Your drum sound is one of the most important aspects of your mix. Mixing drums is therefore a number one priority for laying that solid foundation to your tracks, guaranteeing you a solid rhythm section.
Drums can be one of the most problematic instruments to get right in a mix.
If you did a great job recording the drum kit, then mixing your drums can only be a pleasurable experience.
BUT WHERE TO START?
Kick Drum Sound
Mixing drums starts with the foundation of the kick drum. The sound of the kick drum, along with the snare will be the defining factors of your drum sound. If you leave the kick drum sounding bad, the whole foundation of the song will lose its footing. The kick drum needs to be tight and punchy, with enough low end to fill up the bass range and enough mids to cut through the mix.
EQ
A boomy kick drum can also cloud up the clarity of your kick drum sound, so it's normally a good idea to cut around 200 - 250 Hz if you feel there is too much muddiness in your kick drum sound. A boxy kick drum sound is also a common nuisance, which can be fixed with Eq'ing out the boxiness that resides in the aread around 300 - 600Hz or so.
If your kick drum is all thump and no snap then we need to bring out the sound of the beater. We can usually find it around the 2 - 4 Khz area. Depending on the genre of the song, and the type of beater used, different frequency boosts in the beater area generate different sounds. A boost at 2.5 Khz is more of a typical rock sound as opposed to a narrower boost at around 4 Khz, which results in a Hardcore Metal type snap.
EQ is very important to me, which is why I spend a considerable time educating my email subscribers on the topic. From getting rid of muddiness to EQ'ing your kick and snare effectively, my newsletter subscribers get exclusive articles that help them get better at using EQ to create separation in your mixes. Take a quick second to subscribe right here.
Compression
When mixing drums, along with everything else, using compression is a subjective subject and everyone has an opinion on how things should be compressed. That said, there are a few guidelines you can follow to get a steadier kick drum sound.
How much gain reduction you want from the compressor depends on the genre, the steadiness of the drummer and the feel of the song. I usually start with a ratio of 4:1 or 6:1 and lower the threshold down until I'm compressing around 6 dBs.
Then I adjust the attack and release depending on what sort of sound I want. A fast attack clamps down on the transient of the kick drum, dulling the initial attack down somewhat, but a slower attack lets the attack of the beater break through before the compressor starts working.
I try to time the release in time with the beat, so that the compressor has stopped compressing before the next hit. It's easy to do this in modern DAWs because you are able to see the gain reduction meter working, enabling you to tweak the release perfectly in sync with the song.
EQ and Compression are the fundamental processors for any mix session. If you understand how these two processors work, then you've solved at least 80% of your mixing problems.
Snare Drum Sound
Partner in crime with the kick drum, the snare drum is the other defining rhythmic factor to the song. It's all about the snare” an experienced engineer once told me, because it's what supplies the song with that steady backbeat. Since it's such an important aspect of mixing drums, there needs to be a lot of care taken with getting the best sound possible.
EQ
EQ-wise, there is not an awful lot you need below 100 Hz, so you can start by high-pass filtering all the low end away.
The body of the snare can be brought forward with a little boost at around 150Hz, if you feel like it's lacking some thickness.
I like thick snares so I often catch myself adding a little weight to the snare around that area.
If your snare has ringing frequencies that you find annoying you can try pinpointing them by boosting a specific frequency band with a high Q and sweeping the spectrum until they pop out. I find that sometimes the snare needs a little cut in the mids, either resulting from boxiness at 500 - 800 Hz or too much of a nasally attack from the area around 1 Khz.
Enhance the attack of the snare with a broad boost around 2 - 4 Khz and search for the sizzle of the snares in the higher frequencies.
Compression
Like I do with the bass drum, I try to make the snare compress in time with the song. By timing the attack and release I can get a nice steady snare sound that breathes with each hit. I normally leave the attack at a medium to slow setting so that the snap of the snare is unaffected, and time the release so that it stops compressing just in time for the next hit.
I start with a ratio of 3:1, often going way higher as it depends on the genre how hard I want the compressor to be pumping. You can adjust the threshold so that it is only lightly compressing the peaks for a subtle sound, or you can push the threshold down harder for a heavily compressed sound.
Snare compression is perhaps one of the most argued about subjects in audio production. Every engineer has a certain method to mixing drums, and I think it's up to you to experiment and get acquainted with the knobs and sliders on your audio compressor so that you can create the sound that you want.
REVERB
You can create a completely different snare sound by just applying an interesting reverb to it. Whether that's a rock arena reverb, subdued room or even a spring reverb, different reverbs can transform the sound of your snare drum.
Go through your reverbs and see what type of reverb sounds best with the song you're mixing. Are you going to add a bright plate reverb to make it stand out, or will you be mixing it into a specific room with a small room sound? If you are in a particularly adventurous mood, you can try adding some gated reverb to your snare.
Mixing the Toms
EQ'ing
If the toms are playing a big part in your drum sound, mixing them so that they sound punchy and powerful is crucial to a great drum sound.
Get them punchy with EQ. The best way to EQ toms is to find the unflattering frequencies with your equalizer. Normally, these are the middle frequencies, from 300 - 800 Khz or so.
Find the boxy and unwanted frequencies, cut them out and then add low end power and high end punch as needed.
When mixing drums like toms, sometimes you need to finely cut a few adjacent frequencies instead of scooping out a big portion of the frequency spectrum.
Compressing
By adding a generous amount of compression to your toms you can get a larger than life sound out of them. You can fatten them up considerably with some tight compression, and with the addition of a little reverb you can make them sound huge and powerful. If that's what you want to go for.
The same rule of subtle compression applies as well to toms if you only want to control the peaks and lightly color their signal.
Overheads
The overheads might be the most important microphones on the kit. The overheads are the microphones that are supposed to pick up every drum and give a complete sound to your drum kit.
There are two ways of mixing drums with the overheads; you can either use them as the primary sound, sculpting every drum around the overhead sound or you can use them to primarily accent the cymbals and air around the kit.
By adding the overheads to the mix early on, you can get a better sense of the full sound of the kit, making your drum mixing easier.
Just notice how different a snare drum microphone sounds compared to a snare that's coming from the overhead mics.
By adjusting the overheads with the rest of the close miked drums you can get a different sound.
By focusing on the overheads you can get a roomier sound, but if you want a close in-your-face drum sound you would rather use the overheads as complimentary to the rest of the drums, mainly using them to accent the cymbal sounds.
The Hi-Hat
Mixing drums is a selective process, meaning that certain elements of the drum-kit only need specific frequency ranges.
You only need a specific frequency range from the hi-hat. Considering that the hi-hat microphone is probably picking up a lot of bleed from other drums, some heavy high-pass filtering is in order. Filter up to 250 Hz at least, even higher if you feel that you aren't losing anything from the hi-hat sound with higher filtering.
Now if you feel that there is something lacking from the hi-hat, or that you want to bring out the gong sound, you can find it in the 200 Hz area. So if your hi-hat needs a little more gong to it, you will have to sacrifice that aggressive filtering. Like everything else, just filter until you start hearing the sound becoming compromised and then back off a little bit.
Cutting at 1Khz can reduce the cheap jangly sound from the hi-hat, but you can enhance and give it some sparkle with a boost from 7 Khz or so. Use a high shelving EQ if you want to enhance the high end with some air, but a parametric bell EQ if you just want to accent a specific frequency area.
Room Mics
Room microphones give a different sound to the drum kit than the regular overhead mics.
Due to the distant miking technique most room mics are recorded with, we get a full sound of the drum-kit as well as a great amount of the reverb of the room it was recorded in.
Which, depending on the sound of the room, can either sound amazing or horrible.
Mixing Drums With a Roomy Sound
But let's assume our recording room is great. With a nice room mic picking up the complete kit we can try a few different techniques. We can apply some heavy compression to the room mics to get an even punchier sound.
We can EQ the kit as to draw out the most important elements, such as kick and snare and we can add it underneath an already great drum sound for that final touch.
Mixing Drums Into a Room
If the drums weren't recorded in a nice sounding room and sound quite dead when they come from the recording stage, it's time to add some space to our drum tracks.
A good way to add some ambience to our drum tracks is to add a 0.5 second drum room reverb. You can add a a nice amount to the overhead tracks, and maybe even a slightly different reverb to the snare to make it stand out. Go through your reverbs to try to find the best sound to your particular track.
I actually want to stop the article here and give it up for my buddy David Glenn of David Glenn Recording. He has a really cool video on mixing acoustic drums, especially when it comes to creating space and reverb using some nice plug-ins:
He actually has a cool video series on Mixing Drums if you want a complete, 7 hour in-depth tutorial on the matter.
Conclusion
Mixing drums is a challenging but enjoyable aspect of audio production. Since there are so many different ways of getting the drums to sound with EQ, compression and other mixing tricks there is no actual right way of mixing drums.
The only solid piece of advice I can give you for mixing drums is to experiment with all the tools you have on hand. Get every element to sound as good as possible and then try to mold them together to make them sound like a complete whole.
As always, there are trends in the music industry as to what sounds good right now, but being able to get whatever sound you want, whether it's huge 80's toms or a 90's arena rock snare is an important aspect of being a well rounded mixing engineer.
We've gone through quite a long journey on the different aspects of mixing drums, which I hope you enjoyed.
Showing posts with label Recording Drums Techniques. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Recording Drums Techniques. Show all posts
Saturday, 5 November 2016
Tuesday, 1 November 2016
Drum Recording Techniques, By Joe Hirst
Recording drums in the studio is often one of the most challenging yet rewarding tasks for an engineer, the size and volume of the instrument and variety of sounds it can produce can make it a daunting prospect for anyone undertaking it for the first time. I have around ten years experience of recording drums and have developed several different working methods of which I am happy with but continually strive to change and improve. Throughout this tutorial I will offer some practical and artistic advice aimed at helping you first of all understand some basic principles of drum recording and secondly help you develop your own methods and approaches.
The Drum Kit
You can't achieve a great drum sound with the wrong drum kit, that may sound obvious but in reality there are many factors in choosing the right kit for your recording. Having a clear idea of how you want the kit to sound from the start will greatly help you choose not only the kit but also the recording methods you employ. Preparation is crucial for a successful drum session; if the song suggests an old Motown drum sound for example then you will struggle if you have a brand new DW kit in a large reverberant room. If you feel the kit the drummer has is not right for the job then always hire or borrow anything that'll improve the recording starting with the right snare! As with all recording getting the right instrument, recording space and equipment is essential for a successful session.
Drum kits come in all shapes and sizes and usually in various states of disrepair, as an engineer is very important to be able to get the most out of just about any kit. Fresh heads and careful tuning will always get the best out of a drum, some drummers will do this automatically before a session others will shudder at the thought. I personally like to get involved in tuning drums if I feel the drummer isn't up to it, I recently found some great tutorials on YouTube that I thoroughly recommend (see links at bottom). A drum key, screwdriver and RTOM Moongels (dampening pads) are essential tools for getting the kit in tune and sounding right, always have these handy at a drum session.
There are lots of factors that affect the sound of a drum kit, when I'm recording I'll maybe change several small things that I think will have the greatest overall impact in shaping the sound I'm after.
1. Remove the front skin of a kick drum for a tighter thump sound with little resonance or vice versa
2. Add or remove dampening from the kick drum to adjust resonance
3. Change the kick beater to affect the attack of the beater (felt, plastic, wood)
4. Tighten or loosen the snares
5. Add or remove dampening on all drums
If you are lucky you'll be working with a great drummer who has got all of this covered himself and can tune the toms sympathetically to key of the song if not then don't be afraid to get involved!
The Room
The room you set the kit up in will have a massive impact on how the recordings will turn out, for example if you want a big boomy rock sound don't use a small dead booth, again it's obvious but critical to consider for the overall result. Natural ambience will always help gel the sound of a kit together and create natural space without the need for artificial reverb, for this reason unless you are after a dead sound a largish room with reflective surfaces (brick, wood, stone etc) and high ceilings will be a good bet. Drum screens can help control ambience around the kit and allow you to record a fairly dry close sound whilst also allowing you to capture the full natural ambience of the room.
Many producers and engineers choose specific studios for their drum room. These hallowed spaces make recording drums a pleasure. London has a couple of these magic rooms found at studios like RAK, Abbey Road and of course Miloco's own Garden Studio. In my opinion a great sounding drum room is far more important than an endless list of mics and outboard.
Interesting sounding rooms can also add unique character to a recording, using a brick basement, stairwell or corridor should never be ruled out if appropriate and accessible.
Setting The Mics
Once you have a sympathetically tuned kit in a good room, which works for the tracks you are recording, you can start thinking about how to mic up your kit. I believe there are two main schools of thought when it comes to drum micing:
1. Capture the sound and balance of the kit as a whole using minimal micing. 2. Create a representation of each drum and cymbal to form an overall sound using multimicing.
Both of these approaches have their merit and should be selected and adapted to achieve the sound you are attempting to create. If for example you are recording a metal band and want a clearly defined, punchy and aggressive sound then a multimicing approach would be perfect. In contrast a minimal micing approach would be better suited for recording a jazz kit for example.
Multimicing can mean placing well over fifteen mics on a kit at once, this method clearly requires a large amount of equipment and a lot of time to adjust, here is an outline of a multimicing approach I might take for a big rock sound:
Kick In
Mic inside drum to capture the sound of the beater and general attack of the sound, suggestions include, D12, D112, RE20, basically a solid dynamic that preferably has a large capsule capable of reproducing low frequencies and not distorting at high levels.
Kick Out
Mic on hole of the resonant head (if applicable) to add weight and roundness to the sound and provide more of a note, Neumann FET47 is the classic mic for the job but a U87 will do or any other LDC with a pad that won't distort at high levels.
Kick Sub
Another mic on the outside such as a Yamaha Sub Kick or rewired NS10 cone will provide 808-style sub for your kick drum if needed. This is optional but usually worth taking even if not used.
Snare Top
Mic the top of the snare to capture the main crack and tone. Start by placing the mic a couple of inches above the head facing into the centre, moving the mic will have a dramatic effect on the end sound so always experiment with this. If you have an overly ringy snare for example moving the mic will often help alleviate the worst overtones. I like the humble SM57 on snare top but many dynamics will work, Beyer 201 can be good as can the Sennheiser 441, don't rule out SDCs either (as long as they have a pad!).
Bottom Snare
Mic the bottom of the snare to aid air and sizzle to the sound, blending the two snare mics can yield many different sounds when mixing. Again the SM57 is a favourite of mine but there are many options for this duty.
Toms
Micing toms is essential in this kind of setup and again experiment with positions, moving the mic will allow you to get the best balance between attack and weight and help you minimize spill from other sounds. I usually use either 414s (hyper cardiod mode with 20dB pad) or Sennheiser 421's. 414's offer a strong attack and good spill rejection and 421's often just sound right!!!!
Overheads
There are numerous ways to set up overheads but in this kind of arrangement the most common would probably be by using a spaced pair of mics placed to offer a good spread of the whole kit (possibly one mic over the ride cymbal and another above a high rack tom). The height and width of the mics determine what they capture but essentially you are looking to get an overall picture of the kit with a focus on the cymbals. For a warm and full overhead sound you can't beat Coles 4038's or similar ribbon mics, as an alternative you could use SDCs such as Neumann KM84's, which are bright and provide an excellent transient response.
Hi Hats
If you need a close hi hat sound then a SDC is perfect, an AKG 451 or KM84 will do a great job, you should look to balance the sound between the stick noise and overall tone of the cymbal.
Ride Cymbal
Again this is optional depending on the drum part, if you need to emphasise the bell of the ride for a certain section then placing an SDC close to the cymbal will help you when you come to mix the track.
Room Mics
Capturing the sound of the kit in the recording room helps to add space and depth to the sound and will often gel all of the individual kit mics together. Depending on the room I will usually use a spaced pair of omni LDCs such as 414s, experimenting here can often provide interesting and unique sounds, for example try recording a mono mic pointed at a wall or on the floor behind the kit etc.
Dist Mics
I always like to use a trashy mic set to pick up a whole kit sound which I then heavily limit and distort and blend to taste. This can add excitement and power to a recording and always sounds better than just distorting your drums after. Crystal mics such as the Shure DX520 (Green Bullet) are perfect but my personal favourite is the STC Ball and Biscuit. Ebay is perfect for picking up cheap lo-fi mics that give you a cool and distinct drum sound. The position of this mic varies depending on the player and part but usually I place it between the kick and snare about two feet from the kit.
Fine Tuning the Mics
When using so many mics it is essential that you thoroughly check the phase relationship of everything and make sure nothing is being cancelled out. Most preamps will have a phase reverse switch so you can use that to quickly flip the phase of a mic so see if it solves the problem, if it doesn't then you'll need to move the mic to alleviate the problem. Phase problems often make a particular drum sound weak compared to the others or less punchy often-just phase reversing one or two mics will make a big difference.
Minimal Micing
If you decide to use a minimal micing technique to record your drums then you are effectively looking to capture an overall balance of the kit with around 4 or 5 mics. This approach clearly requires less equipment and time but in many ways requires a better drummer and kit to make it really shine when compared to the multimicing approach. If your drummer plays the hi-hat extremely loud for example and out of balance with the rest of the kit with this method it will be difficult to really adjust that balance when you come to mixing. The sound achieved through minimal micing however can be natural, powerful and more realistic. Glyn Johns is seen as a pioneer of this technique and I believe he used it to great effect with Jon Bonham on many Led Zepplin tracks. More recently a variation of his technique has been called the, ‘Recorderman Technique' there is a great video about this technique on youtube (see links at bottom).
Here is an outline of how I would approach a drum recording with less microphones:
Kick and Snare
One mic on the kick maybe just inside the hole (Fet 47 or similar) positioned to capture a good balance between the attack of the beater and the decay of the drum. One mic on the top of the snare set up as described above.
Overheads
This is where the main difference in setup occurs; the mics are setup in a non-symmetrical fashion. One mic is placed about six inches above the floor tom pointing at the snare and the other over the rack tom again pointing at the snare, ideally they should both be around two stick lengths from the snare centre. The mic above the snare should be panned to the left at about 9 'clock and the other overhead to the right slightly wider.
Room Mics
Add a stereo room mic setup as described above if required.
Dist Mic
I always like to use a distorted mic for blending purposes but it is definitely optional!!!
Summary
Once you have a grasp of these basic principles for recording drums you can begin to experiment and try out your own ideas, compressing and EQing when recording offers some interesting options as does the use of guitar amps and pedals! Always put the best interest of the song first though, a great drum sound that doesn't suit the track is completely useless.
The Drum Kit
You can't achieve a great drum sound with the wrong drum kit, that may sound obvious but in reality there are many factors in choosing the right kit for your recording. Having a clear idea of how you want the kit to sound from the start will greatly help you choose not only the kit but also the recording methods you employ. Preparation is crucial for a successful drum session; if the song suggests an old Motown drum sound for example then you will struggle if you have a brand new DW kit in a large reverberant room. If you feel the kit the drummer has is not right for the job then always hire or borrow anything that'll improve the recording starting with the right snare! As with all recording getting the right instrument, recording space and equipment is essential for a successful session.
Drum kits come in all shapes and sizes and usually in various states of disrepair, as an engineer is very important to be able to get the most out of just about any kit. Fresh heads and careful tuning will always get the best out of a drum, some drummers will do this automatically before a session others will shudder at the thought. I personally like to get involved in tuning drums if I feel the drummer isn't up to it, I recently found some great tutorials on YouTube that I thoroughly recommend (see links at bottom). A drum key, screwdriver and RTOM Moongels (dampening pads) are essential tools for getting the kit in tune and sounding right, always have these handy at a drum session.
There are lots of factors that affect the sound of a drum kit, when I'm recording I'll maybe change several small things that I think will have the greatest overall impact in shaping the sound I'm after.
1. Remove the front skin of a kick drum for a tighter thump sound with little resonance or vice versa
2. Add or remove dampening from the kick drum to adjust resonance
3. Change the kick beater to affect the attack of the beater (felt, plastic, wood)
4. Tighten or loosen the snares
5. Add or remove dampening on all drums
If you are lucky you'll be working with a great drummer who has got all of this covered himself and can tune the toms sympathetically to key of the song if not then don't be afraid to get involved!
The Room
The room you set the kit up in will have a massive impact on how the recordings will turn out, for example if you want a big boomy rock sound don't use a small dead booth, again it's obvious but critical to consider for the overall result. Natural ambience will always help gel the sound of a kit together and create natural space without the need for artificial reverb, for this reason unless you are after a dead sound a largish room with reflective surfaces (brick, wood, stone etc) and high ceilings will be a good bet. Drum screens can help control ambience around the kit and allow you to record a fairly dry close sound whilst also allowing you to capture the full natural ambience of the room.
Many producers and engineers choose specific studios for their drum room. These hallowed spaces make recording drums a pleasure. London has a couple of these magic rooms found at studios like RAK, Abbey Road and of course Miloco's own Garden Studio. In my opinion a great sounding drum room is far more important than an endless list of mics and outboard.
Interesting sounding rooms can also add unique character to a recording, using a brick basement, stairwell or corridor should never be ruled out if appropriate and accessible.
Setting The Mics
Once you have a sympathetically tuned kit in a good room, which works for the tracks you are recording, you can start thinking about how to mic up your kit. I believe there are two main schools of thought when it comes to drum micing:
1. Capture the sound and balance of the kit as a whole using minimal micing. 2. Create a representation of each drum and cymbal to form an overall sound using multimicing.
Both of these approaches have their merit and should be selected and adapted to achieve the sound you are attempting to create. If for example you are recording a metal band and want a clearly defined, punchy and aggressive sound then a multimicing approach would be perfect. In contrast a minimal micing approach would be better suited for recording a jazz kit for example.
Multimicing can mean placing well over fifteen mics on a kit at once, this method clearly requires a large amount of equipment and a lot of time to adjust, here is an outline of a multimicing approach I might take for a big rock sound:
Kick In
Mic inside drum to capture the sound of the beater and general attack of the sound, suggestions include, D12, D112, RE20, basically a solid dynamic that preferably has a large capsule capable of reproducing low frequencies and not distorting at high levels.
Kick Out
Mic on hole of the resonant head (if applicable) to add weight and roundness to the sound and provide more of a note, Neumann FET47 is the classic mic for the job but a U87 will do or any other LDC with a pad that won't distort at high levels.
Kick Sub
Another mic on the outside such as a Yamaha Sub Kick or rewired NS10 cone will provide 808-style sub for your kick drum if needed. This is optional but usually worth taking even if not used.
Snare Top
Mic the top of the snare to capture the main crack and tone. Start by placing the mic a couple of inches above the head facing into the centre, moving the mic will have a dramatic effect on the end sound so always experiment with this. If you have an overly ringy snare for example moving the mic will often help alleviate the worst overtones. I like the humble SM57 on snare top but many dynamics will work, Beyer 201 can be good as can the Sennheiser 441, don't rule out SDCs either (as long as they have a pad!).
Bottom Snare
Mic the bottom of the snare to aid air and sizzle to the sound, blending the two snare mics can yield many different sounds when mixing. Again the SM57 is a favourite of mine but there are many options for this duty.
Toms
Micing toms is essential in this kind of setup and again experiment with positions, moving the mic will allow you to get the best balance between attack and weight and help you minimize spill from other sounds. I usually use either 414s (hyper cardiod mode with 20dB pad) or Sennheiser 421's. 414's offer a strong attack and good spill rejection and 421's often just sound right!!!!
Overheads
There are numerous ways to set up overheads but in this kind of arrangement the most common would probably be by using a spaced pair of mics placed to offer a good spread of the whole kit (possibly one mic over the ride cymbal and another above a high rack tom). The height and width of the mics determine what they capture but essentially you are looking to get an overall picture of the kit with a focus on the cymbals. For a warm and full overhead sound you can't beat Coles 4038's or similar ribbon mics, as an alternative you could use SDCs such as Neumann KM84's, which are bright and provide an excellent transient response.
Hi Hats
If you need a close hi hat sound then a SDC is perfect, an AKG 451 or KM84 will do a great job, you should look to balance the sound between the stick noise and overall tone of the cymbal.
Ride Cymbal
Again this is optional depending on the drum part, if you need to emphasise the bell of the ride for a certain section then placing an SDC close to the cymbal will help you when you come to mix the track.
Room Mics
Capturing the sound of the kit in the recording room helps to add space and depth to the sound and will often gel all of the individual kit mics together. Depending on the room I will usually use a spaced pair of omni LDCs such as 414s, experimenting here can often provide interesting and unique sounds, for example try recording a mono mic pointed at a wall or on the floor behind the kit etc.
Dist Mics
I always like to use a trashy mic set to pick up a whole kit sound which I then heavily limit and distort and blend to taste. This can add excitement and power to a recording and always sounds better than just distorting your drums after. Crystal mics such as the Shure DX520 (Green Bullet) are perfect but my personal favourite is the STC Ball and Biscuit. Ebay is perfect for picking up cheap lo-fi mics that give you a cool and distinct drum sound. The position of this mic varies depending on the player and part but usually I place it between the kick and snare about two feet from the kit.
Fine Tuning the Mics
When using so many mics it is essential that you thoroughly check the phase relationship of everything and make sure nothing is being cancelled out. Most preamps will have a phase reverse switch so you can use that to quickly flip the phase of a mic so see if it solves the problem, if it doesn't then you'll need to move the mic to alleviate the problem. Phase problems often make a particular drum sound weak compared to the others or less punchy often-just phase reversing one or two mics will make a big difference.
Minimal Micing
If you decide to use a minimal micing technique to record your drums then you are effectively looking to capture an overall balance of the kit with around 4 or 5 mics. This approach clearly requires less equipment and time but in many ways requires a better drummer and kit to make it really shine when compared to the multimicing approach. If your drummer plays the hi-hat extremely loud for example and out of balance with the rest of the kit with this method it will be difficult to really adjust that balance when you come to mixing. The sound achieved through minimal micing however can be natural, powerful and more realistic. Glyn Johns is seen as a pioneer of this technique and I believe he used it to great effect with Jon Bonham on many Led Zepplin tracks. More recently a variation of his technique has been called the, ‘Recorderman Technique' there is a great video about this technique on youtube (see links at bottom).
Here is an outline of how I would approach a drum recording with less microphones:
Kick and Snare
One mic on the kick maybe just inside the hole (Fet 47 or similar) positioned to capture a good balance between the attack of the beater and the decay of the drum. One mic on the top of the snare set up as described above.
Overheads
This is where the main difference in setup occurs; the mics are setup in a non-symmetrical fashion. One mic is placed about six inches above the floor tom pointing at the snare and the other over the rack tom again pointing at the snare, ideally they should both be around two stick lengths from the snare centre. The mic above the snare should be panned to the left at about 9 'clock and the other overhead to the right slightly wider.
Room Mics
Add a stereo room mic setup as described above if required.
Dist Mic
I always like to use a distorted mic for blending purposes but it is definitely optional!!!
Summary
Once you have a grasp of these basic principles for recording drums you can begin to experiment and try out your own ideas, compressing and EQing when recording offers some interesting options as does the use of guitar amps and pedals! Always put the best interest of the song first though, a great drum sound that doesn't suit the track is completely useless.
Thursday, 27 October 2016
Comparing Overhead Drum Miking Techniques
matthew mcglynn
You have two microphones and two hours. How many ways can you mike a drum kit?
I had a good idea of my choices, but I wanted to hear them all together so I would know what works in my room. It's no different from getting to know your own mic locker; each stereo mic placement technique is a tool, and like any tool it is only useful if you know how to use it.
I made a list of seven stereo mic techniques for drum recording, then recorded myself playing the same thing on the same drums in the same room, as heard through the same pair of microphones — in seven different configurations. Following is a detailed comparison of Spaced Pair (omni and cardioid), Coincident Pair (omni and cardioid), ORTF, Mid-Side and
Recorderman.”
The mics in question were a pair of
SE Electronics' 4400a The 4400a is an incredibly versatile large-diaphragm multipattern FET condenser in a very small form-factor. (We are liking this mike a lot; watch for a full review soon.)
The audio samples below are stereo 320kbps MP3s. I recommend listening in headphones, as the differences among the tracks are easiest to hear if the sound of your own monitoring environment is well-controlled.
Listening with the proper mindset
All the following are legitimate stereo miking techniques (well, except maybe for XY-omni). While you might find a favorite here, be aware that the appropriate technique for any session depends on the drums, the room, the player, the song, and the arrangement. As always.
Nonetheless, this test reveals characteristics of each OH miking technique — such as the width of the stereo field, the intimacy of the kit, the amount of room sound in the mix, the susceptibility to phasing or comb-filtering problems — that bear consideration for every session.
XY (Coincident Pair)
XY is one of the two most common stereo overhead miking techniques. For my test, the mics were in a 90° spread, about 55'' from the center of the snare head and 80'' above the floor.
I recorded samples in both Cardioid and Omnidirectional modes.
Neither of these clips presents a wide stereo image. Listen to the closing tom fill — there is little discernible lateral movement.
The image collapses to mono gracefully; this is expected, given that the mic capsules were close together. Listening in mono also reveals that, in stereo, both clips do present a sense of space — it's small, but it's there. If you don't like hearing tom fills that go from one corner of the room to the other, or if you're recording a song for which the drums play a background role, then XY is a reliable choice.
For me, both these tracks have too much boomy low end. I don't much like either of them.
The omni clip has far too much room sound for my taste. In a space that is either deader or tuned, I think omni is a more viable choice for drum overheads; for example, listen to the omni tracks in my old drum overhead shootout , in which an omni mic brought depth and LF without excessive boom or smeary HF.
Note, too, that the height of the XY pair will alter the sound of the result. I think I would have liked this pair better if I'd lowered the mics to a height of about 60 inches (instead of 80" this would have reduced the apparent volume of the room sound, and provided more stereo separation too.
Update:
Reader Malcolm Paterson posted a comment suggesting a stereo widening” technique — subtracting ~6dB worth of the inverted L signal from R, and vice-versa. Here's the result… we'll be playing more with this soon.
The spaced pair is the other of the most common overhead drum miking techniques, although there are an infinite variety of ways to do it.
Perhaps more than any other method tested, the spaced pair approach requires care to avoid phasing problems. As an example, let's say the snare drum resonates at 400Hz. The wavelength of a 400Hz tone is about 33 inches. If one of a pair of haphazardly-placed OH mics is 16.5 inches closer to the snare than the other, then the snare sound will arrive out-of-phase at the two mics, and in mono the 400Hz tone won't be heard.
While it's true that drums resonate at multiple frequencies, phasing problems can nonetheless cause drums to sound thin.
The easiest way to avoid screwing up the snare sound with phasing problems is to put the two capsules of the spaced pair at equal distances from the center of the snare head. This has the added benefit of centering the snare in the stereo image, which is most likely where you want it anyway.
To be fair, this arrangement may well introduce phasing problems with the kick or toms, which is why the OH mic position should always be tested before recording.
The 3:1 rule suggests that the mics should be three times farther apart than their height above the drum kit. In practice, I see engineers worrying more about the distance from the snare than the distance between the mics. Use your ears (and a tape measure too).
Should the mics' capsules be pointed straight down, angled in, angled out, or aimed directly at the snare? It's a matter of taste. Any drums or cymbals that are on-axis — meaning, in the mics' line of sight” — are going to be more clearly heard and probably louder too. Adjust the OH position with an ear toward your final mix.
In this test, the mics were 69'' from the floor, 52'' from the center of the snare, and 58'' apart, with the capsules pointing straight down. I recorded samples in both Cardioid and Omnidirectional modes.
The Cardioid clip gives a wide stereo image. The hi-hat is firmly on the left. The tom fill has some movement, although it seems to start in the middle move to the right. (The panning of close tom mics could of course alter this perception.)
I like the sound of the Cardioid pair; the drums retain their presence without losing the sound of the room. I can hear the space, but I can hear the drums too. It's a good balance.
In Omni, the mics bring in more of the sound of the room, but not so much as in XY. This is probably a result of the fact that in XY, the mics were mostly pointing past the drums. But while this Omni track doesn't offend me, I'd be more likely to choose Cardioid for most applications, and rely on room mics for the room sound.
ORTF is a curious stereo technique with specific positioning requirements: 17cm between capsules, angled 110° apart. I fudged this slightly, owing to haste and my unfortunate reliance on the World's Worst Stereo Mic Bar (produced by On-Stage Stands). Note that the 4400a stereo kit includes a far superior stereo bar that I wish I'd used instead. Alas.
My ORTF pair was 77'' above the floor, 53'' above the snare, positioned so the snare was equidistant from the two mics' capsules.
The sound of this track grew on me over repeated listenings. The drums sound big, but not excessively boomy. The cymbals are well-represented without taking anyone's face off.
The stereo image is not as wide as on the Spaced Pair track, but ORTF sounds more realistic — see below for a head-to-head comparison of ORTF vs. Spaced Pair.
I don't hear any drastic volume changes when I monitor the ORTF track in mono; this suggests a lack of significant phase problems.
I think I'd like ORTF even better if the mics were lower.
Mid-Side
The following two clips are of the same performance; the only difference is a mix-time gain change.
Mid-Side is a stereo technique that promises perfect mono compatibility. It employs a mid” Cardioid mic pointed at the source, and a side” figure-of-8 mic whose null is pointed at the source. The stereo left” channel is the mid plus the side, while the right” channel is the mid minus the side… more or less. (See this video to learn more about mid-side technique)
One of the benefits of mid-side is that adjusting the relative gain of the two signals can alter the perceived width of the stereo image. The louder the side” channel is, the wider the stereo image is. That said, the side channel is comprised entirely of off-axis sounds, which might not sound very good, depending on the instrument and room.
My MS pair was located 71'' above the floor, with the mid” capsule about 52'' from the center of the snare. I produced two samples; the difference between narrow” and wide” is about 8dB worth of gain on the side channel. (The mid channel is about 9dB (RMS) louder than the side channel in the wide” mix, and about 17dB louder than the side channel in the narrow” mix.)
The narrow” mix sounds a lot like XY! The XY track contains more of the sound of the room, due to the height of the XY pair. But the stereo image is similar in size.
Flipping to mono, the narrow” track sounds almost the same as in stereo. There is not much side-channel information in this mix.
The wide” track communicates a greater sense of space, but the change is subtle. And it's not true stereo separation to my ear; rather, the size of the space seems to grow, and the size of the kit seems to grow, but I don't hear the high-hats or floor tom move farther to the outside of the mix.
Mono compatibility is excellent for both these tracks, as expected.
But I'm not fond of this sound. Part of the problem is that the side” channel sounds like a room mic, not like an overhead; I'd rather my stereo image not come at the cost of trashing up the sound of the kit. But as with the Omni samples above, Mid-side would likely work better in a treated room.
The Recorderman” technique is a close-overhead technique that attempts to put both mics equidistant from both the snare and the kick drum. One mic stands about 32'' above the snare, pointing straight down, while the other sits over the drummer's right shoulder, pointing at the snare. Here's a video tutorial
I panned the two tracks hard R/L in this clip, which maximizes the width of the stereo image at the cost of leaving a hole in the middle. Listen to the closing tom fill; it sort of jumps from left to right. But of course this is easy to adjust at mix time.
This clip sounds unlike every other clip on this page. It's punchy, clean, and very dry. All that room sound from the other samples is gone, because the mics are nearly half the distance from the drums as before. (Hello, inverse-square law!)
This sound puts me in the middle of the kit. I love the presence of this sound. The kick drum is tighter-sounding here than in any other clip.
But is it too dry?
Head to head
XY
Mid-side
Recorderman
ORTF
Spaced Pair
The tonal difference is eye-opening. Compare the sound of the cymbal in the first two sections; the XY clip contains much more cymbal ring than does the MS clip. Then hear how the cymbals drop away in the third section (Recorderman) — a much drier, more drum-centric OH configuration.
The ORTF clip sounds tonally similar to Recorderman, but has a wider stereo image. The spaced pair clip is wider still, but introduces a tonal change that I'm not fond of.
XY vs Spaced Pair
The next comparison illustrates the stereo field differences between XY and spaced pair, with both mics in Cardioid mode. This clip contains a 1-bar excerpt from the XY sample, then Spaced, and then the whole thing repeats.
I far prefer the spaced-pair approach. The drum kit, unlike just about every other instrument on stage, is naturally a stereo instrument. (And personally, I do like those big Neil Peart tom fills that go from one corner of the room to another!)
ORTF vs Spaced Pair
The next comparison reveals the stereo field differences between ORTF and Spaced Pair. Just to keep things confusing, this time the excerpts are 2 bars long: a 2-bar clip in ORTF, then Spaced, then ORTF again, then Spaced again.
As mentioned above, the sound of ORTF grew on me. It's not as wide as the Spaced Pair image, but it sounds more realistic. Although I liked the Spaced Pair track in isolation, when I compare it to ORTF, it seems unnatural.
Personal Preferences
The Recorderman” technique has been my go-to OH technique for years, so it is familiar, and a welcome change from what was sounding like excessively room-y overhead tracks. I really like the sound of it, and I like that the mics can be close to the kit without being in the way.
But the ORTF results sounded really good, too, and promises an easier setup. Two mics on a single stand can easily be moved around in space to quickly find a sweet spot for height and angle. I'll definitely be trying ORTF more in the future.
What about Glyn Johns?!
The most obvious missing drum mic technique here is the Glyn Johns” method, about which more can be read here I skipped it primarily because it is not a stereo overhead technique — it's a 4-mic approach for the whole drum kit.
Certainly any of the OH techniques I tried would likely be augmented by close mics on the kick and snare, and possibly tom mics and ambient mics too. But all the techniques I tested give a usable representation of the kit. I'm not sure that would be true with one-half of the Glyn Johns approach.
I also didn't try a Jecklin disk. I've never seen anyone record drums that way, but it sounds like fun. Maybe next time.
Conclusions
A few useful lessons emerged from this process:
A pair of cardioid mics provides several distinct, viable OH sounds.
If the mic placement puts the whole drum kit off-axis, the OH sound will be primarily the sound of the room.
The closer the mics are to the kit, the less room sound you'll hear (and the less preamp gain you'll need).
Avoid phase issues by keeping the snare and kick centered between the mics.
XY and mid-side create the narrowest stereo image; ORTF and spaced pair create a wider image.
Reduce cymbal volume (and room sound) via Recorderman.
As always, the main takeaway is Test and listen!” But you knew that already.
I'd like to hear your lessons, too: is your go-to OH technique dependent on the room, the size of the kit, the style of music? Are there gotchas” not already listed here? When the drummer can't stop pounding the hell out of the cymbals, is it acceptable to simply move them out of his reach?
You have two microphones and two hours. How many ways can you mike a drum kit?
I had a good idea of my choices, but I wanted to hear them all together so I would know what works in my room. It's no different from getting to know your own mic locker; each stereo mic placement technique is a tool, and like any tool it is only useful if you know how to use it.
I made a list of seven stereo mic techniques for drum recording, then recorded myself playing the same thing on the same drums in the same room, as heard through the same pair of microphones — in seven different configurations. Following is a detailed comparison of Spaced Pair (omni and cardioid), Coincident Pair (omni and cardioid), ORTF, Mid-Side and
Recorderman.”
The mics in question were a pair of
SE Electronics' 4400a The 4400a is an incredibly versatile large-diaphragm multipattern FET condenser in a very small form-factor. (We are liking this mike a lot; watch for a full review soon.)
The audio samples below are stereo 320kbps MP3s. I recommend listening in headphones, as the differences among the tracks are easiest to hear if the sound of your own monitoring environment is well-controlled.
Listening with the proper mindset
All the following are legitimate stereo miking techniques (well, except maybe for XY-omni). While you might find a favorite here, be aware that the appropriate technique for any session depends on the drums, the room, the player, the song, and the arrangement. As always.
Nonetheless, this test reveals characteristics of each OH miking technique — such as the width of the stereo field, the intimacy of the kit, the amount of room sound in the mix, the susceptibility to phasing or comb-filtering problems — that bear consideration for every session.
XY (Coincident Pair)
XY is one of the two most common stereo overhead miking techniques. For my test, the mics were in a 90° spread, about 55'' from the center of the snare head and 80'' above the floor.
I recorded samples in both Cardioid and Omnidirectional modes.
Neither of these clips presents a wide stereo image. Listen to the closing tom fill — there is little discernible lateral movement.
The image collapses to mono gracefully; this is expected, given that the mic capsules were close together. Listening in mono also reveals that, in stereo, both clips do present a sense of space — it's small, but it's there. If you don't like hearing tom fills that go from one corner of the room to the other, or if you're recording a song for which the drums play a background role, then XY is a reliable choice.
For me, both these tracks have too much boomy low end. I don't much like either of them.
The omni clip has far too much room sound for my taste. In a space that is either deader or tuned, I think omni is a more viable choice for drum overheads; for example, listen to the omni tracks in my old drum overhead shootout , in which an omni mic brought depth and LF without excessive boom or smeary HF.
Note, too, that the height of the XY pair will alter the sound of the result. I think I would have liked this pair better if I'd lowered the mics to a height of about 60 inches (instead of 80" this would have reduced the apparent volume of the room sound, and provided more stereo separation too.
Update:
Reader Malcolm Paterson posted a comment suggesting a stereo widening” technique — subtracting ~6dB worth of the inverted L signal from R, and vice-versa. Here's the result… we'll be playing more with this soon.
The spaced pair is the other of the most common overhead drum miking techniques, although there are an infinite variety of ways to do it.
Perhaps more than any other method tested, the spaced pair approach requires care to avoid phasing problems. As an example, let's say the snare drum resonates at 400Hz. The wavelength of a 400Hz tone is about 33 inches. If one of a pair of haphazardly-placed OH mics is 16.5 inches closer to the snare than the other, then the snare sound will arrive out-of-phase at the two mics, and in mono the 400Hz tone won't be heard.
While it's true that drums resonate at multiple frequencies, phasing problems can nonetheless cause drums to sound thin.
The easiest way to avoid screwing up the snare sound with phasing problems is to put the two capsules of the spaced pair at equal distances from the center of the snare head. This has the added benefit of centering the snare in the stereo image, which is most likely where you want it anyway.
To be fair, this arrangement may well introduce phasing problems with the kick or toms, which is why the OH mic position should always be tested before recording.
The 3:1 rule suggests that the mics should be three times farther apart than their height above the drum kit. In practice, I see engineers worrying more about the distance from the snare than the distance between the mics. Use your ears (and a tape measure too).
Should the mics' capsules be pointed straight down, angled in, angled out, or aimed directly at the snare? It's a matter of taste. Any drums or cymbals that are on-axis — meaning, in the mics' line of sight” — are going to be more clearly heard and probably louder too. Adjust the OH position with an ear toward your final mix.
In this test, the mics were 69'' from the floor, 52'' from the center of the snare, and 58'' apart, with the capsules pointing straight down. I recorded samples in both Cardioid and Omnidirectional modes.
The Cardioid clip gives a wide stereo image. The hi-hat is firmly on the left. The tom fill has some movement, although it seems to start in the middle move to the right. (The panning of close tom mics could of course alter this perception.)
I like the sound of the Cardioid pair; the drums retain their presence without losing the sound of the room. I can hear the space, but I can hear the drums too. It's a good balance.
In Omni, the mics bring in more of the sound of the room, but not so much as in XY. This is probably a result of the fact that in XY, the mics were mostly pointing past the drums. But while this Omni track doesn't offend me, I'd be more likely to choose Cardioid for most applications, and rely on room mics for the room sound.
ORTF is a curious stereo technique with specific positioning requirements: 17cm between capsules, angled 110° apart. I fudged this slightly, owing to haste and my unfortunate reliance on the World's Worst Stereo Mic Bar (produced by On-Stage Stands). Note that the 4400a stereo kit includes a far superior stereo bar that I wish I'd used instead. Alas.
My ORTF pair was 77'' above the floor, 53'' above the snare, positioned so the snare was equidistant from the two mics' capsules.
The sound of this track grew on me over repeated listenings. The drums sound big, but not excessively boomy. The cymbals are well-represented without taking anyone's face off.
The stereo image is not as wide as on the Spaced Pair track, but ORTF sounds more realistic — see below for a head-to-head comparison of ORTF vs. Spaced Pair.
I don't hear any drastic volume changes when I monitor the ORTF track in mono; this suggests a lack of significant phase problems.
I think I'd like ORTF even better if the mics were lower.
Mid-Side
The following two clips are of the same performance; the only difference is a mix-time gain change.
Mid-Side is a stereo technique that promises perfect mono compatibility. It employs a mid” Cardioid mic pointed at the source, and a side” figure-of-8 mic whose null is pointed at the source. The stereo left” channel is the mid plus the side, while the right” channel is the mid minus the side… more or less. (See this video to learn more about mid-side technique)
One of the benefits of mid-side is that adjusting the relative gain of the two signals can alter the perceived width of the stereo image. The louder the side” channel is, the wider the stereo image is. That said, the side channel is comprised entirely of off-axis sounds, which might not sound very good, depending on the instrument and room.
My MS pair was located 71'' above the floor, with the mid” capsule about 52'' from the center of the snare. I produced two samples; the difference between narrow” and wide” is about 8dB worth of gain on the side channel. (The mid channel is about 9dB (RMS) louder than the side channel in the wide” mix, and about 17dB louder than the side channel in the narrow” mix.)
The narrow” mix sounds a lot like XY! The XY track contains more of the sound of the room, due to the height of the XY pair. But the stereo image is similar in size.
Flipping to mono, the narrow” track sounds almost the same as in stereo. There is not much side-channel information in this mix.
The wide” track communicates a greater sense of space, but the change is subtle. And it's not true stereo separation to my ear; rather, the size of the space seems to grow, and the size of the kit seems to grow, but I don't hear the high-hats or floor tom move farther to the outside of the mix.
Mono compatibility is excellent for both these tracks, as expected.
But I'm not fond of this sound. Part of the problem is that the side” channel sounds like a room mic, not like an overhead; I'd rather my stereo image not come at the cost of trashing up the sound of the kit. But as with the Omni samples above, Mid-side would likely work better in a treated room.
The Recorderman” technique is a close-overhead technique that attempts to put both mics equidistant from both the snare and the kick drum. One mic stands about 32'' above the snare, pointing straight down, while the other sits over the drummer's right shoulder, pointing at the snare. Here's a video tutorial
I panned the two tracks hard R/L in this clip, which maximizes the width of the stereo image at the cost of leaving a hole in the middle. Listen to the closing tom fill; it sort of jumps from left to right. But of course this is easy to adjust at mix time.
This clip sounds unlike every other clip on this page. It's punchy, clean, and very dry. All that room sound from the other samples is gone, because the mics are nearly half the distance from the drums as before. (Hello, inverse-square law!)
This sound puts me in the middle of the kit. I love the presence of this sound. The kick drum is tighter-sounding here than in any other clip.
But is it too dry?
Head to head
XY
Mid-side
Recorderman
ORTF
Spaced Pair
The tonal difference is eye-opening. Compare the sound of the cymbal in the first two sections; the XY clip contains much more cymbal ring than does the MS clip. Then hear how the cymbals drop away in the third section (Recorderman) — a much drier, more drum-centric OH configuration.
The ORTF clip sounds tonally similar to Recorderman, but has a wider stereo image. The spaced pair clip is wider still, but introduces a tonal change that I'm not fond of.
XY vs Spaced Pair
The next comparison illustrates the stereo field differences between XY and spaced pair, with both mics in Cardioid mode. This clip contains a 1-bar excerpt from the XY sample, then Spaced, and then the whole thing repeats.
I far prefer the spaced-pair approach. The drum kit, unlike just about every other instrument on stage, is naturally a stereo instrument. (And personally, I do like those big Neil Peart tom fills that go from one corner of the room to another!)
ORTF vs Spaced Pair
The next comparison reveals the stereo field differences between ORTF and Spaced Pair. Just to keep things confusing, this time the excerpts are 2 bars long: a 2-bar clip in ORTF, then Spaced, then ORTF again, then Spaced again.
As mentioned above, the sound of ORTF grew on me. It's not as wide as the Spaced Pair image, but it sounds more realistic. Although I liked the Spaced Pair track in isolation, when I compare it to ORTF, it seems unnatural.
Personal Preferences
The Recorderman” technique has been my go-to OH technique for years, so it is familiar, and a welcome change from what was sounding like excessively room-y overhead tracks. I really like the sound of it, and I like that the mics can be close to the kit without being in the way.
But the ORTF results sounded really good, too, and promises an easier setup. Two mics on a single stand can easily be moved around in space to quickly find a sweet spot for height and angle. I'll definitely be trying ORTF more in the future.
What about Glyn Johns?!
The most obvious missing drum mic technique here is the Glyn Johns” method, about which more can be read here I skipped it primarily because it is not a stereo overhead technique — it's a 4-mic approach for the whole drum kit.
Certainly any of the OH techniques I tried would likely be augmented by close mics on the kick and snare, and possibly tom mics and ambient mics too. But all the techniques I tested give a usable representation of the kit. I'm not sure that would be true with one-half of the Glyn Johns approach.
I also didn't try a Jecklin disk. I've never seen anyone record drums that way, but it sounds like fun. Maybe next time.
Conclusions
A few useful lessons emerged from this process:
A pair of cardioid mics provides several distinct, viable OH sounds.
If the mic placement puts the whole drum kit off-axis, the OH sound will be primarily the sound of the room.
The closer the mics are to the kit, the less room sound you'll hear (and the less preamp gain you'll need).
Avoid phase issues by keeping the snare and kick centered between the mics.
XY and mid-side create the narrowest stereo image; ORTF and spaced pair create a wider image.
Reduce cymbal volume (and room sound) via Recorderman.
As always, the main takeaway is Test and listen!” But you knew that already.
I'd like to hear your lessons, too: is your go-to OH technique dependent on the room, the size of the kit, the style of music? Are there gotchas” not already listed here? When the drummer can't stop pounding the hell out of the cymbals, is it acceptable to simply move them out of his reach?
Sunday, 23 October 2016
Recorderman Overhead Drum Mic Technique
As an amateur recording engineer, you'll likely run into the name Recorderman when learning how to mic a drum kit. Recorderman's approach to placing overhead drum microphones is recommended for beginners because it's easy to set up, and yields good, sometimes great, results in practically every situation.
The name Recorderman” comes from a user on the forums who is credited with popularizing the technique. (Though his approach has been used by engineers for decades. It's largely a two-mic adaptation of Glyn Johns' mic setup)
Recorderman in a nutshell: Use two drum sticks as a ruler to place your mics the same distance from the snare drum, and a cable or string to get them equidistant from the kick beater.
Here's the best video description I've seen, to better illustrate:
Recorderman's approach accomplishes 3 things:
It places the snare and kick drums in the center of the stereo image.
It ensures any close mics on the kick and snare are in phase with the overheads.
It captures a balanced drum kit sound, close to what the drummer hears.
This microphone setup is ideal in a few situations:
When you have limited microphones for the drums: Especially when you only have 2 or 3 mics, Recorderman can still get you an open, balanced stereo image of the drum kit. If you're recording a talented drummer, 2 or 3 microphones in this arrangement might be all you need.
Recording with low ceilings or in a tight space: Drums sound best in a big, open room. Traditional overhead miking approaches tend to capture a smeared” drum sound when used in small rooms, largely because sound reflections off the ceiling interfere with the direct sound from the drums. Recorderman's technique gets the microphones close enough to the drums that this isn't an issue.
When the drums sound killer at the drummer's position: With decent microphones, this setup usually captures a sound close what the drummer hears. If the drums sound ideal right where the drummer is sitting, you should consider a Recorderman setup even if you're in a high-ceilinged space.
The name Recorderman” comes from a user on the forums who is credited with popularizing the technique. (Though his approach has been used by engineers for decades. It's largely a two-mic adaptation of Glyn Johns' mic setup)
Recorderman in a nutshell: Use two drum sticks as a ruler to place your mics the same distance from the snare drum, and a cable or string to get them equidistant from the kick beater.
Here's the best video description I've seen, to better illustrate:
Recorderman's approach accomplishes 3 things:
It places the snare and kick drums in the center of the stereo image.
It ensures any close mics on the kick and snare are in phase with the overheads.
It captures a balanced drum kit sound, close to what the drummer hears.
This microphone setup is ideal in a few situations:
When you have limited microphones for the drums: Especially when you only have 2 or 3 mics, Recorderman can still get you an open, balanced stereo image of the drum kit. If you're recording a talented drummer, 2 or 3 microphones in this arrangement might be all you need.
Recording with low ceilings or in a tight space: Drums sound best in a big, open room. Traditional overhead miking approaches tend to capture a smeared” drum sound when used in small rooms, largely because sound reflections off the ceiling interfere with the direct sound from the drums. Recorderman's technique gets the microphones close enough to the drums that this isn't an issue.
When the drums sound killer at the drummer's position: With decent microphones, this setup usually captures a sound close what the drummer hears. If the drums sound ideal right where the drummer is sitting, you should consider a Recorderman setup even if you're in a high-ceilinged space.
Tuesday, 18 October 2016
Five Techniques For Stereo Miking Drums
By Matt McGlynn
A single pair of multipattern condenser microphones can provide at least five distinct overhead drum miking choices with surprisingly different sonic characteristics.
To demonstrate these different sounds, we recorded a drum kit with a pair of KSM44A overhead microphones five different ways. The drums, the room, the preamps, cables, and composition remained the same. The only variable was the position of the microphones (and in one case, the polar pattern).
How different can a single pair of microphones, in the same room with the same drums, really sound? As you listen to the tracks below, consider the following:
Width of stereo field
Ease of setup
The XY or coincident pair approach wins points for its guaranteed mono compatibility. Because the two capsules are so close together (coincident”), sound waves from every drum and cymbal impinge upon the two mics' diaphragms nearly simultaneously, avoiding any risk of comb-filtering due to partial cancellation of out-of-phase waves when the two OH tracks are heard in mono.
A consequence of coincident positioning is that the resulting stereo field is narrow, even when the two OH tracks are panned hard L/R. This is a good choice for arrangements in which the drums play a supporting role, or when mono compatibility is critical.
Overhead microphone height is an important consideration in this and every technique. If the mics are very high, the capsules will point straight over the sides of the of the kit, essentially putting the entire instrument off-axis. This will result in an overly roomy sound.
Lowering the microphones, or using an angle less than 90o can result in a more direct sound, although the kick and snare will always be off-axis.
Regardless of height, I recommend mounting the XY array directly above the snare drum, to ensure that the snare is centered in the stereo image.
The M-S technique, like XY, ensures mono compatibility. And like XY, it produces a relatively narrow stereo spread.
A primary benefit is that the perceived size of the space can be changed at mix time, by varying the amount of side” channel in the mix. This is often described as adjusting the stereo width,” but to my ear the drum kit doesn't get any wider. The high and low toms don't get farther apart. The room gets bigger, but the drums sound less direct.
The challenge of M-S is that one of the two microphones is not pointed at the drum kit. The figure-of-8 mic is positioned so the drums are in the mic's null point; the microphone hears only reflected sound. If you are recording drums in a small or untreated room, chances are this reflected sound is not what you want on your record.
But if the room does sound good, M-S is a great way to combine a dry, direct sound — the Mid mic — with as much room ambience as suits the rest of the production.
The Recorderman technique is probably the newest and least-known technique here, although it is conceptually similar to the overhead configuration of Glyn Johns' more-famous approach.
It requires two Cardioid microphones. One is suspended 32” above the center of the snare drum, pointing straight down. The other is positioned near the drummer's right shoulder, pointing directly at the snare drum from 32″ away.
This technique requires that the kick drum is also equidistant from both microphones. This can be checked by taping the two ends of a length of string to the center of the snare and kick drums, respectively. Pinch the string together at the point where it touches the mic above the snare, so that both legs of the string are taut. Move that point of the string in an arc toward the drummer's right shoulder to find the perfect location of the second microphone — at a point where it, too, is 32” from the center of the snare, and equally distant from the kick as is the first microphone.
The two tracks are panned L and R, although not necessarily 100%. Extreme panning of Recorderman overhead tracks can leave a hole in the middle of the stereo field.
Mono compatibility is not guaranteed, except for the kick and snare.
Because the microphones are relatively low, they will hear primarily the drums themselves. Cymbals will be understated, as will the sound of the room.
This is therefore a great way to combat some of the problems that plague live drum recording in home or project studios:
Small, untreated rooms that don't sound great
Untrained drummers who bash their cymbals
Even in large, purpose-built studios, the Recorderman technique is a useful way to capture dry overhead tracks that can be supplemented with more-distant ambient microphones, should the arrangement call for a roomier sound.
With a stereo bar, ORTF becomes very easy to use. Once the two microphones are locked into position — with capsules 17cm apart, at 110o- the single stand can easily be raised, lowered, or angled to tune the array to best suit the size of the kit, the sound of the room, and the desired amount of ambience in the recorded track.
Due to the wide spread of the microphones, it is likely that most of the drum kit will be between them, off-axis. This approach, like mid-side, is less likely to succeed in a small or untreated space, because the microphones will mostly hear reflected sounds. Moving the array closer to the drum kit, whether from behind or over the top, will result in a drier sound.
The ORTF stereo image is wider than XY, MS, or Recorderman, but not unbelievably so. Perhaps because the microphone position simulates human ear position, the resulting stereo field seems very natural and realistic, and generally collapses to mono without significant problems.
AB/Spaced Pair
The AB or Spaced Pair approach is among the simplest stereo techniques to understand, but it presents the most problems in practice.
Because the microphones are far apart, AB arrays are susceptible to comb filtering. The risk can be mitigated somewhat by keeping the two microphone capsules equidistant from the center of the snare drum — but even then, the mic placement should be auditioned (in mono) to reveal possible problems with the kick, toms, or cymbals.
Aside from phase-coherency challenges, AB is a powerful technique, with a large palette of sonic colors. By lowering the array, or angling the microphones in toward the center of the kit, room sound can be minimized. Conversely, there are numerous ways to use an AB pair to capture a roomier, indirect sound: by raising the microphones, moving them further out toward the sides of the kit, angling them to point straight down, or changing from Cardioid to a wider polar pattern.
AB arrays can produce a wide stereo image, simply because drums or cymbals very near one of the two microphones will be perceived to come from only that side of the stereo field.
This can result in an unrealistically large-sounding drum kit, if the overhead tracks are panned 100% L/R.
Head to head Comparison
Drum Miking Cheat Sheet
To minimize room sound, lower the OH microphones and point them toward the center of the kit.
To maximize room sound, raise the OH microphones, angle them away from the drums, or use wider polar patterns.
To minimize cymbal sound, try Recorderman.
To ensure mono compatibility, use XY or MS.
For the widest possible stereo spread, use AB.
Avoid phase coherency problems with kick and snare by keeping them centered between the OH mics.
Dry overhead tracks can be optionally supplemented with room mics.
A pair of cardioid mics provides several distinct, viable OH sounds.
Multipattern LDCs provide even more options.
A single pair of multipattern condenser microphones can provide at least five distinct overhead drum miking choices with surprisingly different sonic characteristics.
To demonstrate these different sounds, we recorded a drum kit with a pair of KSM44A overhead microphones five different ways. The drums, the room, the preamps, cables, and composition remained the same. The only variable was the position of the microphones (and in one case, the polar pattern).
How different can a single pair of microphones, in the same room with the same drums, really sound? As you listen to the tracks below, consider the following:
Width of stereo field
Ease of setup
The XY or coincident pair approach wins points for its guaranteed mono compatibility. Because the two capsules are so close together (coincident”), sound waves from every drum and cymbal impinge upon the two mics' diaphragms nearly simultaneously, avoiding any risk of comb-filtering due to partial cancellation of out-of-phase waves when the two OH tracks are heard in mono.
A consequence of coincident positioning is that the resulting stereo field is narrow, even when the two OH tracks are panned hard L/R. This is a good choice for arrangements in which the drums play a supporting role, or when mono compatibility is critical.
Overhead microphone height is an important consideration in this and every technique. If the mics are very high, the capsules will point straight over the sides of the of the kit, essentially putting the entire instrument off-axis. This will result in an overly roomy sound.
Lowering the microphones, or using an angle less than 90o can result in a more direct sound, although the kick and snare will always be off-axis.
Regardless of height, I recommend mounting the XY array directly above the snare drum, to ensure that the snare is centered in the stereo image.
The M-S technique, like XY, ensures mono compatibility. And like XY, it produces a relatively narrow stereo spread.
A primary benefit is that the perceived size of the space can be changed at mix time, by varying the amount of side” channel in the mix. This is often described as adjusting the stereo width,” but to my ear the drum kit doesn't get any wider. The high and low toms don't get farther apart. The room gets bigger, but the drums sound less direct.
The challenge of M-S is that one of the two microphones is not pointed at the drum kit. The figure-of-8 mic is positioned so the drums are in the mic's null point; the microphone hears only reflected sound. If you are recording drums in a small or untreated room, chances are this reflected sound is not what you want on your record.
But if the room does sound good, M-S is a great way to combine a dry, direct sound — the Mid mic — with as much room ambience as suits the rest of the production.
The Recorderman technique is probably the newest and least-known technique here, although it is conceptually similar to the overhead configuration of Glyn Johns' more-famous approach.
It requires two Cardioid microphones. One is suspended 32” above the center of the snare drum, pointing straight down. The other is positioned near the drummer's right shoulder, pointing directly at the snare drum from 32″ away.
This technique requires that the kick drum is also equidistant from both microphones. This can be checked by taping the two ends of a length of string to the center of the snare and kick drums, respectively. Pinch the string together at the point where it touches the mic above the snare, so that both legs of the string are taut. Move that point of the string in an arc toward the drummer's right shoulder to find the perfect location of the second microphone — at a point where it, too, is 32” from the center of the snare, and equally distant from the kick as is the first microphone.
The two tracks are panned L and R, although not necessarily 100%. Extreme panning of Recorderman overhead tracks can leave a hole in the middle of the stereo field.
Mono compatibility is not guaranteed, except for the kick and snare.
Because the microphones are relatively low, they will hear primarily the drums themselves. Cymbals will be understated, as will the sound of the room.
This is therefore a great way to combat some of the problems that plague live drum recording in home or project studios:
Small, untreated rooms that don't sound great
Untrained drummers who bash their cymbals
Even in large, purpose-built studios, the Recorderman technique is a useful way to capture dry overhead tracks that can be supplemented with more-distant ambient microphones, should the arrangement call for a roomier sound.
With a stereo bar, ORTF becomes very easy to use. Once the two microphones are locked into position — with capsules 17cm apart, at 110o- the single stand can easily be raised, lowered, or angled to tune the array to best suit the size of the kit, the sound of the room, and the desired amount of ambience in the recorded track.
Due to the wide spread of the microphones, it is likely that most of the drum kit will be between them, off-axis. This approach, like mid-side, is less likely to succeed in a small or untreated space, because the microphones will mostly hear reflected sounds. Moving the array closer to the drum kit, whether from behind or over the top, will result in a drier sound.
The ORTF stereo image is wider than XY, MS, or Recorderman, but not unbelievably so. Perhaps because the microphone position simulates human ear position, the resulting stereo field seems very natural and realistic, and generally collapses to mono without significant problems.
AB/Spaced Pair
The AB or Spaced Pair approach is among the simplest stereo techniques to understand, but it presents the most problems in practice.
Because the microphones are far apart, AB arrays are susceptible to comb filtering. The risk can be mitigated somewhat by keeping the two microphone capsules equidistant from the center of the snare drum — but even then, the mic placement should be auditioned (in mono) to reveal possible problems with the kick, toms, or cymbals.
Aside from phase-coherency challenges, AB is a powerful technique, with a large palette of sonic colors. By lowering the array, or angling the microphones in toward the center of the kit, room sound can be minimized. Conversely, there are numerous ways to use an AB pair to capture a roomier, indirect sound: by raising the microphones, moving them further out toward the sides of the kit, angling them to point straight down, or changing from Cardioid to a wider polar pattern.
AB arrays can produce a wide stereo image, simply because drums or cymbals very near one of the two microphones will be perceived to come from only that side of the stereo field.
This can result in an unrealistically large-sounding drum kit, if the overhead tracks are panned 100% L/R.
Head to head Comparison
Drum Miking Cheat Sheet
To minimize room sound, lower the OH microphones and point them toward the center of the kit.
To maximize room sound, raise the OH microphones, angle them away from the drums, or use wider polar patterns.
To minimize cymbal sound, try Recorderman.
To ensure mono compatibility, use XY or MS.
For the widest possible stereo spread, use AB.
Avoid phase coherency problems with kick and snare by keeping them centered between the OH mics.
Dry overhead tracks can be optionally supplemented with room mics.
A pair of cardioid mics provides several distinct, viable OH sounds.
Multipattern LDCs provide even more options.
Sunday, 16 October 2016
Miking The Drumset In Your Home Recording Studio
If you're like most musicians, getting great-sounding drum recordings seems like one of the world's great mysteries. You can hear big, fat drums on great albums, but when you try to record your drums, they always end up sounding more like cardboard boxes than drums. Fret not — here are some solutions for you.
The room
The room influences the drums' sound more than it influences other instruments'. If you're looking for a big drum sound, you need a fairly live room (one with lots of reflection).
You may be thinking, "But I just have a bedroom for a studio and it's carpeted." No worries, you can work with that. Remember, you have a home studio, so you potentially have your whole home to work with. Here are a couple of ideas to spark your imagination:
Buy three or four 4-x-8-foot sheets of plywood and lean them up against the walls of your room. Also place one on the floor just in front of the kick drum. This adds some reflective surfaces to the room.
Put the drums in your garage (or living room, or any other room with a reverberating sound) and run long mic cords to your mixer. If you have a studio-in-a-box system, you can just throw it under your arm and move everything into your garage or, better yet, take all this stuff to a really great-sounding room and record.
Set up your drums in a nice-sounding room and place an additional mic just outside the door to catch an additional ambient sound. You can then mix this in with the other drum tracks to add a different quality of reverberation to the drums.
Kick (bass) drum
The mic of choice for most recording engineers when recording a kick drum is a dynamic mic. In fact, you can find some large diaphragm dynamic mics specifically designed to record kick drums.
No matter where you place the mic, you can reduce the amount of boominess that you get from the drum by placing a pillow or blanket inside the drum. Some people choose to let the pillow or blanket touch the inside head.
That said, you can place your mic in several ways (all conveniently illustrated in Figure 1):
Near the inside head: If you take off the outside head or cut a hole in it, you can stick the mic inside the drum. Place the mic 2 to 3 inches away from the inside head and a couple of inches off center. This is the standard way to mic a kick drum if you have the outside head off or if a hole is cut in it. This placement gives you a sharp attack from the beater hitting the head.
Halfway inside the drum: You can modify the preceding miking technique by moving the mic back so that it's about halfway inside the drum. In this case, place the mic right in the middle, pointing where the beater strikes the drum. This placement gives you less of the attack of the beater striking the head and more of the body of the drum's sound.
Near the outside head: If you have both heads on the drum, you can place the mic a few inches from the outside head. If you want a more open, boomy sound (and you have the drum's pitch set fairly high), point the mic directly at the center of the head. If you want less boom, offset the mic a little and point it about two-thirds of the way toward the center.
The kick drum responds quite well to a compressor when tracking. For the most part, you can get by with settings that allow the initial attack to get through and that tame the boom a little. A sample setting looks like this:
Threshold: -6dB
Attack: Between 40 ms and 50 ms
Release: Between 200 ms and 300 ms
Gain: Adjust so that the output level matches the input level. You don't need much added gain.
Snare drum
The snare drum is probably the most important drum in popular music. The bass guitar can cover the kick drum's rhythm, and the rest of the drums aren't part of the main groove. A good, punchy snare drum can make a track, whereas a weak, thin one can eliminate the drive that most popular music needs.
Because the snare drum is located so close to the other drums, especially the hi-hats, a cardioid pattern mic is a must. The most common mic for a snare drum is the trusty Shure SM57. The mic is generally placed between the hi-hats and the small tom-tom about 1 or 2 inches from the snare drum head (see Figure 2). Point the diaphragm directly at the head.
You may need to make some minor adjustments to eliminate any bleed from the hi-hats. This position gives you a nice punchy sound.
Adding compression to the snare drum is crucial if you want a tight, punchy sound. There are a lot of ways to go with the snare. The following settings are common and versatile:
Threshold: -4dB
Attack: Between 5 ms and 10 ms
Release: Between 125 ms and 175 ms
Gain: Adjust so that the output level matches the input level. You don't need much added gain.
Tom-toms
The tom-toms sound best when using a dynamic mic. For the mounted toms (the ones above the kick drum), you can use one or two mics. If you use one mic, place it between the two drums about 4 to 6 inches away from the heads (Figure 3 shows this placement option). If you use two mics, place one above each drum about 1 to 3 inches above the head.
Floor toms are miked the same way as the mounted tom-toms:
Place a single mic a couple of inches away from the head near the rim.
If you have more than one floor tom, you can place one mic between them or mic them individually.
If you want to apply compression to the tom-toms, you can start with the settings that for the snare drum in the preceding section.
Hi-hats
The hi-hats are generally part of the main groove and, as such, you want to spend time getting a good sound. You'll probably have problems with a few other mics on the drumset picking up the hi-hats, particularly the snare drum mic and overhead mics. Some people don't bother miking the hi-hats for this reason.
Hi-hats often sound too trashy through the snare drum mic. If you mic hi-hats, make sure that the snare drum mic is picking up as little of the hi-hats as possible by placing it properly and/or using a noise gate (a dynamic processor use to filter unwanted noise).
You can use either a dynamic mic or, better yet, a small diaphragm condenser mic for the hi-hats. The dynamic mic gives you a trashier sound and the small diaphragm condenser mic produces a bright sound. You can work with either by adjusting the EQ. Try adding just a little bit (4dB or so) of a shelf EQ set at 10 kHz to add just a little sheen to the hi-hats.
Place the mic about 3 to 4 inches above the hi-hats and point it down. The exact placement of the mic is less important than the placement of the other instrument mics because of the hi-hats' tone. Just make sure your mic isn't so close that you hit it.
Compression isn't usually necessary when tracking the hi-hats unless you have a drummer whose volume level is inconsistent. In this case, try using the same snare drum settings.
Cymbals
You want to know one secret to the huge drum sound of Led Zeppelin's drummer, John Bonham? Finesse. He understood that the drums sound louder and bigger in a mix if the cymbals are quieter in comparison. So he played his cymbals softly and hit the drums pretty hard. This allowed the engineer to raise up the levels of the drums without having the
cymbals drown everything else out. Absolutely brilliant.
Because the drums bleeding into the overhead mics is inevitable and the overhead mics are responsible for providing much of the drums' presence in a mix, playing the cymbals softly allows you to get more of the drums in these mics. This helps the drums sound bigger.
Ask (no, demand) that your drummer play the cymbals quieter. Also use smaller cymbals with a fast attack and a short decay. Doing these things creates a better balance between the drums and cymbals and makes the drums stand out more in comparison.
Small diaphragm condenser mics capture the cymbals' high frequencies well. You can mic the cymbals by placing mics about 6 inches above each cymbal or by using overhead mics set 1 to 3 feet above the cymbals.
The whole kit
Most of the time, you want to have at least one (but preferably two) ambient mics on the drums if for no other reason than to pick up the cymbals. These (assuming you use two mics) are called overhead mics and, as the name implies, they are placed above the drumset. The most common types of mics to use for overheads are large and small diaphragm condenser mics because they pick up the high frequencies in the cymbals and give the drumset's sound a nice sheen (brightness). You also may want to try a pair of ribbon mics to pick up a nice, sweet sound on the overheads.
To mic the drumset with overhead mics, you can use either the X-Y coincident technique or spaced stereo pairs. Place them 1 to 2 feet above the cymbals, just forward of the drummer's head. Place X-Y mics in the center and set up spaced stereo pairs so that they follow the 3:1 rule (the mics should be set up 3 to 6 feet apart if they are 1 to 2 feet above the cymbals). This counters any phase problems. Point the mic down toward theFigure 4: Overhead mics capture the cymbals and the drums. drums and you're ready to record.
The room
The room influences the drums' sound more than it influences other instruments'. If you're looking for a big drum sound, you need a fairly live room (one with lots of reflection).
You may be thinking, "But I just have a bedroom for a studio and it's carpeted." No worries, you can work with that. Remember, you have a home studio, so you potentially have your whole home to work with. Here are a couple of ideas to spark your imagination:
Buy three or four 4-x-8-foot sheets of plywood and lean them up against the walls of your room. Also place one on the floor just in front of the kick drum. This adds some reflective surfaces to the room.
Put the drums in your garage (or living room, or any other room with a reverberating sound) and run long mic cords to your mixer. If you have a studio-in-a-box system, you can just throw it under your arm and move everything into your garage or, better yet, take all this stuff to a really great-sounding room and record.
Set up your drums in a nice-sounding room and place an additional mic just outside the door to catch an additional ambient sound. You can then mix this in with the other drum tracks to add a different quality of reverberation to the drums.
Kick (bass) drum
The mic of choice for most recording engineers when recording a kick drum is a dynamic mic. In fact, you can find some large diaphragm dynamic mics specifically designed to record kick drums.
No matter where you place the mic, you can reduce the amount of boominess that you get from the drum by placing a pillow or blanket inside the drum. Some people choose to let the pillow or blanket touch the inside head.
That said, you can place your mic in several ways (all conveniently illustrated in Figure 1):
Near the inside head: If you take off the outside head or cut a hole in it, you can stick the mic inside the drum. Place the mic 2 to 3 inches away from the inside head and a couple of inches off center. This is the standard way to mic a kick drum if you have the outside head off or if a hole is cut in it. This placement gives you a sharp attack from the beater hitting the head.
Halfway inside the drum: You can modify the preceding miking technique by moving the mic back so that it's about halfway inside the drum. In this case, place the mic right in the middle, pointing where the beater strikes the drum. This placement gives you less of the attack of the beater striking the head and more of the body of the drum's sound.
Near the outside head: If you have both heads on the drum, you can place the mic a few inches from the outside head. If you want a more open, boomy sound (and you have the drum's pitch set fairly high), point the mic directly at the center of the head. If you want less boom, offset the mic a little and point it about two-thirds of the way toward the center.
The kick drum responds quite well to a compressor when tracking. For the most part, you can get by with settings that allow the initial attack to get through and that tame the boom a little. A sample setting looks like this:
Threshold: -6dB
Attack: Between 40 ms and 50 ms
Release: Between 200 ms and 300 ms
Gain: Adjust so that the output level matches the input level. You don't need much added gain.
Snare drum
The snare drum is probably the most important drum in popular music. The bass guitar can cover the kick drum's rhythm, and the rest of the drums aren't part of the main groove. A good, punchy snare drum can make a track, whereas a weak, thin one can eliminate the drive that most popular music needs.
Because the snare drum is located so close to the other drums, especially the hi-hats, a cardioid pattern mic is a must. The most common mic for a snare drum is the trusty Shure SM57. The mic is generally placed between the hi-hats and the small tom-tom about 1 or 2 inches from the snare drum head (see Figure 2). Point the diaphragm directly at the head.
You may need to make some minor adjustments to eliminate any bleed from the hi-hats. This position gives you a nice punchy sound.
Adding compression to the snare drum is crucial if you want a tight, punchy sound. There are a lot of ways to go with the snare. The following settings are common and versatile:
Threshold: -4dB
Attack: Between 5 ms and 10 ms
Release: Between 125 ms and 175 ms
Gain: Adjust so that the output level matches the input level. You don't need much added gain.
Tom-toms
The tom-toms sound best when using a dynamic mic. For the mounted toms (the ones above the kick drum), you can use one or two mics. If you use one mic, place it between the two drums about 4 to 6 inches away from the heads (Figure 3 shows this placement option). If you use two mics, place one above each drum about 1 to 3 inches above the head.
Floor toms are miked the same way as the mounted tom-toms:
Place a single mic a couple of inches away from the head near the rim.
If you have more than one floor tom, you can place one mic between them or mic them individually.
If you want to apply compression to the tom-toms, you can start with the settings that for the snare drum in the preceding section.
Hi-hats
The hi-hats are generally part of the main groove and, as such, you want to spend time getting a good sound. You'll probably have problems with a few other mics on the drumset picking up the hi-hats, particularly the snare drum mic and overhead mics. Some people don't bother miking the hi-hats for this reason.
Hi-hats often sound too trashy through the snare drum mic. If you mic hi-hats, make sure that the snare drum mic is picking up as little of the hi-hats as possible by placing it properly and/or using a noise gate (a dynamic processor use to filter unwanted noise).
You can use either a dynamic mic or, better yet, a small diaphragm condenser mic for the hi-hats. The dynamic mic gives you a trashier sound and the small diaphragm condenser mic produces a bright sound. You can work with either by adjusting the EQ. Try adding just a little bit (4dB or so) of a shelf EQ set at 10 kHz to add just a little sheen to the hi-hats.
Place the mic about 3 to 4 inches above the hi-hats and point it down. The exact placement of the mic is less important than the placement of the other instrument mics because of the hi-hats' tone. Just make sure your mic isn't so close that you hit it.
Compression isn't usually necessary when tracking the hi-hats unless you have a drummer whose volume level is inconsistent. In this case, try using the same snare drum settings.
Cymbals
You want to know one secret to the huge drum sound of Led Zeppelin's drummer, John Bonham? Finesse. He understood that the drums sound louder and bigger in a mix if the cymbals are quieter in comparison. So he played his cymbals softly and hit the drums pretty hard. This allowed the engineer to raise up the levels of the drums without having the
cymbals drown everything else out. Absolutely brilliant.
Because the drums bleeding into the overhead mics is inevitable and the overhead mics are responsible for providing much of the drums' presence in a mix, playing the cymbals softly allows you to get more of the drums in these mics. This helps the drums sound bigger.
Ask (no, demand) that your drummer play the cymbals quieter. Also use smaller cymbals with a fast attack and a short decay. Doing these things creates a better balance between the drums and cymbals and makes the drums stand out more in comparison.
Small diaphragm condenser mics capture the cymbals' high frequencies well. You can mic the cymbals by placing mics about 6 inches above each cymbal or by using overhead mics set 1 to 3 feet above the cymbals.
The whole kit
Most of the time, you want to have at least one (but preferably two) ambient mics on the drums if for no other reason than to pick up the cymbals. These (assuming you use two mics) are called overhead mics and, as the name implies, they are placed above the drumset. The most common types of mics to use for overheads are large and small diaphragm condenser mics because they pick up the high frequencies in the cymbals and give the drumset's sound a nice sheen (brightness). You also may want to try a pair of ribbon mics to pick up a nice, sweet sound on the overheads.
To mic the drumset with overhead mics, you can use either the X-Y coincident technique or spaced stereo pairs. Place them 1 to 2 feet above the cymbals, just forward of the drummer's head. Place X-Y mics in the center and set up spaced stereo pairs so that they follow the 3:1 rule (the mics should be set up 3 to 6 feet apart if they are 1 to 2 feet above the cymbals). This counters any phase problems. Point the mic down toward theFigure 4: Overhead mics capture the cymbals and the drums. drums and you're ready to record.
Saturday, 15 October 2016
How To Record Drums
Recording a live drummer can be lots of fun when done right. At Platinumloops, we've recorded many different drummers in many different locations, sometimes in challenging circumstances.
There are a few things you can do to prepare for ‘on location' recording in order to get the best results.
Your two main objectives are to get the best performance from the drummer and also to get the best sound from the drum kit and the room.
Before starting a session, arm yourself with these essential resources.
1 - Moon Gel
3 - Gaffa Tape
4 - Some Really robust headphones with thick enclosures and long cable.
5 - A couple of tuning keys
6 - Some high quality lubricating oil - not WD40
7 - A headphone amp with stereo in and out.
8 - Some deodorant spray - things can get sweaty
9 - Lots of drinking water
10 - A thick rug or piece of carpet
11 - Some earplugs for both you and the drummer
The Recording Situation
An ideal situation for recording drums is for the drummer to be in a separate live room to the sound engineer. This allows the engineer to monitor the microphone inputs without being deafened by the shed builder on the other side of the glass, however you might not have that luxury.
Recording while in the same room as the drummer does have its benefits. First of all, the communication between engineer and drummer is far better, you can be sat right next to the drummer and it makes for much faster workflow and can often make the drummer feel more comfortable and less isolated.
In addition to this the engineer can often hear unwanted sounds within the room much better than from a control room which he/she otherwise might not notice until the session is over.
Communicating From the Control Room
The downside to recording within the same room as the drummer is obvious ear fatigue and the fact that you can only really monitor the mic inputs properly on playback while the drummer has stopped playing.
If you have a separate live room to the control room but no window between the two, you can easily setup a couple of web cams via wireless internet or use tablets and phones so that you and the drummer can communicate visually.
You'll here the drummer through the mic's when he talks and he will be able to hear you if you patch a mic in to his headphone amp.
The wonders of modern technology eh!
Setting Up
I strongly advise that you learn how to tune a drum kit yourself. I used to be a drummer (a very bad one) so I learned the basics of this years ago. There are some brilliant video tutorials on Youtube that helped to improve my drum tuning skills. If your drummer is really good, they'll know how best to tune the kit and how much life is left in the drum skins (heads).
If your room has a nice wooden floor, you're going to want to protect it with a thick rug or a piece of carpet. You can also buy those rubber floor protectors that will prevent your floor from getting scratched by the rough underside of the rug or carpet.
The carpet also prevents the entire drum kit from moving forwards every time your drummer hits the kick drum. If he's a metal drummer he's going to be hitting it pretty hard.
With the kit setup and tuned, get your drummer to play for a while before you even think about setting up the mic's. What your listening for here are two things.
1 - Firstly, mechanical noises from the kit - such as squeaky pedals, drum stools, rattling tom mounts. I can pretty much guarantee at least one of these noises will rear it's ugly head.
2 - The second thing your listening for are noises from the room - such as vibrating furniture, fixtures and appliances.
You might also want to experiment with the placement of the kit. Start off in the middle of the room and then move the kit to either end to compare the room sound, this is where the carpet/rug comes in handy as you can carefully just drag the whole thing wherever you want it.
Walk around the room while the drummer plays to find the sweat spot for the room ambience, this is where we'll place a mic to add hugeness” to the sound if that's what you're after. If you have a stair case or hallway at the end of the live room, try listening to that space for the sweat spot.
We'll do some more of this later when we crack the mic's out, for now it's all about where to place the kit for the best room sound.
Blu Tack to the Rescue
If you're wondering what the Blu Tack and gaffa tape are for, you'll have figured that out pretty much as soon as the drummer starts playing. Tom mounts are notoriously rattly and creaky, especially in older drum kits or cheaper drum kits.
Use the blu Tack to stuff into the gaps on the tom mounts to silence the rattling, you'll be surprised how much you'll use. Blu Tack is also really good because it doesn't leave much of a residue on the drum hardware and your drummer will thank you for that.
When we recorded our Ultra Metal Drum Loops V1 , we used a spectacular sounding Premiere PK Cabria Drum Kit with Sabian and Zildjian cymbals and a Pearl double kick pedal.
Unfortunately the tom mounts rattled and squeaked so badly that we ended up using two full packs of Blu Tack to silence the pesky things - and this was a brand new kit.
For our Power Ballad Rock Drum Loops V1 we used a brand new Mapex M-Birch kit that had a far superior tom mount system that needed no such Blu Tack treatment. The birch kit was much louder and the hardware was easier to use with no nasty noises to content with. We liked this kit so much that we kept it as our stock studio kit.
The Snare Drum
The gaffa tape is essential to use as a dampener on the snare. If you're recording a funk drummer or a rock drummer that wants a really tight and ‘pingy' snare with minimal rattle, you're going to need to reduce the snare buzz. Use a 6 inch piece of gaffa tape across the centre of the snare then add more if required.
If you want a very natural, roomy kit sound, you might be able to get away without dampening the top head on the snare drum. We like snare drums to be tuned really high so that they cut through the mix, but this tends to make them more prone to resonating when playing other parts of the kit.
To counteract this problem use one or two chunks of moon gel to dampen the resonating top skin. It'll still sound good but won't ring on every time the drummer stamps on the kick drum pedal.
The Kick Drum
Use some heavy duty lubricating oil or grease on the Kick drum pedal and maybe even on the hi-hat pedal. Even once the squeak has gone you still might get some rattle from the kick pedal so get the drummer to adjust the tension on the pedal so that you get a happy compromise of playability and quietness.
An ideal situation is to have a few other pedals on hand just in case, but if the drummer is using a double beater that's not very likely.
The squeaky drum pedal has been the cause of many delayed sessions, so it helps if your drummer is able to be flexible with the pedal tension. Better still, ask your drummer to make sure it's perfectly quiet before they arrive. Time is money.
The beater on the kick drum pedal is also an often overlooked factor. Your drummer might not like the feel of a wooden or plastic beater but you might prefer the sharp clicky sound that it gives you.
If this is going to effect your drummers performance, you're going to have to give way and let them use the felt beater. Try adjusting the height of the beater for both playability and sound quality. You want to get as much definition and punch from the kick drum as possible without making it difficult for the drummer to play.
Tom Toms
Tuning toms is an art form in itself. We won't get into the details of how to tune toms, you can find hundreds of instructional videos on Youtube for that. Let's focus instead on how to overcome some common problems you might experience when recording toms.
It's more than likely that your toms will need some form of dampening to prevent them from resonating every time the drummer hits the kick. After you've spent the last hour tuning them to perfection, you'll feel like crying when you hear how crap they sound after you've slapped a couple of moon gel patches on the top skin.
Don't despair. They might sound a bit lame with the dampening on but by the time you've mixed the kit, added a bit of compression to the toms and then a bit more to the overall stereo kit, they'll sound fantastic again and you wont have as many ‘resonating problems'.
One other problem with toms is that you'll usually find one tom is much louder than the others, namely the hi-tom. You can overcome this with tuning but that's going to compromise that cool tone. Your only option is to leave it up to the drummer to try and balance them out with his playing - that, and shed loads of compression during the mix stage of course.
Balance out the Volume
Finally, listen for imbalances in the volume of the separate kit parts. Even after what I just said about the toms, don't be tempted to leave certain problems up to the mix because there are some things you just cant fix.
For example, rock drummers tend be really heavy on the hi-hat and no matter what you do during the mixing stage, you're going to find it difficult to get the snare sounding sharp and bright without inadvertently boosting the already over loud hi-hat that's bleeding through onto all the mic's.
This is where having a quieter set of hi-hats can be a godsend. Your aim is to get your transient levels as even as possible before you even record. If one of the toms is louder than the entire kit try re-tuning it, adding some dampening with moon gel or even replacing it. The same goes for your cymbals. If your crash cymbals dominate the entire drum mix, you're going to have serious problems down the line.
You can always ask your drummer not to hit certain parts of the kit quite so hard but that's like asking Lewis Hamilton not to drive fast.
Mic'ing Up
Now that you've got the kit and room sounding splendid, the next stage is to bring in the mic's. Assuming you've only got 8 audio inputs in your audio interface you'll need to prioritize.
If your drummer is playing a 5 piece kit, you're probably best to use 7 mic's on the kit and one mic in the sweat spot of the room if you want some room ambience in the mix.
If you're after a tight, closed in sound and you're not bothered about room ambience, bring that 8th mic back in and place it on the hi-hat or some other part of the kit you feel is important. Here's how I would mic up a 5 piece kit.
Kick Drum - AKG D112
Room Ambience - SE Electronics Z3300A
This setup means that my hi-hat, cymbals and ride will primarily get picked up by the 2 overheads and the room mic. In most cases this is perfectly fine but obviously we'd have more control of the mix if we had more inputs and more mic's. This just illustrates how to get the most of an 8 channel situation.
Some people don't like to use condenser mic's for recording drums due to the way they struggle with extreme transients, but I make sure the Z3300A is a long way from the kit and all I can say is that it sounds lush is a room ambience mic.
There are a few things you can do to prepare for ‘on location' recording in order to get the best results.
Your two main objectives are to get the best performance from the drummer and also to get the best sound from the drum kit and the room.
Before starting a session, arm yourself with these essential resources.
1 - Moon Gel
3 - Gaffa Tape
4 - Some Really robust headphones with thick enclosures and long cable.
5 - A couple of tuning keys
6 - Some high quality lubricating oil - not WD40
7 - A headphone amp with stereo in and out.
8 - Some deodorant spray - things can get sweaty
9 - Lots of drinking water
10 - A thick rug or piece of carpet
11 - Some earplugs for both you and the drummer
The Recording Situation
An ideal situation for recording drums is for the drummer to be in a separate live room to the sound engineer. This allows the engineer to monitor the microphone inputs without being deafened by the shed builder on the other side of the glass, however you might not have that luxury.
Recording while in the same room as the drummer does have its benefits. First of all, the communication between engineer and drummer is far better, you can be sat right next to the drummer and it makes for much faster workflow and can often make the drummer feel more comfortable and less isolated.
In addition to this the engineer can often hear unwanted sounds within the room much better than from a control room which he/she otherwise might not notice until the session is over.
Communicating From the Control Room
The downside to recording within the same room as the drummer is obvious ear fatigue and the fact that you can only really monitor the mic inputs properly on playback while the drummer has stopped playing.
If you have a separate live room to the control room but no window between the two, you can easily setup a couple of web cams via wireless internet or use tablets and phones so that you and the drummer can communicate visually.
You'll here the drummer through the mic's when he talks and he will be able to hear you if you patch a mic in to his headphone amp.
The wonders of modern technology eh!
Setting Up
I strongly advise that you learn how to tune a drum kit yourself. I used to be a drummer (a very bad one) so I learned the basics of this years ago. There are some brilliant video tutorials on Youtube that helped to improve my drum tuning skills. If your drummer is really good, they'll know how best to tune the kit and how much life is left in the drum skins (heads).
If your room has a nice wooden floor, you're going to want to protect it with a thick rug or a piece of carpet. You can also buy those rubber floor protectors that will prevent your floor from getting scratched by the rough underside of the rug or carpet.
The carpet also prevents the entire drum kit from moving forwards every time your drummer hits the kick drum. If he's a metal drummer he's going to be hitting it pretty hard.
With the kit setup and tuned, get your drummer to play for a while before you even think about setting up the mic's. What your listening for here are two things.
1 - Firstly, mechanical noises from the kit - such as squeaky pedals, drum stools, rattling tom mounts. I can pretty much guarantee at least one of these noises will rear it's ugly head.
2 - The second thing your listening for are noises from the room - such as vibrating furniture, fixtures and appliances.
You might also want to experiment with the placement of the kit. Start off in the middle of the room and then move the kit to either end to compare the room sound, this is where the carpet/rug comes in handy as you can carefully just drag the whole thing wherever you want it.
Walk around the room while the drummer plays to find the sweat spot for the room ambience, this is where we'll place a mic to add hugeness” to the sound if that's what you're after. If you have a stair case or hallway at the end of the live room, try listening to that space for the sweat spot.
We'll do some more of this later when we crack the mic's out, for now it's all about where to place the kit for the best room sound.
Blu Tack to the Rescue
If you're wondering what the Blu Tack and gaffa tape are for, you'll have figured that out pretty much as soon as the drummer starts playing. Tom mounts are notoriously rattly and creaky, especially in older drum kits or cheaper drum kits.
Use the blu Tack to stuff into the gaps on the tom mounts to silence the rattling, you'll be surprised how much you'll use. Blu Tack is also really good because it doesn't leave much of a residue on the drum hardware and your drummer will thank you for that.
When we recorded our Ultra Metal Drum Loops V1 , we used a spectacular sounding Premiere PK Cabria Drum Kit with Sabian and Zildjian cymbals and a Pearl double kick pedal.
Unfortunately the tom mounts rattled and squeaked so badly that we ended up using two full packs of Blu Tack to silence the pesky things - and this was a brand new kit.
For our Power Ballad Rock Drum Loops V1 we used a brand new Mapex M-Birch kit that had a far superior tom mount system that needed no such Blu Tack treatment. The birch kit was much louder and the hardware was easier to use with no nasty noises to content with. We liked this kit so much that we kept it as our stock studio kit.
The Snare Drum
The gaffa tape is essential to use as a dampener on the snare. If you're recording a funk drummer or a rock drummer that wants a really tight and ‘pingy' snare with minimal rattle, you're going to need to reduce the snare buzz. Use a 6 inch piece of gaffa tape across the centre of the snare then add more if required.
If you want a very natural, roomy kit sound, you might be able to get away without dampening the top head on the snare drum. We like snare drums to be tuned really high so that they cut through the mix, but this tends to make them more prone to resonating when playing other parts of the kit.
To counteract this problem use one or two chunks of moon gel to dampen the resonating top skin. It'll still sound good but won't ring on every time the drummer stamps on the kick drum pedal.
The Kick Drum
Use some heavy duty lubricating oil or grease on the Kick drum pedal and maybe even on the hi-hat pedal. Even once the squeak has gone you still might get some rattle from the kick pedal so get the drummer to adjust the tension on the pedal so that you get a happy compromise of playability and quietness.
An ideal situation is to have a few other pedals on hand just in case, but if the drummer is using a double beater that's not very likely.
The squeaky drum pedal has been the cause of many delayed sessions, so it helps if your drummer is able to be flexible with the pedal tension. Better still, ask your drummer to make sure it's perfectly quiet before they arrive. Time is money.
The beater on the kick drum pedal is also an often overlooked factor. Your drummer might not like the feel of a wooden or plastic beater but you might prefer the sharp clicky sound that it gives you.
If this is going to effect your drummers performance, you're going to have to give way and let them use the felt beater. Try adjusting the height of the beater for both playability and sound quality. You want to get as much definition and punch from the kick drum as possible without making it difficult for the drummer to play.
Tom Toms
Tuning toms is an art form in itself. We won't get into the details of how to tune toms, you can find hundreds of instructional videos on Youtube for that. Let's focus instead on how to overcome some common problems you might experience when recording toms.
It's more than likely that your toms will need some form of dampening to prevent them from resonating every time the drummer hits the kick. After you've spent the last hour tuning them to perfection, you'll feel like crying when you hear how crap they sound after you've slapped a couple of moon gel patches on the top skin.
Don't despair. They might sound a bit lame with the dampening on but by the time you've mixed the kit, added a bit of compression to the toms and then a bit more to the overall stereo kit, they'll sound fantastic again and you wont have as many ‘resonating problems'.
One other problem with toms is that you'll usually find one tom is much louder than the others, namely the hi-tom. You can overcome this with tuning but that's going to compromise that cool tone. Your only option is to leave it up to the drummer to try and balance them out with his playing - that, and shed loads of compression during the mix stage of course.
Balance out the Volume
Finally, listen for imbalances in the volume of the separate kit parts. Even after what I just said about the toms, don't be tempted to leave certain problems up to the mix because there are some things you just cant fix.
For example, rock drummers tend be really heavy on the hi-hat and no matter what you do during the mixing stage, you're going to find it difficult to get the snare sounding sharp and bright without inadvertently boosting the already over loud hi-hat that's bleeding through onto all the mic's.
This is where having a quieter set of hi-hats can be a godsend. Your aim is to get your transient levels as even as possible before you even record. If one of the toms is louder than the entire kit try re-tuning it, adding some dampening with moon gel or even replacing it. The same goes for your cymbals. If your crash cymbals dominate the entire drum mix, you're going to have serious problems down the line.
You can always ask your drummer not to hit certain parts of the kit quite so hard but that's like asking Lewis Hamilton not to drive fast.
Mic'ing Up
Now that you've got the kit and room sounding splendid, the next stage is to bring in the mic's. Assuming you've only got 8 audio inputs in your audio interface you'll need to prioritize.
If your drummer is playing a 5 piece kit, you're probably best to use 7 mic's on the kit and one mic in the sweat spot of the room if you want some room ambience in the mix.
If you're after a tight, closed in sound and you're not bothered about room ambience, bring that 8th mic back in and place it on the hi-hat or some other part of the kit you feel is important. Here's how I would mic up a 5 piece kit.
Kick Drum - AKG D112
Room Ambience - SE Electronics Z3300A
This setup means that my hi-hat, cymbals and ride will primarily get picked up by the 2 overheads and the room mic. In most cases this is perfectly fine but obviously we'd have more control of the mix if we had more inputs and more mic's. This just illustrates how to get the most of an 8 channel situation.
Some people don't like to use condenser mic's for recording drums due to the way they struggle with extreme transients, but I make sure the Z3300A is a long way from the kit and all I can say is that it sounds lush is a room ambience mic.
Thursday, 13 October 2016
The Glynn Johns Three Mic Drum Recording Setup — Jon Stinson
As minimalist as possible. That's how I approach making a record. When miking up drums, this is paramount.
The options to weigh when recording drums can be overwhelming.
Hey, look! It's Glynn Johns to rescue with his simple yet monumental method for recording drums
Glynn Johns is a producer and recording engineer behind many of the Led Zepplin records, and part of the equation attributing to John Bonham's mammoth-sounding drums. John Bonham himself being the other part of the equation.
Here's the setup:
One mic directly over the kit, about 40 inches high, and looking directly down at the snare drum. A second mic at the 3 'clock position to the floor tom (drummer's perspective), about 1 or 2 feet above the rim of the tom, looking across the kit to the hi-hat, and 40 inches from the snare drum.
These two microphones will serve as the overhead” mics. The objective is to get a good overall balance of the whole kit, as they will function as the main drum sound.
The third mic will be positioned as a close mic on the kick drum. The purpose of this mic is to fill in the kick drum so that it is more apparent and punchy in the drum mix. Otherwise, it would get lost underneath everything else in the final mix, making the drums lose a bit of punch.
This is a very minimal drum miking technique that yields surprisingly huge sounding results. This approach is also quite versatile.
Here's a sample of what the drums sound like recorded with the Glynn Johns microphone setup:
The most important part of this method to recording drums is the two main overhead mics. Since these two microphones will be making up the primary sound of the drum recording, it's critical that you put most your attention on them.
The key to the overhead mics is that they are both equal distant from the snare drum to ensure proper phase, an issue of small timing differences in sound when it reaches individual microphones, causing a degraded sound quality (the drums will sound thin).
The exact positions specified above are meant to give you a good starting place. Many people have found, depending on specific circumstances, that fine tuning these positions help more closely achieve the sound they want. For example, some people find positioning the first overhead mic a bit more over the rack toms is more to their taste.
Another variation is adding a 4th mic as a close mic on the snare to give it a bit more presence in the drum mix, just like with the bass drum.
Finally, the last two major factors that play a part in this approach to recording drums are 1) the quality of the drummer-since there are limited spot mics used, the drummer needs to be aware of his or her playing to ensure the kit is well balanced throughout the performance. 2) The space you are using to record the drums plays a significant role in how big the sound is.
I'll wrap this post up with a thought on microphone selection-don't get distracted by this. Yes, Glynn Johns had some very nice tube microphones at his disposal when working with Led Zepplin. But those types of mics are very expensive, which makes them an impractical choice for most of us. Use what you have available to make the best recording you possibly can. You want to concentrate your energy on making music. Move towards this creative work as quickly as possible, and don't let yourself get bogged down with tedious technical details.
The options to weigh when recording drums can be overwhelming.
Hey, look! It's Glynn Johns to rescue with his simple yet monumental method for recording drums
Glynn Johns is a producer and recording engineer behind many of the Led Zepplin records, and part of the equation attributing to John Bonham's mammoth-sounding drums. John Bonham himself being the other part of the equation.
Here's the setup:
One mic directly over the kit, about 40 inches high, and looking directly down at the snare drum. A second mic at the 3 'clock position to the floor tom (drummer's perspective), about 1 or 2 feet above the rim of the tom, looking across the kit to the hi-hat, and 40 inches from the snare drum.
These two microphones will serve as the overhead” mics. The objective is to get a good overall balance of the whole kit, as they will function as the main drum sound.
The third mic will be positioned as a close mic on the kick drum. The purpose of this mic is to fill in the kick drum so that it is more apparent and punchy in the drum mix. Otherwise, it would get lost underneath everything else in the final mix, making the drums lose a bit of punch.
This is a very minimal drum miking technique that yields surprisingly huge sounding results. This approach is also quite versatile.
Here's a sample of what the drums sound like recorded with the Glynn Johns microphone setup:
The most important part of this method to recording drums is the two main overhead mics. Since these two microphones will be making up the primary sound of the drum recording, it's critical that you put most your attention on them.
The key to the overhead mics is that they are both equal distant from the snare drum to ensure proper phase, an issue of small timing differences in sound when it reaches individual microphones, causing a degraded sound quality (the drums will sound thin).
The exact positions specified above are meant to give you a good starting place. Many people have found, depending on specific circumstances, that fine tuning these positions help more closely achieve the sound they want. For example, some people find positioning the first overhead mic a bit more over the rack toms is more to their taste.
Another variation is adding a 4th mic as a close mic on the snare to give it a bit more presence in the drum mix, just like with the bass drum.
Finally, the last two major factors that play a part in this approach to recording drums are 1) the quality of the drummer-since there are limited spot mics used, the drummer needs to be aware of his or her playing to ensure the kit is well balanced throughout the performance. 2) The space you are using to record the drums plays a significant role in how big the sound is.
I'll wrap this post up with a thought on microphone selection-don't get distracted by this. Yes, Glynn Johns had some very nice tube microphones at his disposal when working with Led Zepplin. But those types of mics are very expensive, which makes them an impractical choice for most of us. Use what you have available to make the best recording you possibly can. You want to concentrate your energy on making music. Move towards this creative work as quickly as possible, and don't let yourself get bogged down with tedious technical details.
Wednesday, 12 October 2016
Recording Drums
In session two of DIY Recording we are looking at drums, as part of our five part series on General Production Techniques, with tips and tricks to help with your sound. Recording is an art and a science, so try these tips out using your ears and creativity.
Drums are the foundation of your recording and a crucial element in determining the genre, style and flavour of your sound. Because of the many aspects of recording drums, it can be a tricky thing to get right, so it's important you focus on getting things as good as you can each step of the way.
Before you start, think about the sound of the room you are going to record your drums in. Move the kick drum, snare and hi-hat around the room to try and find the sweet spot. It is also important that the kit is tuned to the sound you are going for; here's a great article from Music Radar with drum tuning tips.
Once your happy with that, time to get the kit set up and get miking. Below is our rough guide to getting your mics set up, for a more detailed analysis check out School Of Audio Engineering's reference material Remember to use your ears!
Kick
Gating
Gates are used to tighten sound by modifying the attack and release of the envelope. Don't record with a gate.
Compression
Used to even out dynamics & improve tightness. Threshold should be high to control dynamics without squashing sound. Try a 4:1 ratio. Fast to medium attack, fast to medium release. Use hard knee for punchier sound. If using a gate insert after compressor. Reference.
Reverb on Kick
Reverb is dangerous on kick as it may muddy the sound. However you may need reverb to balance the kick with the rest of the kit or make it sit in the mix. Reverb should be bright (eg plate) and unwanted freqs must be cut. Delay time no more than 1.2s (think under 1s). Alternatively set up a large diaphragm condenser with good LF response about 5m in front of the kick. Record on a separate track and blend with the kick to give it some space. The natural ambience picked up by the /Hs and the other mic drum mics. Reverb flat. (Remove dynamics).
Using pitch shift
Recording Level
Recording at -3VU, peak will be at -12dBV higher. With analogue record on an edge track.
Double kick
Best to pan both to centre and leave it there.
Optional Distant Mic Technique
Place a condenser mic about 3 feet away from the kick drum, and cover the space in a tunnel / tube.
Snare
Compression
The snare is a little more transient. Try a higher ratio with a higher threshold.
Gating
Maybe used for ring, or to pull down the decay to make it choppier.
Reverb
Big sounding one eg Big Plate Decay time: 1.2s (more for ballad, less for fast song).
Snare bottom
If you mic the snare bottom, make sure you reverse the phase of that track.
Tricks
Noise gate add bursts of pink noise - can send pink noise to reverb of snare & mix with dry snare.
Send snare to harmonise, set at -1/2 octave. Blend with original deeper sound (in & out for a big sound).
Distortion - distant the reverb of snare & mix with clean snare sound.
To get a more realistic snare from a sequencer - put snare in studio in studio and put small speaker cone down or on top of it. Mic up snare. Play the track and speaker will play snare.
Hi Hat
200Hz - Clang/gong
5-6kHz - Presence/brightness/crispness
Reverb
Generally you get what you need from the OHs, might want some on sequenced hats, but not too much.
Recording Level
0VU
Effects
Backward Hi Hat - Use reverse reverb, blend with Hi Hat.
Delays - can use short delays. Level must be low. Don't use for whole song.
Flange - can be a nice sound, use a very slow one to round off edges of Hi Hat.
Toms
The aim is to get natural ring with a good stereo image while avoid the ring on resulting from poor drums.
80-120Hz - Fundamental
250Hz - Shell
Gates
To control decay, careful not to cut out natural rings.
Reverb
Plate reverb. Big sound. Percussive. Metallic. Big decay, up to 2s depending on sound.
Can use same tricks as snare.
Recording Level
Overheads
Record at 0VU, pan hard L & R. At recording time, check mono for phasing problems.
100Hz - HPF
10kHz - Crispness
Get mics right for tonal balance between drums and cymbals.. Get rid of excess LFs.
Ambience Mics
Distance: 2m minimal. Depends on sound you want.
Use for a less processed, controlled sound, more natural and raw etc.
Think about mid freqs and compress heavily.
Can add distortion.
Drum replacement and alignment
Over the years drum triggering software has been highly developed and is often used before starting mixdown, and something that should be considered depending on the sound you are going for. Check out this article from Sound on Sound, for more detailed info about drum replacement.
Get the gear
A good place to start is getting a drum mic kit which will tend to cover your basic needs. Two mics that are definitely good to have on hand and aren't too expensive are the Shure
SM57 for snare (works great on guitar too) and AKG D112 for kick (also works great on bass).
Drums are the foundation of your recording and a crucial element in determining the genre, style and flavour of your sound. Because of the many aspects of recording drums, it can be a tricky thing to get right, so it's important you focus on getting things as good as you can each step of the way.
Before you start, think about the sound of the room you are going to record your drums in. Move the kick drum, snare and hi-hat around the room to try and find the sweet spot. It is also important that the kit is tuned to the sound you are going for; here's a great article from Music Radar with drum tuning tips.
Once your happy with that, time to get the kit set up and get miking. Below is our rough guide to getting your mics set up, for a more detailed analysis check out School Of Audio Engineering's reference material Remember to use your ears!
Kick
Gating
Gates are used to tighten sound by modifying the attack and release of the envelope. Don't record with a gate.
Compression
Used to even out dynamics & improve tightness. Threshold should be high to control dynamics without squashing sound. Try a 4:1 ratio. Fast to medium attack, fast to medium release. Use hard knee for punchier sound. If using a gate insert after compressor. Reference.
Reverb on Kick
Reverb is dangerous on kick as it may muddy the sound. However you may need reverb to balance the kick with the rest of the kit or make it sit in the mix. Reverb should be bright (eg plate) and unwanted freqs must be cut. Delay time no more than 1.2s (think under 1s). Alternatively set up a large diaphragm condenser with good LF response about 5m in front of the kick. Record on a separate track and blend with the kick to give it some space. The natural ambience picked up by the /Hs and the other mic drum mics. Reverb flat. (Remove dynamics).
Using pitch shift
Recording Level
Recording at -3VU, peak will be at -12dBV higher. With analogue record on an edge track.
Double kick
Best to pan both to centre and leave it there.
Optional Distant Mic Technique
Place a condenser mic about 3 feet away from the kick drum, and cover the space in a tunnel / tube.
Snare
Compression
The snare is a little more transient. Try a higher ratio with a higher threshold.
Gating
Maybe used for ring, or to pull down the decay to make it choppier.
Reverb
Big sounding one eg Big Plate Decay time: 1.2s (more for ballad, less for fast song).
Snare bottom
If you mic the snare bottom, make sure you reverse the phase of that track.
Tricks
Noise gate add bursts of pink noise - can send pink noise to reverb of snare & mix with dry snare.
Send snare to harmonise, set at -1/2 octave. Blend with original deeper sound (in & out for a big sound).
Distortion - distant the reverb of snare & mix with clean snare sound.
To get a more realistic snare from a sequencer - put snare in studio in studio and put small speaker cone down or on top of it. Mic up snare. Play the track and speaker will play snare.
Hi Hat
200Hz - Clang/gong
5-6kHz - Presence/brightness/crispness
Reverb
Generally you get what you need from the OHs, might want some on sequenced hats, but not too much.
Recording Level
0VU
Effects
Backward Hi Hat - Use reverse reverb, blend with Hi Hat.
Delays - can use short delays. Level must be low. Don't use for whole song.
Flange - can be a nice sound, use a very slow one to round off edges of Hi Hat.
Toms
The aim is to get natural ring with a good stereo image while avoid the ring on resulting from poor drums.
80-120Hz - Fundamental
250Hz - Shell
Gates
To control decay, careful not to cut out natural rings.
Reverb
Plate reverb. Big sound. Percussive. Metallic. Big decay, up to 2s depending on sound.
Can use same tricks as snare.
Recording Level
Overheads
Record at 0VU, pan hard L & R. At recording time, check mono for phasing problems.
100Hz - HPF
10kHz - Crispness
Get mics right for tonal balance between drums and cymbals.. Get rid of excess LFs.
Ambience Mics
Distance: 2m minimal. Depends on sound you want.
Use for a less processed, controlled sound, more natural and raw etc.
Think about mid freqs and compress heavily.
Can add distortion.
Drum replacement and alignment
Over the years drum triggering software has been highly developed and is often used before starting mixdown, and something that should be considered depending on the sound you are going for. Check out this article from Sound on Sound, for more detailed info about drum replacement.
Get the gear
A good place to start is getting a drum mic kit which will tend to cover your basic needs. Two mics that are definitely good to have on hand and aren't too expensive are the Shure
SM57 for snare (works great on guitar too) and AKG D112 for kick (also works great on bass).
Saturday, 8 October 2016
9 Microphone Techniques For Recording A Snare Drum
The recording of a snare drum is the focal point of every modern recording. It sits right in the center of the mix, below or above the vocals depending on the style of the music. In this article, I've outlined some mic placement techniques that will help focus in on getting specific snare sounds in your recordings.
1. Close Mic
This is simple, easy, and very exposing. If you are looking to get that initial attack of your snare drum, use this type of placement. On its own it does not sound as appealing as one would first think, but once you add in the rest of your microphones you will begin to understand how the drumset takes shape.
Close mic'ing a snare drum captures ghost notes, blast beats, and other low-volume hits. Adding this type of placement to your snare configurations and then automating it's level in post or during the performance can help pick up snare hits that do not get through to the rest of the microphones on the drumset.
2. Close Mic with Moon Gel Applied
This microphone placement is the same one used in number 1 above, but with Moongel applied. Applying Moongel to a snare drum reduces ringing overtones. Some snares ring a bit more than others depending on the type of head, drum-tuning and wood. This one in particular rang more than what was desired, so the application of moongel was necessary.
Obviously the amount of ring in your snare is based on what you like stylistically. Coming from a heavy rock and metal background I tend to lean towards a more-attack and short-sustain type of snare sound. In my experience I have found that a snare with a long sustain can immensely impede drum editing, time alignment, and replacement; it can also get in the way of other frequencies when it comes time to mix.
3. Six inches from the snare - Let your snare breath
4. Side snare
Obtaining the proper sound of a snare drum should be something that is tried and tried again. Moving microphones, trying different microphones, and referencing a track with desired sounds is the best way to start understanding the recording of a snare drum. Inexperienced users will start to reach for a plugin the second they get the tracks down in their DAW.
Microphone placement is like anything else, practicing will only make you better.
One (not so typical) technique that I like is setting up a microphone from the side. This allows for a combination of the top and bottom as well as some of ringing from the shell. You can increase the amount of top or bottom by simply raising or lowering the microphone. This, again, is a stylistic choice and introduces some new ways to personalize the sound of your snare.
Bonus - A Warm Microphone Pre makes the difference
The Warm WA12 microphone pre is by far one of the best preamps of it's kind and price range. The feel, sound, and overall architecture of this pre amp makes for a great snare top choice just like the microphone pre amp that it's modelled after - the API312. In fact this pre amp is so close to API's design that it's actually considered an absolute clone of the vintage ancestor. This was first noticeable when sending the hot snare top signal through it and understanding how it embraced the low frequencies with ease and didn't break up in the high-end. It is by far the perfect option for home studios and pro studios alike. I used this for all of the snare top recordings in this article.
5. Bottom snare
Typically this one is always paired with a top snare microphone. The common practice is to flip the two microphones out of phase due to their arrangement, but that's really up to the engineer's ear. Listen to your signal, then flip them out of phase and decipher which one sounds better. Sometimes this will even act as an EQ. Regardless, the bottom snare is there to pick up the crisp rattling of the snares against the resonant head. This bright sizzle from the bottom and the attack of a top snare can be used to balance the lows and highs of your initial snare signal when dialing in the right sound during mixing.
6. Overheads
If you follow my other articles you will know that I typically work by getting the sound of the drums with the overheads first. Much of this is understanding the drums in the room, and how the snare sounds with the rest of the kit. For the most part, OH microphones are where a lot of the sound of your drums come from in the final mix, including the snare. Center your snare in the overhead microphones or dedicate a pair of overheads to your snare as secondary overheads. The point is to capture the sound of the snare in the room with the rest of the kit. After that, it's a matter of dialing in the right balance and blending your top, side, bottom or other snare microphones in with the sound.
7. 1 Condenser - In front of the kit
There really is no turning back once you start adding room microphones to your drum sounds. Having many different microphones in different places of your drum room can start to shape the sound of the set even more than you would expect. Placing a condenser microphone like the Mojave MA200 in front of your kit captures a narrow perspective of the drums in the room. The advantage here is that you are recording the kit in mono, so everything is reduced to the center of the stereo image.
That center is where your snare occurs, so if you filter out the high and low end of this signal you essentially have a dedicated snare microphone 10 feet from the kit. Apply some compression and voila!
8. 1 Dynamic - In front of the kit
The same principles apply here as they did in number 7 above, although this perspective changes significantly with a different type of microphone. In comparison to the Mojave, the SM7B is more aggressive in the mid range. If you are familiar with the SM57, the SM7B is close in sound and more accepting of the low end.
You can use this to fatten up the center of your drumset, or simply throw a reverb on it to make for an even more ambient sound. Again, filtering and crushing this type of source can produce results that are unmatched to other recordings.
9. Stereo Room Microphones - Facing opposing walls
Using wide room microphones is a great way to up the intensity and quality of your drum recordings. If you're not in a big room, you can face the microphone capsules in the opposite direction of the drum set. Place them as close to any opposing wall as you can and set them to the Cardiod Pattern”.
Facing the microphones towards a reflective surface breaks the line-of-sight between the capsule of the microphone and the drum means that your distant stereo room microphones will pick up reflections from the wall first. This slight variation of mic positioning creates a difference in the sound of your rooms.
1. Close Mic
This is simple, easy, and very exposing. If you are looking to get that initial attack of your snare drum, use this type of placement. On its own it does not sound as appealing as one would first think, but once you add in the rest of your microphones you will begin to understand how the drumset takes shape.
Close mic'ing a snare drum captures ghost notes, blast beats, and other low-volume hits. Adding this type of placement to your snare configurations and then automating it's level in post or during the performance can help pick up snare hits that do not get through to the rest of the microphones on the drumset.
2. Close Mic with Moon Gel Applied
This microphone placement is the same one used in number 1 above, but with Moongel applied. Applying Moongel to a snare drum reduces ringing overtones. Some snares ring a bit more than others depending on the type of head, drum-tuning and wood. This one in particular rang more than what was desired, so the application of moongel was necessary.
Obviously the amount of ring in your snare is based on what you like stylistically. Coming from a heavy rock and metal background I tend to lean towards a more-attack and short-sustain type of snare sound. In my experience I have found that a snare with a long sustain can immensely impede drum editing, time alignment, and replacement; it can also get in the way of other frequencies when it comes time to mix.
3. Six inches from the snare - Let your snare breath
4. Side snare
Obtaining the proper sound of a snare drum should be something that is tried and tried again. Moving microphones, trying different microphones, and referencing a track with desired sounds is the best way to start understanding the recording of a snare drum. Inexperienced users will start to reach for a plugin the second they get the tracks down in their DAW.
Microphone placement is like anything else, practicing will only make you better.
One (not so typical) technique that I like is setting up a microphone from the side. This allows for a combination of the top and bottom as well as some of ringing from the shell. You can increase the amount of top or bottom by simply raising or lowering the microphone. This, again, is a stylistic choice and introduces some new ways to personalize the sound of your snare.
Bonus - A Warm Microphone Pre makes the difference
The Warm WA12 microphone pre is by far one of the best preamps of it's kind and price range. The feel, sound, and overall architecture of this pre amp makes for a great snare top choice just like the microphone pre amp that it's modelled after - the API312. In fact this pre amp is so close to API's design that it's actually considered an absolute clone of the vintage ancestor. This was first noticeable when sending the hot snare top signal through it and understanding how it embraced the low frequencies with ease and didn't break up in the high-end. It is by far the perfect option for home studios and pro studios alike. I used this for all of the snare top recordings in this article.
5. Bottom snare
Typically this one is always paired with a top snare microphone. The common practice is to flip the two microphones out of phase due to their arrangement, but that's really up to the engineer's ear. Listen to your signal, then flip them out of phase and decipher which one sounds better. Sometimes this will even act as an EQ. Regardless, the bottom snare is there to pick up the crisp rattling of the snares against the resonant head. This bright sizzle from the bottom and the attack of a top snare can be used to balance the lows and highs of your initial snare signal when dialing in the right sound during mixing.
6. Overheads
If you follow my other articles you will know that I typically work by getting the sound of the drums with the overheads first. Much of this is understanding the drums in the room, and how the snare sounds with the rest of the kit. For the most part, OH microphones are where a lot of the sound of your drums come from in the final mix, including the snare. Center your snare in the overhead microphones or dedicate a pair of overheads to your snare as secondary overheads. The point is to capture the sound of the snare in the room with the rest of the kit. After that, it's a matter of dialing in the right balance and blending your top, side, bottom or other snare microphones in with the sound.
7. 1 Condenser - In front of the kit
There really is no turning back once you start adding room microphones to your drum sounds. Having many different microphones in different places of your drum room can start to shape the sound of the set even more than you would expect. Placing a condenser microphone like the Mojave MA200 in front of your kit captures a narrow perspective of the drums in the room. The advantage here is that you are recording the kit in mono, so everything is reduced to the center of the stereo image.
That center is where your snare occurs, so if you filter out the high and low end of this signal you essentially have a dedicated snare microphone 10 feet from the kit. Apply some compression and voila!
8. 1 Dynamic - In front of the kit
The same principles apply here as they did in number 7 above, although this perspective changes significantly with a different type of microphone. In comparison to the Mojave, the SM7B is more aggressive in the mid range. If you are familiar with the SM57, the SM7B is close in sound and more accepting of the low end.
You can use this to fatten up the center of your drumset, or simply throw a reverb on it to make for an even more ambient sound. Again, filtering and crushing this type of source can produce results that are unmatched to other recordings.
9. Stereo Room Microphones - Facing opposing walls
Using wide room microphones is a great way to up the intensity and quality of your drum recordings. If you're not in a big room, you can face the microphone capsules in the opposite direction of the drum set. Place them as close to any opposing wall as you can and set them to the Cardiod Pattern”.
Facing the microphones towards a reflective surface breaks the line-of-sight between the capsule of the microphone and the drum means that your distant stereo room microphones will pick up reflections from the wall first. This slight variation of mic positioning creates a difference in the sound of your rooms.
Monday, 19 September 2016
How To Record Drums Like An Expert
Drum recording is one of those things that you need to get right. There is much less room for experimentation in drum sounds. What I mean to say is, you can have the most alternative guitar sound or effected vocal sound in the world but if the drums don't sound right nobody is going to care.
Sure, you can experiment with different mixing techniques and try different production tricks later down the line, but the first order of business is to nail that drum sound. If your kick drum sounds like a cardboard box beaten with a marshmallow then no amount of mixing is going to fix it. Get it right at the source or don't do it at all.
Correct placement and microphone selection is important to the sound of your recorded drums, but so is the room you are recording in. Let's get busy with some drum recording tricks.
Room
Clap your hands say yeah! Indie music aside (not a big fan), clap your hands. Do it. Right now. If you're in a typical office or living room then chances are it's not going to last that long. The echo will die down within a second since the size of your room don't allow for a lot of buildup of reverb or reflections.
Now, imagine if you were in a gymnasium and clapped your hands. The perceived bigness” of the echo and reverb of the sound is dictated by the size of the room you are in, therefore clapping your hands inside a big gymnasium will result in more reflections, a larger reverb and a longer decay” time for the sound of your handclaps to die down. For more on reverb and reflections see my other Basix tutorial How the Hell do I Use Reverb Anyway?!? ”
So, if we intend to record drums we need to take the room into account, since those reflections from your handclap are just peanuts compared to the amount of echoes and reflections a whole drum kit will make inside a gymnasium. Your ears heard them, and your microphones will most surely do so too.
If you have a mobile recording rig, which today means a laptop, an interface and some microphones and access to some different rooms you can create a whole different feel to your drum sound depending on which you choose. Many engineers opt for a dead, or a very quiet room to track drums in since that will allow them to add the type of reverb they want later on during the mixing process. While this method is sound and valid, just look at all those great rock records that were made before the advent of digital reverb. Recording studios used to have amazing sounding live rooms to track drums in, and that became an inherent part of the drum sound.
If you want to go the safe route, try to find a nice (preferably acoustically treated) room that doesn't have a whole lot of liveness. But if you are up for experimentation then finding an interesting or great sounding room might yield some impressive results.
Pre-production
Gourmet dishes are not cooked from leftovers. You don't wear dirty clothes to a wedding. And you certainly don't record worn heads and out of tune drums if you want great results.
Make sure to replace each drum head and tune it so that each drum sounds both great in its own right and as a part of the kit. If you, or the drummer don't know how to tune a drum properly (I don't really know how, and most drummers are pretty bad at it) get someone that can.
A great sounding drum kit in a great sounding room and you've won half the battle. Next we have to look at what types of microphones we want to be using.
Microphone Selection
A few considerations when choosing the right microphone for recording drums.
How Many? - How many microphones are you going to be using? Are you trying to mike up the kit with only one microphone? Then a full sounding large condenser should be the best bet. It has a broad frequency response and will most accurately capture the kit, especially compared to a dynamic microphone.
Condenser microphones - Condenser microphones (small or large diaphragm) are usually the default microphones of choice used as overheads. Overhead microphones are placed over the drum kit to capture the overall sound of the drum kit from a close distance. Condenser have the capacity to capture all the nuances of the drum kit, from the low end of the kick drum to the swash of the cymbals.
Dynamic microphones - Dynamic microphones can take more volume, but they lack the frequency response and accuracy of a condenser. They can take the pounding and volume of the kick drum and they have no problem with the incredibly loud whack of the snare. If you decide to close mike every drum, then you would usually opt for a good sounding dynamic at each drum; kick, snare and each of the toms.
Ribbon microphones - Ribbons might be a good choice if you can afford it, especially if you are only using a few microphones. Ribbons have a smoother sound, but they are more delicate than the average condenser, and way more fragile than a sturdy dynamic.
Remember, each microphone sounds different and they will all act as a piece of the drum recording puzzle.
Collection of Instruments
One of the things you have to be aware of is that recording drums can be much more complex than recording a regular” instrument that only has one sound source. Take vocals for example, the most standard way of recording vocals is placing a microphone in front of the singer's sound source, i.e. his mouth.
But when you are recording drums, every single drum is a sound source, and you also need to portray the overall sound of the kit as a whole. That's the reason why modern drum recording puts a microphone on every drum and then some overhead mics to capture the complete kit.
People want to control each drum as a specific sound source and then treat the whole drum kit as one sound source as well. Then, by mixing and matching the overall volume of all the tracks in the mixing phase people have more control over what kinds of sounds they can get from their drums.
Kick Drum
I don't care what anybody says. The kick drum is the most important part of the drum sound. You can argue that the snare sound is all you want, and it certainly is important, but if the kick drum lacks power and definition the overall drum sound is going to suffer. The kick drum is also the trickiest sound to get right since the placement of the microphone plays a pivotal role.
Microphone - Your best bet, if you are just using one microphone to record the drums is a large dynamic microphone, such as the AKG D112, Audix D6 or Shure Beta 52A. They will usually have the frequency response needed to get the thick low end coupled with the snap of the beater.
Placement - The default position to try is just inside the outer head (I hope there is a hole in the outer head) pointing at, or just a little off axis towards the beater. In this position the microphone is far enough away as to capture both the boom and the snap. Microphones placed too close to the inner head (the beater side) can't capture the full resonance of the drum since they are facing away from the drum and are picking up too much click” from the beater.
Placing the microphone outside the shell can give you great results, but there is a possibility of the microphone capturing too much bleed from the other drums and that it will lack definition from the beater. Great if you want a natural bass drum sound, but bad if you want a isolated and click” heavy sound.
Best of both worlds? - By using two microphones you can capture both the beater and the boom by placing the microphones at different positions. Positioning one inside the kit close to the beater head and the other just outside the shell will result in two different sounds that can be mixed together to great results. Boundary, or PZM (Pressure Zone Microphones) work really well on the inside since they react well to transients and can usually just sit on the shell.
By combining a PZM that reacts well to transients (initial attack) at the beater and a big dynamic picking up the low end on the outside you can get the best of both worlds.
Snare Drum
The snare drum is the master of the backbeat, and thus must sound great in order to capture the groove. Whether you are producing a heavy rock song or light jazz, careful consideration must be put into the snare drum sound.
Microphone - A trusty Shure SM57, or any other type of dynamic is a great starting point when capturing snare drum. If you looking for a different, more vintage sound then using a large condenser or a ribbon can give the snare a much different feel. Take into account how loud the drummer will be hitting the drum. If he's going to be whacking that drum for all he's got then a condenser might overload too easily, leaving you with a distorted snare instead of a smooth and full sound.
Placement - Consider angling the microphone 45° into the middle of the drum to get the right amount of attack from the snare. For a rounder sound you can angle the microphone into the edge of the drum. Make sure that the microphone isn't in the drummer's way since whacking the microphone will not result in a better sound. In general, for more harmonics angle the mic towards the edges, but if you want more resonance and/or attack then angling the microphone more towards the middle and center will yield greater results for each respective sound.
Above & Below - If you want to achieve a direct sound from the top but want to accent the rattle the snares you can place another microphone underneath the snare pointing up. If you decide to do this make sure you flip the phase of the under-mic either during the recording or at the mixing stage. Most audio programs have a phase invert switch that allow you to flip the phase of your waveform. I touched upon the why's and how's of this practice a long time ago in A Guide to Effective Drum Mixing Part 1
Hi-hat
If you want to have added control over the hi-hat during the mixing stage, then adding a separate microphone for it wouldn't hurt
Microphone - You usually want a small condenser to record the hi-hat. Due to the fast transient nature of the hi-hat you want to capture all the definition and clarity of the hi-hat, even though you're recording a garage rock track.
Placement - Placing the condenser by the edge give you a much different sound than placing it at the center bell of the hi-hat. Also, try placing it in the middle and angle it to or from the edge until you find the sound you are looking for.
Over or under? - Some people swear by under-miking the hi-hat, others don't see why anybody would do such nonsense. Personally, in live situation I place the microphone underneath the hi-hat, facing up but during recording it's the other way around. Why? I don't know. Probably just force of habit.
Toms
Those drum fills need to sound good. The toms need to sound clean, defined and tuned. There's nothing worse than a tom that rings for seconds after it's hit. Assuming you have made all the necessary arrangements and made sure each drum sounds as good as it can then you only have to worry about the right microphone and placement thereof.
Microphone - Dynamic microphones such as an Audix i5, Shure SM57 or a Sennheiser MD421 are a good bet to capture a full and powerful tom sound. Especially if you are playing any sort of hard music then going for dynamics is the way to go. Experienced engineers sometimes use condensers and even ribbons(!) but as always, you have to careful about not overloading those more delicate microphones. In live sound I used to use AKG C519 clip-on condensers for toms. They work really well through a powerful P.A. and can also work well in the studio. Each sound company has a drum miking package that is usually a good bet if you don't have anything to work with.
Placement - The microphone placement is very similar to that of the snare drum. If you want more attack and stick sound from the toms you should angle them towards the middle. If you want a thicker, boomier sound you should angle them straight down towards the edge of the tom so that the microphone picks up the full resonant sound of the toms.
Underneath as well? - If you have a crazy amount of microphones, an amazing kit in a sweet sounding room then more microphones will add to the sound right? Yes, well and no. If you have the resources to mike both sides of the toms then you probably shouldn't be reading this article. But the same rules apply as if you were recording the snare with two microphones. Beware of phase and make sure both microphones are capturing something different.
Overheads
Overheads are usually placed over the drum kit, both to capture the complete kit but also to accent the sounds of the cymbals. There are a few microphone techniques that you can use to accurately and effectively capture both the cymbals and overall drum kit.
X/Y - The X/Y microphone technique can be used effectively as overheads. You don't have to worry about phase problems when using this stereo technique since they are a coincident technique. Meaning that you place them beside each other at a 90° angle facing down onto the drum kit.
A/B - This is the typical one microphone over each side of the drum kit. It's a good rule of thumb to adhere to the 3:1 rule so that if you place one microphone a foot (30 cm) over the cymbal the other microphone must be placed at a distance of 3 feet (or 90 cm).
Accent the cymbals - Just like engineers that place microphones on the hi-hat, some engineers want to accent specific cymbals. For example, if we're recording a minor blues shuffle we might like to record that crucial ride cymbal, giving you added control over its sound during the mixing stage.
Room/Ambience
We've talked about how to mike up every individual sound source of the drum kit. That is, every drum has been covered as a single sound source. Now we need to step back and look at the drum kit as one instrument. When we use room microphones we want to capture the complete kit as well as the room that is complimenting it. If you are in a dead room there should be more thought put into capturing the kit as one instrument, whereas in a great sounding room, there is more preference to finding a good spot where the room and reflections help heighten the drum sound to a different level.
Microphone - I'd like to say that anything goes here. If you are trying to get a nice sounding complete drum kit” sound then a large condenser will do the trick. However, ribbon microphones can do a very similar job, and often a better one since they sound so good. Even normal dynamic microphones can be used to get an extra dimension to the drum kit by placing it in the room.
Placement - Placing a simple SM57 in front of the kit facing up towards the ceiling can give you some ambience from the room. A condenser that you want to use to capture the complete drum kit without adding too much room ambience should be placed at around waist level facing towards the kit. To get the drums an extra stereo dimension, two condensers can be positioned in the upper corners of the room.
Experiment - Lastly, room microphones and ambient miking is very fun to experiment with. There might be a weird place in the room where the drums just really work. Walk around with headphones and try to find where the best place to position your mics is. A long hallway outside the drum room might have a great alternative sound that can work for you.
Throw up a few room microphones all over, record a few measures and see which ones work best.
Conclusion
We've covered some important aspects of recording one of the most complex instruments that us engineers face. The complicated puzzle of multiple types of microphones, placements and techniques is sure to make the beginner engineer nervous. But if we break it down into small pieces, looking at each drum as part of the puzzle and then combining it into one sound source we can more easily understand what makes drum recording such a difficult, but ultimately enjoyable subject.
Sure, you can experiment with different mixing techniques and try different production tricks later down the line, but the first order of business is to nail that drum sound. If your kick drum sounds like a cardboard box beaten with a marshmallow then no amount of mixing is going to fix it. Get it right at the source or don't do it at all.
Correct placement and microphone selection is important to the sound of your recorded drums, but so is the room you are recording in. Let's get busy with some drum recording tricks.
Room
Clap your hands say yeah! Indie music aside (not a big fan), clap your hands. Do it. Right now. If you're in a typical office or living room then chances are it's not going to last that long. The echo will die down within a second since the size of your room don't allow for a lot of buildup of reverb or reflections.
Now, imagine if you were in a gymnasium and clapped your hands. The perceived bigness” of the echo and reverb of the sound is dictated by the size of the room you are in, therefore clapping your hands inside a big gymnasium will result in more reflections, a larger reverb and a longer decay” time for the sound of your handclaps to die down. For more on reverb and reflections see my other Basix tutorial How the Hell do I Use Reverb Anyway?!? ”
So, if we intend to record drums we need to take the room into account, since those reflections from your handclap are just peanuts compared to the amount of echoes and reflections a whole drum kit will make inside a gymnasium. Your ears heard them, and your microphones will most surely do so too.
If you have a mobile recording rig, which today means a laptop, an interface and some microphones and access to some different rooms you can create a whole different feel to your drum sound depending on which you choose. Many engineers opt for a dead, or a very quiet room to track drums in since that will allow them to add the type of reverb they want later on during the mixing process. While this method is sound and valid, just look at all those great rock records that were made before the advent of digital reverb. Recording studios used to have amazing sounding live rooms to track drums in, and that became an inherent part of the drum sound.
If you want to go the safe route, try to find a nice (preferably acoustically treated) room that doesn't have a whole lot of liveness. But if you are up for experimentation then finding an interesting or great sounding room might yield some impressive results.
Pre-production
Gourmet dishes are not cooked from leftovers. You don't wear dirty clothes to a wedding. And you certainly don't record worn heads and out of tune drums if you want great results.
Make sure to replace each drum head and tune it so that each drum sounds both great in its own right and as a part of the kit. If you, or the drummer don't know how to tune a drum properly (I don't really know how, and most drummers are pretty bad at it) get someone that can.
A great sounding drum kit in a great sounding room and you've won half the battle. Next we have to look at what types of microphones we want to be using.
Microphone Selection
A few considerations when choosing the right microphone for recording drums.
How Many? - How many microphones are you going to be using? Are you trying to mike up the kit with only one microphone? Then a full sounding large condenser should be the best bet. It has a broad frequency response and will most accurately capture the kit, especially compared to a dynamic microphone.
Condenser microphones - Condenser microphones (small or large diaphragm) are usually the default microphones of choice used as overheads. Overhead microphones are placed over the drum kit to capture the overall sound of the drum kit from a close distance. Condenser have the capacity to capture all the nuances of the drum kit, from the low end of the kick drum to the swash of the cymbals.
Dynamic microphones - Dynamic microphones can take more volume, but they lack the frequency response and accuracy of a condenser. They can take the pounding and volume of the kick drum and they have no problem with the incredibly loud whack of the snare. If you decide to close mike every drum, then you would usually opt for a good sounding dynamic at each drum; kick, snare and each of the toms.
Ribbon microphones - Ribbons might be a good choice if you can afford it, especially if you are only using a few microphones. Ribbons have a smoother sound, but they are more delicate than the average condenser, and way more fragile than a sturdy dynamic.
Remember, each microphone sounds different and they will all act as a piece of the drum recording puzzle.
Collection of Instruments
One of the things you have to be aware of is that recording drums can be much more complex than recording a regular” instrument that only has one sound source. Take vocals for example, the most standard way of recording vocals is placing a microphone in front of the singer's sound source, i.e. his mouth.
But when you are recording drums, every single drum is a sound source, and you also need to portray the overall sound of the kit as a whole. That's the reason why modern drum recording puts a microphone on every drum and then some overhead mics to capture the complete kit.
People want to control each drum as a specific sound source and then treat the whole drum kit as one sound source as well. Then, by mixing and matching the overall volume of all the tracks in the mixing phase people have more control over what kinds of sounds they can get from their drums.
Kick Drum
I don't care what anybody says. The kick drum is the most important part of the drum sound. You can argue that the snare sound is all you want, and it certainly is important, but if the kick drum lacks power and definition the overall drum sound is going to suffer. The kick drum is also the trickiest sound to get right since the placement of the microphone plays a pivotal role.
Microphone - Your best bet, if you are just using one microphone to record the drums is a large dynamic microphone, such as the AKG D112, Audix D6 or Shure Beta 52A. They will usually have the frequency response needed to get the thick low end coupled with the snap of the beater.
Placement - The default position to try is just inside the outer head (I hope there is a hole in the outer head) pointing at, or just a little off axis towards the beater. In this position the microphone is far enough away as to capture both the boom and the snap. Microphones placed too close to the inner head (the beater side) can't capture the full resonance of the drum since they are facing away from the drum and are picking up too much click” from the beater.
Placing the microphone outside the shell can give you great results, but there is a possibility of the microphone capturing too much bleed from the other drums and that it will lack definition from the beater. Great if you want a natural bass drum sound, but bad if you want a isolated and click” heavy sound.
Best of both worlds? - By using two microphones you can capture both the beater and the boom by placing the microphones at different positions. Positioning one inside the kit close to the beater head and the other just outside the shell will result in two different sounds that can be mixed together to great results. Boundary, or PZM (Pressure Zone Microphones) work really well on the inside since they react well to transients and can usually just sit on the shell.
By combining a PZM that reacts well to transients (initial attack) at the beater and a big dynamic picking up the low end on the outside you can get the best of both worlds.
Snare Drum
The snare drum is the master of the backbeat, and thus must sound great in order to capture the groove. Whether you are producing a heavy rock song or light jazz, careful consideration must be put into the snare drum sound.
Microphone - A trusty Shure SM57, or any other type of dynamic is a great starting point when capturing snare drum. If you looking for a different, more vintage sound then using a large condenser or a ribbon can give the snare a much different feel. Take into account how loud the drummer will be hitting the drum. If he's going to be whacking that drum for all he's got then a condenser might overload too easily, leaving you with a distorted snare instead of a smooth and full sound.
Placement - Consider angling the microphone 45° into the middle of the drum to get the right amount of attack from the snare. For a rounder sound you can angle the microphone into the edge of the drum. Make sure that the microphone isn't in the drummer's way since whacking the microphone will not result in a better sound. In general, for more harmonics angle the mic towards the edges, but if you want more resonance and/or attack then angling the microphone more towards the middle and center will yield greater results for each respective sound.
Above & Below - If you want to achieve a direct sound from the top but want to accent the rattle the snares you can place another microphone underneath the snare pointing up. If you decide to do this make sure you flip the phase of the under-mic either during the recording or at the mixing stage. Most audio programs have a phase invert switch that allow you to flip the phase of your waveform. I touched upon the why's and how's of this practice a long time ago in A Guide to Effective Drum Mixing Part 1
Hi-hat
If you want to have added control over the hi-hat during the mixing stage, then adding a separate microphone for it wouldn't hurt
Microphone - You usually want a small condenser to record the hi-hat. Due to the fast transient nature of the hi-hat you want to capture all the definition and clarity of the hi-hat, even though you're recording a garage rock track.
Placement - Placing the condenser by the edge give you a much different sound than placing it at the center bell of the hi-hat. Also, try placing it in the middle and angle it to or from the edge until you find the sound you are looking for.
Over or under? - Some people swear by under-miking the hi-hat, others don't see why anybody would do such nonsense. Personally, in live situation I place the microphone underneath the hi-hat, facing up but during recording it's the other way around. Why? I don't know. Probably just force of habit.
Toms
Those drum fills need to sound good. The toms need to sound clean, defined and tuned. There's nothing worse than a tom that rings for seconds after it's hit. Assuming you have made all the necessary arrangements and made sure each drum sounds as good as it can then you only have to worry about the right microphone and placement thereof.
Microphone - Dynamic microphones such as an Audix i5, Shure SM57 or a Sennheiser MD421 are a good bet to capture a full and powerful tom sound. Especially if you are playing any sort of hard music then going for dynamics is the way to go. Experienced engineers sometimes use condensers and even ribbons(!) but as always, you have to careful about not overloading those more delicate microphones. In live sound I used to use AKG C519 clip-on condensers for toms. They work really well through a powerful P.A. and can also work well in the studio. Each sound company has a drum miking package that is usually a good bet if you don't have anything to work with.
Placement - The microphone placement is very similar to that of the snare drum. If you want more attack and stick sound from the toms you should angle them towards the middle. If you want a thicker, boomier sound you should angle them straight down towards the edge of the tom so that the microphone picks up the full resonant sound of the toms.
Underneath as well? - If you have a crazy amount of microphones, an amazing kit in a sweet sounding room then more microphones will add to the sound right? Yes, well and no. If you have the resources to mike both sides of the toms then you probably shouldn't be reading this article. But the same rules apply as if you were recording the snare with two microphones. Beware of phase and make sure both microphones are capturing something different.
Overheads
Overheads are usually placed over the drum kit, both to capture the complete kit but also to accent the sounds of the cymbals. There are a few microphone techniques that you can use to accurately and effectively capture both the cymbals and overall drum kit.
X/Y - The X/Y microphone technique can be used effectively as overheads. You don't have to worry about phase problems when using this stereo technique since they are a coincident technique. Meaning that you place them beside each other at a 90° angle facing down onto the drum kit.
A/B - This is the typical one microphone over each side of the drum kit. It's a good rule of thumb to adhere to the 3:1 rule so that if you place one microphone a foot (30 cm) over the cymbal the other microphone must be placed at a distance of 3 feet (or 90 cm).
Accent the cymbals - Just like engineers that place microphones on the hi-hat, some engineers want to accent specific cymbals. For example, if we're recording a minor blues shuffle we might like to record that crucial ride cymbal, giving you added control over its sound during the mixing stage.
Room/Ambience
We've talked about how to mike up every individual sound source of the drum kit. That is, every drum has been covered as a single sound source. Now we need to step back and look at the drum kit as one instrument. When we use room microphones we want to capture the complete kit as well as the room that is complimenting it. If you are in a dead room there should be more thought put into capturing the kit as one instrument, whereas in a great sounding room, there is more preference to finding a good spot where the room and reflections help heighten the drum sound to a different level.
Microphone - I'd like to say that anything goes here. If you are trying to get a nice sounding complete drum kit” sound then a large condenser will do the trick. However, ribbon microphones can do a very similar job, and often a better one since they sound so good. Even normal dynamic microphones can be used to get an extra dimension to the drum kit by placing it in the room.
Placement - Placing a simple SM57 in front of the kit facing up towards the ceiling can give you some ambience from the room. A condenser that you want to use to capture the complete drum kit without adding too much room ambience should be placed at around waist level facing towards the kit. To get the drums an extra stereo dimension, two condensers can be positioned in the upper corners of the room.
Experiment - Lastly, room microphones and ambient miking is very fun to experiment with. There might be a weird place in the room where the drums just really work. Walk around with headphones and try to find where the best place to position your mics is. A long hallway outside the drum room might have a great alternative sound that can work for you.
Throw up a few room microphones all over, record a few measures and see which ones work best.
Conclusion
We've covered some important aspects of recording one of the most complex instruments that us engineers face. The complicated puzzle of multiple types of microphones, placements and techniques is sure to make the beginner engineer nervous. But if we break it down into small pieces, looking at each drum as part of the puzzle and then combining it into one sound source we can more easily understand what makes drum recording such a difficult, but ultimately enjoyable subject.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)