had known then what I know now?”
What's the trouble?
The piano is a complicated contraption consisting of up to 7000 discrete parts. Hundreds of strings resonate sympathetically and then project in unpredictable directions. Challenges include reflections within the case, tuning, leakage from other instruments, and the sheer fact that no two pianos sound exactly alike. Then there's the wide range of pitches, from the lowest A (beneath the lowest E on a bass) to the highest C (which is also the highest note on the piccolo)—your mics have to be able to capture the full spectrum.
Finally, the sheer size of the Grand with its expanse of strings and the two-position lid calls for placement experimentation—too close and you might not capture the full range and miss out on the room sound, too far and you may get less definition and more room than is desirable.
Tone, tuning, placement
Every instrument has registers and dynamics where it sounds the best. Listen, enlist the help of the player or arranger, and get the best result from the instrument and the part. It pays to be flexible.
Piano tuning is an art, not a science. No two tunings sound exactly alike but they can all pretty noticeably change the character of an instrument. Discuss your requirements with all parties involved; a skilled piano tuner can help greatly.
Just because it's big and heavy doesn't mean you shouldn't move the Grand to the location where it sounds best in the room. Moving it gently shouldn't affect the tuning, and finding the right spot will have a profound effect on the piano's tone. Then look for the most balanced sound, in the sense that all notes from high to low have a similar sound, without any notes or note clusters sticking out more prominently than others.
Stereo—what stereo?
Piano lends itself nicely to stereo recording where two signals are split, traditionally with bass on the left and treble on the right which is the way the pianist hears it. This does not restrict you to orthodox, phase-coherent stereo techniques designed to create a strong center image. In fact, many of the techniques that follow will result in a very wide image that may not resolve perfectly to mono. Live with it.
You need to keep an eye and ear out for phase problems, whether you multi-mike and pan or record in true stereo using something like an XY technique. With all the sound bouncing around inside the case of a piano, there can be a lot of stuff out of phase. But before you use the meter, use your ears.
First, sum the mics to mono and note how the sound changes. If you lose a lot of bass or you hear some weird kind of filtering in the midrange, try switching the phase on one mic, or try moving it. A little repositioning goes a long way, and this may be enough to get things into the ballpark.
Next listen in stereo. With any luck, you will hear a bit of a phantom center image. Flip the phase again to be sure you still have it the best way. Once it sounds good in mono and stereo, you are done. But if you were to look at it with a scope, it will probably still look a mess. Give up. If it sounds fine, it probably is.
In fact, sometimes to accentuate the left-right effect, I will actually delay one channel of the stereo pair by a few hundred samples in my DAW. This purposely destroys the stereo image, making the spacing from left to right seem very wide. Think of it as the bastard child of stereo miking and tight double-tracking. It isn't necessarily a natural sound, but it can often help phase issues and sometimes makes the track hold its place better in a mix.
Leakage
With more than one player in the room, leakage is inevitable. A little bit can help keep things sounding cohesive. But drums next to the piano will bleed too much into the piano mics.
Standard procedure is to stuff mics inside the piano, shut the lid, and use as many moving blankets as you can afford. This will help some. A highpass filter on your mic or preamp can deal with some of the kick drum, but the hi-hat could be enough trouble to make you move the drum kit further away and use baffles or gobos, although they begin to defeat the benefit of recording together in the first place.
With all the sound bouncing around inside the closed box, it may sound muddy, muffled, and boxy. This makes mic choice and placement within a closed piano particularly important.
Unfortunately there is no magic formula for where to stick piano mics. The sound of a piano is too complex. I recommend making a series of test recordings with the mics in different spots to better evaluate how the sound changes from place to place. Use the positions below as a point of departure.
Mic positions—the best seat in the house
Every piano is different. Suggestions for mic positioning are just that—suggestions. Walk around the open instrument while someone is playing, cover up one ear and let the open ear guide you as to where a mic should go. Then make test recordings and evaluate them. Factor this into your time budget—if you don't, you are relying on luck.
For example, on my piano, the best seat in the house is, well, the seat. Even with the lid down, there is a beautifully balanced stereo image right where my ears are while I am playing; not too hyped, percussive or unnaturally close sounding but still not distant.
An XY pair of small-diaphragm condensers about a foot over the player's head, pointing down but not directly at the keys, reveals a great jazz tone. An omni mic a little closer, or a figure-eight, gives the added benefit of allowing you to record a piano/vocalist once you get the balance right. Be careful about player noise such as creaky benches, grunting players, and people with long clicking fingernails. And if leakage from another instrument in the room is to be an issue, then, well, as we say in NYC, fuhgetubattit!
Other sweet spots
There are often a few sweet spots to be found, despite the crazy bouncing around of sound inside the piano. For example, on a well designed Grand piano, there is often a wonderful place at the tail, just about where the back leg is, or often just outside the case. Here, the various registers tend to project in a surprisingly uniform manner. This is a great spot to place a single mic for a well-balanced mono recording.
For this technique, try a large-diaphragm condenser to capture a large full sound from the instrument. This is also a good mic choice outside the piano case because this mic position won't be adversely affected by the off-axis coloration that is often present in many large-diaphragm mics.
A ribbon mic could work well here, too, typically capturing a good deal of room tone from its rear lobe. Another option is an XY pair of small-diaphragm condensers in this same location, although it won't give you the pronounced stereo image that you may be accustomed to; but you may get a natural, balanced and true stereo image if your piano projects here the way many do.
A happy medium is an M-S pair. In some ways this is the best of both worlds, capturing the on-axis mono signal along with the side mic which allows you to adjust the stereo width to taste. But again, if isolation from other instruments in the same room is mission-critical, this would not be my first choice because the mics are outside (or almost outside) the piano.
The missionary position
Two cardioid mics directly over the hammers, pointing down, one for the bass strings, one for the treble, is probably the most common setup that I observe, but it's not my personal favorite for most styles. It can work well for percussive styles such as rock and gospel because of the proximity to the hammers, but watch out for that hole in the middle” of the frequency range which can be a result of close-miking the top and bottom of the range.
The problem may start to go away as the lid is closed (due the many reflections inside of a piano). But these reflections can also be detrimental. A benefit of this technique, however, is that it allows the lid to be placed on the half stick” or, depending on your mic, perhaps even fully closed. With a bunch of blankets, you can get significant isolation, although you will invariably have to dial in some general tone fixes with a good eq to make up for the boxy and muffled sound of the fully enclosed piano. For this setup, check out Slider's Piano Barre (reviewed March 2000), as it can really help with positioning.
Off with your head
A variation of this position involves actually removing the lid of the piano and lifting the mics higher off the strings. This can solve some of the problems inherent with the missionary position.” Removing the lid isn't hard to do, but you will want an extra set of strong arms to make sure you don't hurt the piano or yourself. Pull out the small pins that are set into the hinges that hold the lid in place, and carefully pull the lid off, taking care not to bend the hinges.
Once this is done, you can hang the mics directly over the strings at any height. Remember that the lid is an integral part of the way a piano projects its sound, so this may or may not work for your needs. But this technique often results in a bright, nicely separated and well-balanced piano sound. Try different kinds of mics. Small-diaphragm condensers are a safe pick but if you have a good sounding room, try spaced omnis three or four feet off the strings.
Down the hatch
A lot of people like to stuff mics in and over the metal holes that cover the sound board. I suspect that there are more people that do it that way than pianos that sound good that way.
But there is an exception to every rule.
Sometimes I find this can work as a supplemental mic in setups that use more than two mics. Contrary to what you may have been told, these holes are not where the sound comes out.” But they do tend to focus certain frequencies. Sometimes it's a good place to catch an extra bit of zing,” sometimes it is just resonant and peaky. But people swear by this method so I include it, assuming there are instruments that really sound good this way.
One exception is that a dynamic mic or two (think SM58) can really capture a vintage piano-bar type sound. I suggest a fishbowl placed on top of the piano, as resonance from a glass full of dollar bills is requisite for authenticity.
Boundary mics
Another popular miking technique involves a pair of PZMs placed either along opposite side rails of the piano, pointing in toward the strings, or taped to the lid pointing down. A boundary mic is basically like one half of an omni mic, and because it sits at the far extremity of the piano, it is not subject to reflections from the rear. As is the case with a pair of spaced omnis, the stereo image really depends on how far the mics are spaced apart.
If your piano doesn't happen to sound good at its edges you are out of luck. But if it does, and you can adjust the placement to ensure good phase relationships, you might really like this sound.
Spaced pair” ORTF
Another option, and one of my favorites, is a sort of modified ORTF array. Two cardioids spaced a foot or two apart are placed at or around the unhinged side opening of a grand piano.
The mic closer to the keyboard can be thought of as a treble mic, the other as a bass. In practice, however, what you will most likely be getting is the full balanced sound from the mic near the back of the piano (remember that sweet spot I mentioned) mixed with a slightly more percussive sound from the treble” mic which is closer to the hammers.
The two mics are spaced far enough so that a rich stereo panned effect will be evident, but given their orientation, the phase issues should not be overwhelming. Another benefit of this position is that it will allow you to freely adjust the lid opening to taste: wide for a clearer sound, half stick for a lot more reflection, and there's even the possibility of blanketing the piano to reduce track bleed from other instruments. With an apparatus such as Slider's Piano Barre, you can even close the lid all the way if you have mics that can fit deeper inside. Another benefit of this technique is that, with the exception of an XY pair, it is the best way I have found to capture a true stereo” recording.
This position is a good starting point for classical recordings. With classical music, you typically don't want so much of the sound of the hammers and the inside of the case. The air around the instrument and the tone of the room is paramount. A spaced ORTF pair can be pulled away from the piano a couple of feet (or to taste) to excellent effect.
Another benefit of this setup is that you can be flexible in your choice of mics. While ORTF generally favors a small-diaphragm condenser, I find that sometimes a large-diaphragm pair can help to capture a more broad-shouldered sound. The rear of the mic will be pointing outside the piano (or in some instances the entire mic is outside), which makes the slower response and off-axis coloration, so typical of most large diaphragm condensers, less of an issue.
Many engineers favor an AKG C 12 in this application, but there is really a world of choices these days. Consider ribbons too! One of my favorites is the Beyer M160 because of its unique cardioid pickup pattern. Traditional figure-eight ribbons can also be used here (you might even substitute a Blumlein pair—see Robert Auld's review of the Royer Labs SF-24 in this issue) when the room sound is an asset; one lobe picks up the piano, the other gets the room.
Everything else
You can mix and match the abovementioned techniques to accentuate different aspects of an instrument. I have found that mixing microphone types and placements can sometimes catch elusive qualities that stereo and pseudo-stereo miking can't achieve. For example, you might want to use two different kinds of mics on the hammers. This can start to break down the stereo image, making the piano's width seem wider, like a cousin of the channel-delay technique I mentioned earlier.
Another valid technique involves using more than two mics. Perhaps the standard, over-the-hammer position works well but there might be a sound hole, where the very high frequencies seem to congregate. (My piano has one that seems to focus all the really high stuff, i.e. 10 kHz and above.) A supplemental mic here may be mixed in to capture this.
Watch out for phase problems and keep the relative distance between mics and the piano in mind when adding mics. The old three-to-one rule” states that the distance between any two mics must be at least three times the distance between the mics and the source to avoid phase problems, but it's a bit more complex than that: see John Shirley's ‘Compleat Recording Musician' on the subject in the October 2004 issue. To make your life a little easier, it might also be worthwhile to eq the stuff you don't need (in my case, everything below 6 kHz) out of the extra mic's track.
Keep in mind that reflections from the case and the lid will be intense here, so choose a mic with good off-axis response and attenuation I use an Electro-Voice RE20, which works well because of its slower response time, excellent rejection and bass response, and unpronounced proximity effect. For whatever reason, however, I have also had good luck with nearly the polar opposite: an AKG C414B-TLII (a predecessor of the C414B-XLII reviewed by Paul Stamler in this issue). Go figure.
Either way, supplement this mic with another one in the treble register, somewhere where you are going to catch that high end and punch that the other mic will miss. I would usually reach for a small-diaphragm condenser. Pan them hard left and right and see how you like it.
Don't forget to have fun
I hope this wide selection of suggestions gets you started and helps you avoid some of the cliches and pitfalls that novices can encounter when recording this big, beautiful, complex instrument. Just remember: if it sounds good, it is good.
I started recording pianos before recording anything else, probably because I am a pianist. It is a notoriously difficult instrument to record, so when the editors of Recording asked me to write about miking acoustic pianos, I began by asking myself What if I had known then what I know now?”
What's the trouble?
The piano is a complicated contraption consisting of up to 7000 discrete parts. Hundreds of strings resonate sympathetically and then project in unpredictable directions. Challenges include reflections within the case, tuning, leakage from other instruments, and the sheer fact that no two pianos sound exactly alike. Then there's the wide range of pitches, from the lowest A (beneath the lowest E on a bass) to the highest C (which is also the highest note on the piccolo)—your mics have to be able to capture the full spectrum.
Finally, the sheer size of the Grand with its expanse of strings and the two-position lid calls for placement experimentation—too close and you might not capture the full range and miss out on the room sound, too far and you may get less definition and more room than is desirable.
Tone, tuning, placement
Every instrument has registers and dynamics where it sounds the best. Listen, enlist the help of the player or arranger, and get the best result from the instrument and the part. It pays to be flexible.
Piano tuning is an art, not a science. No two tunings sound exactly alike but they can all pretty noticeably change the character of an instrument. Discuss your requirements with all parties involved; a skilled piano tuner can help greatly.
Just because it's big and heavy doesn't mean you shouldn't move the Grand to the location where it sounds best in the room. Moving it gently shouldn't affect the tuning, and finding the right spot will have a profound effect on the piano's tone. Then look for the most balanced sound, in the sense that all notes from high to low have a similar sound, without any notes or note clusters sticking out more prominently than others.
Stereo—what stereo?
Piano lends itself nicely to stereo recording where two signals are split, traditionally with bass on the left and treble on the right which is the way the pianist hears it. This does not restrict you to orthodox, phase-coherent stereo techniques designed to create a strong center image. In fact, many of the techniques that follow will result in a very wide image that may not resolve perfectly to mono. Live with it.
You need to keep an eye and ear out for phase problems, whether you multi-mike and pan or record in true stereo using something like an XY technique. With all the sound bouncing around inside the case of a piano, there can be a lot of stuff out of phase. But before you use the meter, use your ears.
First, sum the mics to mono and note how the sound changes. If you lose a lot of bass or you hear some weird kind of filtering in the midrange, try switching the phase on one mic, or try moving it. A little repositioning goes a long way, and this may be enough to get things into the ballpark.
Next listen in stereo. With any luck, you will hear a bit of a phantom center image. Flip the phase again to be sure you still have it the best way. Once it sounds good in mono and stereo, you are done. But if you were to look at it with a scope, it will probably still look a mess. Give up. If it sounds fine, it probably is.
In fact, sometimes to accentuate the left-right effect, I will actually delay one channel of the stereo pair by a few hundred samples in my DAW. This purposely destroys the stereo image, making the spacing from left to right seem very wide. Think of it as the bastard child of stereo miking and tight double-tracking. It isn't necessarily a natural sound, but it can often help phase issues and sometimes makes the track hold its place better in a mix.
Leakage
With more than one player in the room, leakage is inevitable. A little bit can help keep things sounding cohesive. But drums next to the piano will bleed too much into the piano mics.
Standard procedure is to stuff mics inside the piano, shut the lid, and use as many moving blankets as you can afford. This will help some. A highpass filter on your mic or preamp can deal with some of the kick drum, but the hi-hat could be enough trouble to make you move the drum kit further away and use baffles or gobos, although they begin to defeat the benefit of recording together in the first place.
With all the sound bouncing around inside the closed box, it may sound muddy, muffled, and boxy. This makes mic choice and placement within a closed piano particularly important.
Unfortunately there is no magic formula for where to stick piano mics. The sound of a piano is too complex. I recommend making a series of test recordings with the mics in different spots to better evaluate how the sound changes from place to place. Use the positions below as a point of departure.
Mic positions—the best seat in the house
Every piano is different. Suggestions for mic positioning are just that—suggestions. Walk around the open instrument while someone is playing, cover up one ear and let the open ear guide you as to where a mic should go. Then make test recordings and evaluate them. Factor this into your time budget—if you don't, you are relying on luck.
For example, on my piano, the best seat in the house is, well, the seat. Even with the lid down, there is a beautifully balanced stereo image right where my ears are while I am playing; not too hyped, percussive or unnaturally close sounding but still not distant.
An XY pair of small-diaphragm condensers about a foot over the player's head, pointing down but not directly at the keys, reveals a great jazz tone. An omni mic a little closer, or a figure-eight, gives the added benefit of allowing you to record a piano/vocalist once you get the balance right. Be careful about player noise such as creaky benches, grunting players, and people with long clicking fingernails. And if leakage from another instrument in the room is to be an issue, then, well, as we say in NYC, fuhgetubattit!
Other sweet spots
There are often a few sweet spots to be found, despite the crazy bouncing around of sound inside the piano. For example, on a well designed Grand piano, there is often a wonderful place at the tail, just about where the back leg is, or often just outside the case. Here, the various registers tend to project in a surprisingly uniform manner. This is a great spot to place a single mic for a well-balanced mono recording.
For this technique, try a large-diaphragm condenser to capture a large full sound from the instrument. This is also a good mic choice outside the piano case because this mic position won't be adversely affected by the off-axis coloration that is often present in many large-diaphragm mics.
A ribbon mic could work well here, too, typically capturing a good deal of room tone from its rear lobe. Another option is an XY pair of small-diaphragm condensers in this same location, although it won't give you the pronounced stereo image that you may be accustomed to; but you may get a natural, balanced and true stereo image if your piano projects here the way many do.
A happy medium is an M-S pair. In some ways this is the best of both worlds, capturing the on-axis mono signal along with the side mic which allows you to adjust the stereo width to taste. But again, if isolation from other instruments in the same room is mission-critical, this would not be my first choice because the mics are outside (or almost outside) the piano.
The missionary position
Two cardioid mics directly over the hammers, pointing down, one for the bass strings, one for the treble, is probably the most common setup that I observe, but it's not my personal favorite for most styles. It can work well for percussive styles such as rock and gospel because of the proximity to the hammers, but watch out for that hole in the middle” of the frequency range which can be a result of close-miking the top and bottom of the range.
The problem may start to go away as the lid is closed (due the many reflections inside of a piano). But these reflections can also be detrimental. A benefit of this technique, however, is that it allows the lid to be placed on the half stick” or, depending on your mic, perhaps even fully closed. With a bunch of blankets, you can get significant isolation, although you will invariably have to dial in some general tone fixes with a good eq to make up for the boxy and muffled sound of the fully enclosed piano. For this setup, check out Slider's Piano Barre (reviewed March 2000), as it can really help with positioning.
Off with your head
A variation of this position involves actually removing the lid of the piano and lifting the mics higher off the strings. This can solve some of the problems inherent with the missionary position.” Removing the lid isn't hard to do, but you will want an extra set of strong arms to make sure you don't hurt the piano or yourself. Pull out the small pins that are set into the hinges that hold the lid in place, and carefully pull the lid off, taking care not to bend the hinges.
Once this is done, you can hang the mics directly over the strings at any height. Remember that the lid is an integral part of the way a piano projects its sound, so this may or may not work for your needs. But this technique often results in a bright, nicely separated and well-balanced piano sound. Try different kinds of mics. Small-diaphragm condensers are a safe pick but if you have a good sounding room, try spaced omnis three or four feet off the strings.
Down the hatch
A lot of people like to stuff mics in and over the metal holes that cover the sound board. I suspect that there are more people that do it that way than pianos that sound good that way.
But there is an exception to every rule.
Sometimes I find this can work as a supplemental mic in setups that use more than two mics. Contrary to what you may have been told, these holes are not where the sound comes out.” But they do tend to focus certain frequencies. Sometimes it's a good place to catch an extra bit of zing,” sometimes it is just resonant and peaky. But people swear by this method so I include it, assuming there are instruments that really sound good this way.
One exception is that a dynamic mic or two (think SM58) can really capture a vintage piano-bar type sound. I suggest a fishbowl placed on top of the piano, as resonance from a glass full of dollar bills is requisite for authenticity.
Boundary mics
Another popular miking technique involves a pair of PZMs placed either along opposite side rails of the piano, pointing in toward the strings, or taped to the lid pointing down. A boundary mic is basically like one half of an omni mic, and because it sits at the far extremity of the piano, it is not subject to reflections from the rear. As is the case with a pair of spaced omnis, the stereo image really depends on how far the mics are spaced apart.
If your piano doesn't happen to sound good at its edges you are out of luck. But if it does, and you can adjust the placement to ensure good phase relationships, you might really like this sound.
Spaced pair” ORTF
Another option, and one of my favorites, is a sort of modified ORTF array. Two cardioids spaced a foot or two apart are placed at or around the unhinged side opening of a grand piano.
The mic closer to the keyboard can be thought of as a treble mic, the other as a bass. In practice, however, what you will most likely be getting is the full balanced sound from the mic near the back of the piano (remember that sweet spot I mentioned) mixed with a slightly more percussive sound from the treble” mic which is closer to the hammers.
The two mics are spaced far enough so that a rich stereo panned effect will be evident, but given their orientation, the phase issues should not be overwhelming. Another benefit of this position is that it will allow you to freely adjust the lid opening to taste: wide for a clearer sound, half stick for a lot more reflection, and there's even the possibility of blanketing the piano to reduce track bleed from other instruments. With an apparatus such as Slider's Piano Barre, you can even close the lid all the way if you have mics that can fit deeper inside. Another benefit of this technique is that, with the exception of an XY pair, it is the best way I have found to capture a true stereo” recording.
This position is a good starting point for classical recordings. With classical music, you typically don't want so much of the sound of the hammers and the inside of the case. The air around the instrument and the tone of the room is paramount. A spaced ORTF pair can be pulled away from the piano a couple of feet (or to taste) to excellent effect.
Another benefit of this setup is that you can be flexible in your choice of mics. While ORTF generally favors a small-diaphragm condenser, I find that sometimes a large-diaphragm pair can help to capture a more broad-shouldered sound. The rear of the mic will be pointing outside the piano (or in some instances the entire mic is outside), which makes the slower response and off-axis coloration, so typical of most large diaphragm condensers, less of an issue.
Many engineers favor an AKG C 12 in this application, but there is really a world of choices these days. Consider ribbons too! One of my favorites is the Beyer M160 because of its unique cardioid pickup pattern. Traditional figure-eight ribbons can also be used here (you might even substitute a Blumlein pair—see Robert Auld's review of the Royer Labs SF-24 in this issue) when the room sound is an asset; one lobe picks up the piano, the other gets the room.
Everything else
You can mix and match the abovementioned techniques to accentuate different aspects of an instrument. I have found that mixing microphone types and placements can sometimes catch elusive qualities that stereo and pseudo-stereo miking can't achieve. For example, you might want to use two different kinds of mics on the hammers. This can start to break down the stereo image, making the piano's width seem wider, like a cousin of the channel-delay technique I mentioned earlier.
Another valid technique involves using more than two mics. Perhaps the standard, over-the-hammer position works well but there might be a sound hole, where the very high frequencies seem to congregate. (My piano has one that seems to focus all the really high stuff, i.e. 10 kHz and above.) A supplemental mic here may be mixed in to capture this.
Watch out for phase problems and keep the relative distance between mics and the piano in mind when adding mics. The old three-to-one rule” states that the distance between any two mics must be at least three times the distance between the mics and the source to avoid phase problems, but it's a bit more complex than that: see John Shirley's ‘Compleat Recording Musician' on the subject in the October 2004 issue. To make your life a little easier, it might also be worthwhile to eq the stuff you don't need (in my case, everything below 6 kHz) out of the extra mic's track.
Keep in mind that reflections from the case and the lid will be intense here, so choose a mic with good off-axis response and attenuation I use an Electro-Voice RE20, which works well because of its slower response time, excellent rejection and bass response, and unpronounced proximity effect. For whatever reason, however, I have also had good luck with nearly the polar opposite: an AKG C414B-TLII (a predecessor of the C414B-XLII reviewed by Paul Stamler in this issue). Go figure.
Either way, supplement this mic with another one in the treble register, somewhere where you are going to catch that high end and punch that the other mic will miss. I would usually reach for a small-diaphragm condenser. Pan them hard left and right and see how you like it.
Don't forget to have fun
I hope this wide selection of suggestions gets you started and helps you avoid some of the cliches and pitfalls that novices can encounter when recording this big, beautiful, complex instrument. Just remember: if it sounds good, it is good.
Thursday, 28 July 2016
6 Stereo Miking Techniques You Can Use Today
Twice a month we revisit some of our reader favorite posts from throughout the history of Audiotuts+. This tutorial was first published in August 2008.
Stereo miking is a great way to increase the sense of depth in your recording of an instrument. Here are six stereo miking techniques you can try out today. We'll start with the basics and then move to some more exciting options.
Before You Get Started
One thing to be careful of in stereo recording is phase cancellation. When using a spaced pair this can be a concern. Phase cancellation occurs when two versions of the same sound, which occur at slightly different times, are mixed together. The result is that when one signal is going into positive amplitude and the other is going into negative amplitude they will cancel each other out and when they are both going the same way they will boost each other.
When two signals are out of phase you will notice a warble in your sound or, if the two signals are 180 degrees out of phase, you will get silence. You will not notice this when the two signals are panned hard left and right. So, to avoid any surprises always check in mono.
The way to minimize your chance of running into phase problems is to use coincident pairs (where the two mics are very close together) or to use the 3:1 rule (place the mics 3 times as far from each other as they are from the sound source).
Spaced Pair
Spaced pair miking is exactly what the name implies. Two cardioid microphones are placed apart from each other to produce two different recordings of the same instrument. I suggest trying two places on the instrument that produce different tonalities. For example, on a guitar you may want to have one mic on the bridge and one on the nut.
X-Y
The X-Y configuration takes two cardioid microphones and places them with heads together at 90 degree angles. The result is that the mic on the left will pickup the right side of the room and the mic on the right will pickup the left side of the room.
Blumlein Pair
The Blumlein Pair is much like the X-Y technique with one variation. Two bi-directional mics are used at 90 degree angles. The result of this technique is that one mic will pickup the front left and back right of the room while the other picks up the front right and back left of the room. This technique is best if you have a nice sounding room to record in.
ORTF
The ORTF technique is named after the French television and radio commission who invented it (Office de Radiodiffusion-Télévision Française). This is a binaural mic technique which means it is meant to approximate the response of your two ears. In the ORTF technique two cardioid mics are placed at an angle of 110 degrees with the heads 17cm (7”) apart. The beauty of this technique is that mic placement can be as simple as moving around the room until it sounds good and then placing the mics where your head was.
Mid-side
In this technique a cardioid mic is placed facing the sound source and a bi-directional mic is placed perpendicular to the cardioid mic (so it is picking up the sides of the room). They are each recorded onto one track. The track with the bidirectional microphone is then copied and the phase is inverted on the copy. The two bi-directional tracks are then panned hard left and right while the cardioid mic is panned center. By adjusting the relative volume of the cardioid mic we can control how close or far away the recorded instrument sounds.
Note: This technique only works in stereo. If this is played back in mono the two bi-directional tracks will cancel each other out.
Decca Tree
The Decca Tree is used mainly for recording orchestras and large ensembles. It was developed in the 1950s by engineers at Decca Records. The Decca Tree uses a special T-shaped mic stand suspended above the conductor's head. On the T-shaped stand are 3 cardioid microphones facing left, right and centre which are then panned to match their configuration.
There are no fixed measurements for the distance between the microphones but the standard seems to be around 5-7 feet. The mics are usually placed closer together for smaller orchestras and further apart for larger ones.
Stereo miking is a great way to increase the sense of depth in your recording of an instrument. Here are six stereo miking techniques you can try out today. We'll start with the basics and then move to some more exciting options.
Before You Get Started
One thing to be careful of in stereo recording is phase cancellation. When using a spaced pair this can be a concern. Phase cancellation occurs when two versions of the same sound, which occur at slightly different times, are mixed together. The result is that when one signal is going into positive amplitude and the other is going into negative amplitude they will cancel each other out and when they are both going the same way they will boost each other.
When two signals are out of phase you will notice a warble in your sound or, if the two signals are 180 degrees out of phase, you will get silence. You will not notice this when the two signals are panned hard left and right. So, to avoid any surprises always check in mono.
The way to minimize your chance of running into phase problems is to use coincident pairs (where the two mics are very close together) or to use the 3:1 rule (place the mics 3 times as far from each other as they are from the sound source).
Spaced Pair
Spaced pair miking is exactly what the name implies. Two cardioid microphones are placed apart from each other to produce two different recordings of the same instrument. I suggest trying two places on the instrument that produce different tonalities. For example, on a guitar you may want to have one mic on the bridge and one on the nut.
X-Y
The X-Y configuration takes two cardioid microphones and places them with heads together at 90 degree angles. The result is that the mic on the left will pickup the right side of the room and the mic on the right will pickup the left side of the room.
Blumlein Pair
The Blumlein Pair is much like the X-Y technique with one variation. Two bi-directional mics are used at 90 degree angles. The result of this technique is that one mic will pickup the front left and back right of the room while the other picks up the front right and back left of the room. This technique is best if you have a nice sounding room to record in.
ORTF
The ORTF technique is named after the French television and radio commission who invented it (Office de Radiodiffusion-Télévision Française). This is a binaural mic technique which means it is meant to approximate the response of your two ears. In the ORTF technique two cardioid mics are placed at an angle of 110 degrees with the heads 17cm (7”) apart. The beauty of this technique is that mic placement can be as simple as moving around the room until it sounds good and then placing the mics where your head was.
Mid-side
In this technique a cardioid mic is placed facing the sound source and a bi-directional mic is placed perpendicular to the cardioid mic (so it is picking up the sides of the room). They are each recorded onto one track. The track with the bidirectional microphone is then copied and the phase is inverted on the copy. The two bi-directional tracks are then panned hard left and right while the cardioid mic is panned center. By adjusting the relative volume of the cardioid mic we can control how close or far away the recorded instrument sounds.
Note: This technique only works in stereo. If this is played back in mono the two bi-directional tracks will cancel each other out.
Decca Tree
The Decca Tree is used mainly for recording orchestras and large ensembles. It was developed in the 1950s by engineers at Decca Records. The Decca Tree uses a special T-shaped mic stand suspended above the conductor's head. On the T-shaped stand are 3 cardioid microphones facing left, right and centre which are then panned to match their configuration.
There are no fixed measurements for the distance between the microphones but the standard seems to be around 5-7 feet. The mics are usually placed closer together for smaller orchestras and further apart for larger ones.
Friday, 15 July 2016
Minimalist Drum Miking Techniques
Minimalist Drum Miking Techniques
By Jake Wood
Hi, my name is Jake, and I'm a recovering mike-aholic. Back when I was a junky I'd do anything to get my next mix. I was fading fast, isolating my loved ones, all to stop the bleed. Every quarter-inch went to more microphones, and I was one Neumann away from becoming homeless, hanging by an XLR. Thankfully, I eventually saw the sine, and ever since I've had a clean track of one to four microphones per session. I'll never forget my past, and for that, everyday still Hertz.
The Alternative Approach
While standard professional drum-recording scenarios involve at least eight or nine microphones, history has colorfully proven that quite the contrary can also be just as kosher. It is in fact very possible to get great-sounding drum tracks with only a few choice microphones, and there's still a respectable place in the recording market for minimalist drum-tracking techniques.
Minimalism wasn't an edgy alternative back in the 1960's when the art of recording drums began to take shape - it was the norm. With the four-track recorder as the standard medium of the time, it limited engineers to very few microphones on the drums. Bands like The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, The Dave Brubeck Quartet, and John Coltrane typically used one to four microphones on a kit, depending on the album and the year it was made. Eddie Kramer, for instance, the engineer on Jimi Hendrixs' Are You Experienced (and the engineer for many other ground-breaking albums), was forced to track Mitch Mitchell's monumental drum performances in mono!
Another song of the time that was captured with a minimalist technique, Led Zeppelin's When The Levee Breaks,” contains one of the single most significant and easily identifiable drum mixes in history, yet it was tracked with only two microphones. The engineer on that track, Andy Johns, brother of Engineer Glyn Johns, is greatly responsible for this definitive Bonham sound.
While in a large house, Johns recorded Bonham with two M160 double-ribbon microphones placed approximately halfway up a stairwell in the foyer, compressed to all hell, and affected with a Binson Echorec delay. According to Johns, it was the first time Bonham was actually happy with the drum tones (and rightfully so. They sound huge!). And yet as epic as that drum mix is, do the drums sound perfect? Would that tone work for just any song? Not a chance. The track is muddied with grit; it's fairly monophonic; and of course, he's John Bonham and you aren't.
Make no mistake; minimalist drum-recording setups are not the answer for every situation. As rich as they can sound, their natural yet lively chaotic ambience simply won't work for every song or band. Additionally, trying to replicate certain drum sounds from favorite recordings, like a Metallica album, for instance, won't work, as they were crafted from many close mikes and samples. That said, here are some suggested steps, setups, and treatments to make the most out of a minimalist recording setup.
Real Estate
Prior to plugging anything in, the most important thing to do first is figure out where in the room the drums sound best. While the idea of moving drums around isn't a holiday for most, enjoying the subtle differences of playing in various areas of a room can really affect a performance, and will certainly affect how the drums sound. To maximize the open” sound (assuming the ceiling is angled), place the drums under the tallest point for the most reverb. Just remember that every room has a character of its own, and different locations will greatly change the gestalt of the drums, particularly the kick and toms.
Make A New Plan, Stan
Having an artistic plan instead of a let's see what comes out in the wash” attitude is a smarter approach to saving time in the mixing room. Surprisingly, many engineers, both amateur and professional, don't always have a planned outcome. San Francisco mastering engineer Michael Romanowski (Dredg, Badfinger, Super Adventure Club), a regular practitioner of minimalist drum miking, is always amazed at how people will plug in a lot of microphones and not know what they are going for, noting that paying attention from the start makes mixing super easy and with little to no fixes. A lot of people just throw mikes up and say, 'We'll fix it in the mix.'” Well, why bother repairing if it's possible to get it right from the downbeat? The following approaches have differing results, and hopefully their descriptions, along with experimentation, will galvanize and expedite your next recording session.
One Mike? Done
Starting with the simplest setup possible, it doesn't get much easier than a one-mike operation. Although sonically limiting and leaving a little something to be desired, the one-mike strategy can be just what the doctor ordered, if given the right drummer and the right song. Ribbon and condenser microphones are the best candidates for the leading role in this one-mike show, with condensers typically being more sensitive to higher frequencies (this can be both good and bad, as they are brighter, but can also be on the brittle side).
The three best locations for this rather important piece are as a room mike, a drummer's perspective mike, and a front-of-kit mike. The room position (a minimum of 10' from the kit) has the most ambience and sounds farthest away. The front-of-kit (approximately 2' back from the kick and 4' up), meanwhile, is the punchiest. But the drummer's-perspective position might just be the most realistic. This author's personal favorite is the front-of-kit position because it captures everything, especially a strong kick (much stronger than the drummer's perspective).
Also keep in mind that the one-mike method is married to a certain natural, harmonically chaotic vibe. Because this isn't a pristine controlled recording situation (it's the exact opposite of the close-miked Steely Dan tones), it's only recommended for folks that can go with the flow and embrace the dirt.
Skeptical? Who wouldn't be? Yours truly was only so lucky to stumble upon this method during a late-night epiphany fueled by spontaneity, impatience, a lack of preparation, and a need to record immediately. Check out this free download of Smoke Signals,” a tune recorded on a jazz kit with only an iPhone and its internal microphone (disclosure: there's also a programmed kick on the downbeats):
Two Timing
Because most entry-level audio interfaces come with only two XLR inputs, learning to milk two mikes is a very valuable money-saving skill. Looking at it as an efficient means of making a mountain out of an audio molehill, and not a limitation, a second mike with its own separate track can really add just enough sonic control to salt a mix and bring out some real flavor. The two main positioning strategies to maximizing auditory potential are either with both microphones as distant-mikes, or with one as a distant-mike and the other as a close-mike. Both can sound great, but there's an interesting balance of power between the two methods. With two distant mikes, it's possible to get more of a stereo image of the kit.
With one distant and one close-mike, stereo imaging is stymied, but there's more control over the tone of a specific drum. Here are two excellent means to recording with only a pair of microphones:
Front-Of-Kit And Snare Mike
The front-of-kit mike (again, about 2' back from the kick and 4' high) is like the Swiss Army Knife of mike placement (minus the worthless toothpick). With a large-diaphragm condenser at the helm, it pretty much has every drum covered. The drums sound active and lively, and even the kick comes in surprisingly nice and strong. That said, sometimes there's a little meat missing from the snare. With the addition of a dynamic mike (Shure's SM57 is the standard, placed approximately 1" away from the head and rim, pointed at the center of the snare), it's possible to fatten up and focus in on a closer” snare tone. The major downsides to this format are that the cymbals can easily overwhelm the front-of-kit mike (which is 85 percent of the mix), and that stereo imaging is limited and awkward.
The two best steps to avoiding cymbal overload are to simply play the cymbals quieter and to use the duller high-end pickup pattern of a ribbon mike instead of a condenser. Check out Steve Zissou's Underwater Party,” a two-mike production, with an Audio-Technica 4033a condenser at the front of kit and an SM57 on the snare:
Drummer's Perspective And Kick Mike
The drummer's perspective mike (placed relatively close to the drummer's head, but not so close as to catch any teased hair head-banging) sounds very similar to the front-of-kit position, except that there's a little more of the high-end stick attack and a lot less kick drum. The kick mike, placed about halfway inside the drum (for instance Shure's Beta 52A or AKG's D 112), and pointing a little off center, is added as a precautionary inoculation of an extra chest-thumping 50Hz boost and a 2—5kHz clicking attack.
Three's Company. So Who Invited Four And Five?
While options increase greatly as more mikes become involved, the basic capturing concepts of distant and close mikes still work for most setups involving anywhere from three to five microphones. If budget and time allow, these variations can really lead to outstandingly large and live results. Here are but a few of the many variations that can be implemented.
180 Degrees
A common practice with 1960's and '70s rock and jazz is the three-microphone triangular approach. While stubborn opinions abound on what's the best way to configure the traditional triumvirate, the basic format is a front-of-kit mike, a hi-hat side overhead, and a floor tom overhead (somewhat near the drummer's right shoulder). The distances of all of these mikes from the kit is directly proportional to how close and open the drums sound, and with no close mikes to reign it back in, it's important to evaluate an appropriate balance.
The height of the overheads (anywhere from 30"—60" from the snare) should be positioned with consideration to the height of the ceiling, the distance between drums and cymbals, and the drummer's sensitivity to dynamics.
Because there are two overheads involved, phase cancellation becomes a serious concern. Break out the measuring tape and adjust the overheads so they are equidistant from the snare. Note, however, this method only prevents the snare from being out of phase, and any other drum or cymbal may still be somewhat phase-y.
To counteract this, some engineers prefer to measure from the imaginary center” of the kit. Unlike the previous setups, the two overheads allow for a beautiful panning job, making the drums sound cohesively wide. Not surprisingly, someone in the microphone business finally took note and made a mike kit just for the triple-threat vintage approach. Blue Microphone's new Pro Drum Kit Kit” is a three-piece suit, tailored with two cardioid-condenser Dragonflys and one large-diaphragm-condenser Mouse to capture phenomenally realistic reproductions of all elements of the kit, from the sparkling highs and warm mids to the thumping lows and sharp attack normally delegated to a kick mike. Similarly, Earthworks has a three-piece mike set (it's actually just three SR25 cardioid condensers) with two overheads and one kick.
The other popular minimalist strategy, sometimes referred to as the Glyn Johns technique,” involves a mixture of four to five distant and close mikes. With two overheads, one near the hi-hat, the other near the floor tom and right shoulder, a kick, a snare, and occasionally a room mike, the arsenal is more than enough to capture well-rounded drum tones that don't suffer from being too roomy or too controlled.
A few other basic starting blocks for various scenarios are to have the overheads in XY position (angled at 90 degrees from each other), two drummer's perspective mikes (one near each shoulder, using the head as a baffle, and from here on out referred to as double parrot”), or to have a stereo pair as room mikes. All have a character of their own, and experimentation is the best way to learn about them.
A Note About Overheads
If the ceiling is low, it's best to work with cardioid condensers, as ribbons by nature work as figure-8 pickup patterns and will catch a lot of unwanted reflections from the ceiling. If the ceiling is more than 8' tall, try out some omni mikes. And if the drummer is tracking with the band in the same room, switch them out with hypercardioid condensers for the most isolation possible.
Drumming Strategies
Getting a good drum mix isn't only up to the engineer, as the drummer plays an even more critical role. The less microphones used puts that much more responsibility on a solid, balanced drum take, as it's less possible to polish an erratic and disjointed performance with studio magic. Wimpy snare cracks and pussyfooting tom rolls combined with overbearing trashy cymbals can be the death of the backbeat, and a minimalist setup can't resuscitate that kind of issue. Sensitivity and awareness are key, and drummers that learn to mix by playing have plenty more work in their future, so set up some mikes, mix from the sticks, and give the faders a rest.
By Jake Wood
Hi, my name is Jake, and I'm a recovering mike-aholic. Back when I was a junky I'd do anything to get my next mix. I was fading fast, isolating my loved ones, all to stop the bleed. Every quarter-inch went to more microphones, and I was one Neumann away from becoming homeless, hanging by an XLR. Thankfully, I eventually saw the sine, and ever since I've had a clean track of one to four microphones per session. I'll never forget my past, and for that, everyday still Hertz.
The Alternative Approach
While standard professional drum-recording scenarios involve at least eight or nine microphones, history has colorfully proven that quite the contrary can also be just as kosher. It is in fact very possible to get great-sounding drum tracks with only a few choice microphones, and there's still a respectable place in the recording market for minimalist drum-tracking techniques.
Minimalism wasn't an edgy alternative back in the 1960's when the art of recording drums began to take shape - it was the norm. With the four-track recorder as the standard medium of the time, it limited engineers to very few microphones on the drums. Bands like The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, The Dave Brubeck Quartet, and John Coltrane typically used one to four microphones on a kit, depending on the album and the year it was made. Eddie Kramer, for instance, the engineer on Jimi Hendrixs' Are You Experienced (and the engineer for many other ground-breaking albums), was forced to track Mitch Mitchell's monumental drum performances in mono!
Another song of the time that was captured with a minimalist technique, Led Zeppelin's When The Levee Breaks,” contains one of the single most significant and easily identifiable drum mixes in history, yet it was tracked with only two microphones. The engineer on that track, Andy Johns, brother of Engineer Glyn Johns, is greatly responsible for this definitive Bonham sound.
While in a large house, Johns recorded Bonham with two M160 double-ribbon microphones placed approximately halfway up a stairwell in the foyer, compressed to all hell, and affected with a Binson Echorec delay. According to Johns, it was the first time Bonham was actually happy with the drum tones (and rightfully so. They sound huge!). And yet as epic as that drum mix is, do the drums sound perfect? Would that tone work for just any song? Not a chance. The track is muddied with grit; it's fairly monophonic; and of course, he's John Bonham and you aren't.
Make no mistake; minimalist drum-recording setups are not the answer for every situation. As rich as they can sound, their natural yet lively chaotic ambience simply won't work for every song or band. Additionally, trying to replicate certain drum sounds from favorite recordings, like a Metallica album, for instance, won't work, as they were crafted from many close mikes and samples. That said, here are some suggested steps, setups, and treatments to make the most out of a minimalist recording setup.
Real Estate
Prior to plugging anything in, the most important thing to do first is figure out where in the room the drums sound best. While the idea of moving drums around isn't a holiday for most, enjoying the subtle differences of playing in various areas of a room can really affect a performance, and will certainly affect how the drums sound. To maximize the open” sound (assuming the ceiling is angled), place the drums under the tallest point for the most reverb. Just remember that every room has a character of its own, and different locations will greatly change the gestalt of the drums, particularly the kick and toms.
Make A New Plan, Stan
Having an artistic plan instead of a let's see what comes out in the wash” attitude is a smarter approach to saving time in the mixing room. Surprisingly, many engineers, both amateur and professional, don't always have a planned outcome. San Francisco mastering engineer Michael Romanowski (Dredg, Badfinger, Super Adventure Club), a regular practitioner of minimalist drum miking, is always amazed at how people will plug in a lot of microphones and not know what they are going for, noting that paying attention from the start makes mixing super easy and with little to no fixes. A lot of people just throw mikes up and say, 'We'll fix it in the mix.'” Well, why bother repairing if it's possible to get it right from the downbeat? The following approaches have differing results, and hopefully their descriptions, along with experimentation, will galvanize and expedite your next recording session.
One Mike? Done
Starting with the simplest setup possible, it doesn't get much easier than a one-mike operation. Although sonically limiting and leaving a little something to be desired, the one-mike strategy can be just what the doctor ordered, if given the right drummer and the right song. Ribbon and condenser microphones are the best candidates for the leading role in this one-mike show, with condensers typically being more sensitive to higher frequencies (this can be both good and bad, as they are brighter, but can also be on the brittle side).
The three best locations for this rather important piece are as a room mike, a drummer's perspective mike, and a front-of-kit mike. The room position (a minimum of 10' from the kit) has the most ambience and sounds farthest away. The front-of-kit (approximately 2' back from the kick and 4' up), meanwhile, is the punchiest. But the drummer's-perspective position might just be the most realistic. This author's personal favorite is the front-of-kit position because it captures everything, especially a strong kick (much stronger than the drummer's perspective).
Also keep in mind that the one-mike method is married to a certain natural, harmonically chaotic vibe. Because this isn't a pristine controlled recording situation (it's the exact opposite of the close-miked Steely Dan tones), it's only recommended for folks that can go with the flow and embrace the dirt.
Skeptical? Who wouldn't be? Yours truly was only so lucky to stumble upon this method during a late-night epiphany fueled by spontaneity, impatience, a lack of preparation, and a need to record immediately. Check out this free download of Smoke Signals,” a tune recorded on a jazz kit with only an iPhone and its internal microphone (disclosure: there's also a programmed kick on the downbeats):
Two Timing
Because most entry-level audio interfaces come with only two XLR inputs, learning to milk two mikes is a very valuable money-saving skill. Looking at it as an efficient means of making a mountain out of an audio molehill, and not a limitation, a second mike with its own separate track can really add just enough sonic control to salt a mix and bring out some real flavor. The two main positioning strategies to maximizing auditory potential are either with both microphones as distant-mikes, or with one as a distant-mike and the other as a close-mike. Both can sound great, but there's an interesting balance of power between the two methods. With two distant mikes, it's possible to get more of a stereo image of the kit.
With one distant and one close-mike, stereo imaging is stymied, but there's more control over the tone of a specific drum. Here are two excellent means to recording with only a pair of microphones:
Front-Of-Kit And Snare Mike
The front-of-kit mike (again, about 2' back from the kick and 4' high) is like the Swiss Army Knife of mike placement (minus the worthless toothpick). With a large-diaphragm condenser at the helm, it pretty much has every drum covered. The drums sound active and lively, and even the kick comes in surprisingly nice and strong. That said, sometimes there's a little meat missing from the snare. With the addition of a dynamic mike (Shure's SM57 is the standard, placed approximately 1" away from the head and rim, pointed at the center of the snare), it's possible to fatten up and focus in on a closer” snare tone. The major downsides to this format are that the cymbals can easily overwhelm the front-of-kit mike (which is 85 percent of the mix), and that stereo imaging is limited and awkward.
The two best steps to avoiding cymbal overload are to simply play the cymbals quieter and to use the duller high-end pickup pattern of a ribbon mike instead of a condenser. Check out Steve Zissou's Underwater Party,” a two-mike production, with an Audio-Technica 4033a condenser at the front of kit and an SM57 on the snare:
Drummer's Perspective And Kick Mike
The drummer's perspective mike (placed relatively close to the drummer's head, but not so close as to catch any teased hair head-banging) sounds very similar to the front-of-kit position, except that there's a little more of the high-end stick attack and a lot less kick drum. The kick mike, placed about halfway inside the drum (for instance Shure's Beta 52A or AKG's D 112), and pointing a little off center, is added as a precautionary inoculation of an extra chest-thumping 50Hz boost and a 2—5kHz clicking attack.
Three's Company. So Who Invited Four And Five?
While options increase greatly as more mikes become involved, the basic capturing concepts of distant and close mikes still work for most setups involving anywhere from three to five microphones. If budget and time allow, these variations can really lead to outstandingly large and live results. Here are but a few of the many variations that can be implemented.
180 Degrees
A common practice with 1960's and '70s rock and jazz is the three-microphone triangular approach. While stubborn opinions abound on what's the best way to configure the traditional triumvirate, the basic format is a front-of-kit mike, a hi-hat side overhead, and a floor tom overhead (somewhat near the drummer's right shoulder). The distances of all of these mikes from the kit is directly proportional to how close and open the drums sound, and with no close mikes to reign it back in, it's important to evaluate an appropriate balance.
The height of the overheads (anywhere from 30"—60" from the snare) should be positioned with consideration to the height of the ceiling, the distance between drums and cymbals, and the drummer's sensitivity to dynamics.
Because there are two overheads involved, phase cancellation becomes a serious concern. Break out the measuring tape and adjust the overheads so they are equidistant from the snare. Note, however, this method only prevents the snare from being out of phase, and any other drum or cymbal may still be somewhat phase-y.
To counteract this, some engineers prefer to measure from the imaginary center” of the kit. Unlike the previous setups, the two overheads allow for a beautiful panning job, making the drums sound cohesively wide. Not surprisingly, someone in the microphone business finally took note and made a mike kit just for the triple-threat vintage approach. Blue Microphone's new Pro Drum Kit Kit” is a three-piece suit, tailored with two cardioid-condenser Dragonflys and one large-diaphragm-condenser Mouse to capture phenomenally realistic reproductions of all elements of the kit, from the sparkling highs and warm mids to the thumping lows and sharp attack normally delegated to a kick mike. Similarly, Earthworks has a three-piece mike set (it's actually just three SR25 cardioid condensers) with two overheads and one kick.
The other popular minimalist strategy, sometimes referred to as the Glyn Johns technique,” involves a mixture of four to five distant and close mikes. With two overheads, one near the hi-hat, the other near the floor tom and right shoulder, a kick, a snare, and occasionally a room mike, the arsenal is more than enough to capture well-rounded drum tones that don't suffer from being too roomy or too controlled.
A few other basic starting blocks for various scenarios are to have the overheads in XY position (angled at 90 degrees from each other), two drummer's perspective mikes (one near each shoulder, using the head as a baffle, and from here on out referred to as double parrot”), or to have a stereo pair as room mikes. All have a character of their own, and experimentation is the best way to learn about them.
A Note About Overheads
If the ceiling is low, it's best to work with cardioid condensers, as ribbons by nature work as figure-8 pickup patterns and will catch a lot of unwanted reflections from the ceiling. If the ceiling is more than 8' tall, try out some omni mikes. And if the drummer is tracking with the band in the same room, switch them out with hypercardioid condensers for the most isolation possible.
Drumming Strategies
Getting a good drum mix isn't only up to the engineer, as the drummer plays an even more critical role. The less microphones used puts that much more responsibility on a solid, balanced drum take, as it's less possible to polish an erratic and disjointed performance with studio magic. Wimpy snare cracks and pussyfooting tom rolls combined with overbearing trashy cymbals can be the death of the backbeat, and a minimalist setup can't resuscitate that kind of issue. Sensitivity and awareness are key, and drummers that learn to mix by playing have plenty more work in their future, so set up some mikes, mix from the sticks, and give the faders a rest.
Thursday, 14 July 2016
Stereo Miking Techniques For Recording Acoustic Guitar
The Three Techniques
All three of the following techniques have been used on countless hit records. You should familiarize yourself with all of them and then experiment with each to achieve your desired tone. In most situations, you'll want to use a pair of unidirectional, condenser mics placed close to the instrument (approximately 6 to 12 inches away). Mics with a cardioid polar pattern are generally best for an acoustic guitar because they exhibit less "bass-boost" from proximity effect than other directional types when placed close to the sound source.
Acoustic guitars will exhibit a "boomy" sound if miked incorrectly. Experiment with different mic combinations to achieve the sound you're after.
Spaced Mics - Setup 1
For this setup, two mics are spaced apart from each other at the same approximate height. My preference for the first mic is a small diaphragm condenser mic pointed at the 12th fret of the guitar to capture higher frequencies and string dynamics. For the second mic, I use a large diaphragm condenser aimed at the bridge or slightly behind it, to capture the lower frequencies and body characteristics of the acoustic guitar. When using this technique, remember to follow the Rule of 3:1,” where the distance between the two mics is at least three times the distance between each mic and the acoustic guitar. (For example, if Mic A is 6” from the twelfth fret, Mic B should be at least 18” away from Mic A.) This will help keep phase cancellations to a minimum and provide a smoother sound that will translate well to mono should you decide to do that later.
Spaced Mics - Setup 2
This technique is primarily a variation on the previous spaced mics setup. The first mic is still a small diaphragm condenser pointed at the twelfth fret. The second mic, however, is positioned on a mic stand around the performer's ear level, pointing down either at the bridge or at the strings just in front of the bridge. For a right-handed player, the mic will be positioned over the right shoulder. It should be placed out in front of the guitar and the performer and angled back towards the guitar (as opposed to pointing at the ground). This setup will yield a brighter sound that is thinner, but more open sounding than the first setup. Keep the Rule of 3:1” in mind, but experiment with the mic placement slightly to improve the timbre.
X-Y Stereo Mics
X-Y, also known as a coincident pair, is probably the easiest and most reliable method for recording acoustic guitar. It is hard to get a bad or unnatural-sounding recording with this setup for several reasons. First, the mics are positioned similarly to how our own ears hear an acoustic guitar. Second, you do not need to be as concerned with the phase issues apparent in the other setups because the capsules are so close to each other. Last, because the sound waves arrive at roughly the same time to both mics, and phase issues are minimized, the resulting tracks will be highly mono-compatible, if so desired. To start, place two small diaphragm condenser mics (a matched pair is ideal) so that one capsule is above the other (nearly touching) and the back ends are split apart roughly 90 to 120 degrees, forming a V-shape. Keep the capsules focused on the 12th fret, but feel free to move the mics further away to capture more of the room, or slightly left or right of the 12th fret to emphasize particular frequencies. I find that about 7 inches back from the 12th fret often yields the sweet spot between the bass frequencies from the sound hole and higher frequencies from the neck, and in effect de-emphasizes the midrange frequencies. This setup will create a narrower stereo image than the other two setups discussed, but will make up for it with a warmer, more natural sound.
EQ, Compression
While some engineers like to add compression and EQ to acoustic guitars when recording, others prefer to add those touches after the fact and only as needed. It's hard to know just how an acoustic guitar track will sit in a mix, and hey, that's what all of these wonderful UAD Powered Plug-Ins are for anyway! In the end, and once again, there are no rules. So, have fun experimenting with these stereo pair recording techniques for acoustic guitar and stay tuned for more tips next month with Studio Basics.
All three of the following techniques have been used on countless hit records. You should familiarize yourself with all of them and then experiment with each to achieve your desired tone. In most situations, you'll want to use a pair of unidirectional, condenser mics placed close to the instrument (approximately 6 to 12 inches away). Mics with a cardioid polar pattern are generally best for an acoustic guitar because they exhibit less "bass-boost" from proximity effect than other directional types when placed close to the sound source.
Acoustic guitars will exhibit a "boomy" sound if miked incorrectly. Experiment with different mic combinations to achieve the sound you're after.
Spaced Mics - Setup 1
For this setup, two mics are spaced apart from each other at the same approximate height. My preference for the first mic is a small diaphragm condenser mic pointed at the 12th fret of the guitar to capture higher frequencies and string dynamics. For the second mic, I use a large diaphragm condenser aimed at the bridge or slightly behind it, to capture the lower frequencies and body characteristics of the acoustic guitar. When using this technique, remember to follow the Rule of 3:1,” where the distance between the two mics is at least three times the distance between each mic and the acoustic guitar. (For example, if Mic A is 6” from the twelfth fret, Mic B should be at least 18” away from Mic A.) This will help keep phase cancellations to a minimum and provide a smoother sound that will translate well to mono should you decide to do that later.
Spaced Mics - Setup 2
This technique is primarily a variation on the previous spaced mics setup. The first mic is still a small diaphragm condenser pointed at the twelfth fret. The second mic, however, is positioned on a mic stand around the performer's ear level, pointing down either at the bridge or at the strings just in front of the bridge. For a right-handed player, the mic will be positioned over the right shoulder. It should be placed out in front of the guitar and the performer and angled back towards the guitar (as opposed to pointing at the ground). This setup will yield a brighter sound that is thinner, but more open sounding than the first setup. Keep the Rule of 3:1” in mind, but experiment with the mic placement slightly to improve the timbre.
X-Y Stereo Mics
X-Y, also known as a coincident pair, is probably the easiest and most reliable method for recording acoustic guitar. It is hard to get a bad or unnatural-sounding recording with this setup for several reasons. First, the mics are positioned similarly to how our own ears hear an acoustic guitar. Second, you do not need to be as concerned with the phase issues apparent in the other setups because the capsules are so close to each other. Last, because the sound waves arrive at roughly the same time to both mics, and phase issues are minimized, the resulting tracks will be highly mono-compatible, if so desired. To start, place two small diaphragm condenser mics (a matched pair is ideal) so that one capsule is above the other (nearly touching) and the back ends are split apart roughly 90 to 120 degrees, forming a V-shape. Keep the capsules focused on the 12th fret, but feel free to move the mics further away to capture more of the room, or slightly left or right of the 12th fret to emphasize particular frequencies. I find that about 7 inches back from the 12th fret often yields the sweet spot between the bass frequencies from the sound hole and higher frequencies from the neck, and in effect de-emphasizes the midrange frequencies. This setup will create a narrower stereo image than the other two setups discussed, but will make up for it with a warmer, more natural sound.
EQ, Compression
While some engineers like to add compression and EQ to acoustic guitars when recording, others prefer to add those touches after the fact and only as needed. It's hard to know just how an acoustic guitar track will sit in a mix, and hey, that's what all of these wonderful UAD Powered Plug-Ins are for anyway! In the end, and once again, there are no rules. So, have fun experimenting with these stereo pair recording techniques for acoustic guitar and stay tuned for more tips next month with Studio Basics.
Wednesday, 13 July 2016
Miking Basses, Revisited
How do you get a good bass guitar sound in the studio? Learn some techniques in this article.
This is a re-write of an article that was over 4 years old. While much of the content and theory remains the same, it is hopefully a little clearer and perhaps some new ideas.
Bass guitars, more often than electric guitars, are recorded at least partly, if not completely, directly. However, you may want to mic a speaker as with a guitar and mix the two sounds to get a fuller sound, it all depends on your personal taste. I prefer the direct method for basement/garage recordings because it eliminates the problem of sound bleeding into the mic, and still provides a good solid bass sound that sometimes an average-quality mic might not pick up as cleanly. Also, modern bass guitar amplifiers, unlike guitar amps, have multiple speak sized in their cabinets, or multiple cabinets each with different size speakers. This is more common in bass guitar amps due to the extreme lows bass guitars produce, and some bass sounds really just wouldn't be the same without some of the high end sound particularly notable in slap and pop style playing as well as players that play with a pick.
That type of amplification would require the miking of two, or maybe more, different speakers to attain the high and low response of the instrument. Recording direct eliminates this problem.
Another not widely used technique in the home studio environment, but very effective technique for getting a good high end sound from the slap n' pop or picking styles is to put a mic right in front of the bass aiming straight at where the neck meets the body. It will give a good solid, sharp sound when mixed with the direct or miked bass sound. Line 6 also makes a great version of the "POD" (mentioned above) for the bass as well as Sansamp making their own fabulous Bass Driver DI
The basic miking techniques for the speaker itself are the same as with a guitar as far as placement is concerned.
The classic "Dead Center" miking position, this is the most obvious and most common positioning. Sometimes, with certain mics this may want to be avoided because it does put a huge amount of pressure on the mic because the sound is coming from right in the center of the cone, especially when talking about the low end power of a bass instrument. It does give a clean, pure representation of the speaker, but is sometimes prone to overdrive the mic.
Placing the mic on the center of the cone. I have seen many live sound engineers use this method with, some say, less pressure put on the mic. Still, it is a nice, close-proximity option for you to try with you amplifier.
Putting the mic at a 45 degree angle with the cone centered on the cap. I have seen this method used more for the second mic on a cabinet rather than the first, but none-the-less, it is an option. Used further back from the amp it can be good for grabbing extra bass. Theoretically, the highs will just shoot right past it and the booming bass will the picked up more with this position.
Putting the mic perpendicular with the speaker. This is even a more radical approach to getting more bass in your sound. Same theory as above, just a greater angle to let more highs zip past.
Though the direct method is probably the most common, as stated above, but a miked speaker can add some very big fullness to the sound. Quite often the mixture of miked and direct recording can create some very rich bass sounds.
Part of the fun of this hobby is experimentation. Try to mix and match the miking styles mentioned above, try a couple of them together, have a mic a few feet back to catch the bass wash from the speaker. With many bass speakers, 15" or bigger, the full bass waveform doesn't even fully develop for many feet, which is why some of you performers may notice that the guitarist on the other side of the stage hears your bass better than you do standing right next to the amp. So having a mic a ways back can help as well.
Last, but not least, the engineer has to be aware of the basses pickups. There are active and passive pickups. Passive pickups are the standard, simple magnetic pickups that most instruments come with as standard equipment. Higher end instruments, or a frequent customization bass players do is add active pickups. Active pickups are battery powered magnetic pickups that act as a type of preamp in the pickup itself. It tends to add nice power and punch to the sound and sometimes makes getting a good tone recording much easier, especially when going direct. So, when experimenting techniques, take note of what you see working better for not only each playing style but also for each pickup style.
Many home-recording artists approach bass as a "back-end" instrument, so a "good enuf" take is used. Don't fall into that trap. Personally, even with all I have said above, I still prefer recording direct, it seems to give me the best sound with the least amount of hassle, but there is certainly a strong case for going to more effort and trying for that "perfect sound".
Rock on, and don't get lazy on the low end.
This is a re-write of an article that was over 4 years old. While much of the content and theory remains the same, it is hopefully a little clearer and perhaps some new ideas.
Bass guitars, more often than electric guitars, are recorded at least partly, if not completely, directly. However, you may want to mic a speaker as with a guitar and mix the two sounds to get a fuller sound, it all depends on your personal taste. I prefer the direct method for basement/garage recordings because it eliminates the problem of sound bleeding into the mic, and still provides a good solid bass sound that sometimes an average-quality mic might not pick up as cleanly. Also, modern bass guitar amplifiers, unlike guitar amps, have multiple speak sized in their cabinets, or multiple cabinets each with different size speakers. This is more common in bass guitar amps due to the extreme lows bass guitars produce, and some bass sounds really just wouldn't be the same without some of the high end sound particularly notable in slap and pop style playing as well as players that play with a pick.
That type of amplification would require the miking of two, or maybe more, different speakers to attain the high and low response of the instrument. Recording direct eliminates this problem.
Another not widely used technique in the home studio environment, but very effective technique for getting a good high end sound from the slap n' pop or picking styles is to put a mic right in front of the bass aiming straight at where the neck meets the body. It will give a good solid, sharp sound when mixed with the direct or miked bass sound. Line 6 also makes a great version of the "POD" (mentioned above) for the bass as well as Sansamp making their own fabulous Bass Driver DI
The basic miking techniques for the speaker itself are the same as with a guitar as far as placement is concerned.
The classic "Dead Center" miking position, this is the most obvious and most common positioning. Sometimes, with certain mics this may want to be avoided because it does put a huge amount of pressure on the mic because the sound is coming from right in the center of the cone, especially when talking about the low end power of a bass instrument. It does give a clean, pure representation of the speaker, but is sometimes prone to overdrive the mic.
Placing the mic on the center of the cone. I have seen many live sound engineers use this method with, some say, less pressure put on the mic. Still, it is a nice, close-proximity option for you to try with you amplifier.
Putting the mic at a 45 degree angle with the cone centered on the cap. I have seen this method used more for the second mic on a cabinet rather than the first, but none-the-less, it is an option. Used further back from the amp it can be good for grabbing extra bass. Theoretically, the highs will just shoot right past it and the booming bass will the picked up more with this position.
Putting the mic perpendicular with the speaker. This is even a more radical approach to getting more bass in your sound. Same theory as above, just a greater angle to let more highs zip past.
Though the direct method is probably the most common, as stated above, but a miked speaker can add some very big fullness to the sound. Quite often the mixture of miked and direct recording can create some very rich bass sounds.
Part of the fun of this hobby is experimentation. Try to mix and match the miking styles mentioned above, try a couple of them together, have a mic a few feet back to catch the bass wash from the speaker. With many bass speakers, 15" or bigger, the full bass waveform doesn't even fully develop for many feet, which is why some of you performers may notice that the guitarist on the other side of the stage hears your bass better than you do standing right next to the amp. So having a mic a ways back can help as well.
Last, but not least, the engineer has to be aware of the basses pickups. There are active and passive pickups. Passive pickups are the standard, simple magnetic pickups that most instruments come with as standard equipment. Higher end instruments, or a frequent customization bass players do is add active pickups. Active pickups are battery powered magnetic pickups that act as a type of preamp in the pickup itself. It tends to add nice power and punch to the sound and sometimes makes getting a good tone recording much easier, especially when going direct. So, when experimenting techniques, take note of what you see working better for not only each playing style but also for each pickup style.
Many home-recording artists approach bass as a "back-end" instrument, so a "good enuf" take is used. Don't fall into that trap. Personally, even with all I have said above, I still prefer recording direct, it seems to give me the best sound with the least amount of hassle, but there is certainly a strong case for going to more effort and trying for that "perfect sound".
Rock on, and don't get lazy on the low end.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)