Get better results when recording at home.
We regularly get questions on how to achieve the best recordings at home. While many Blue users are recording in professional studios, even more are recording in their home office, bedroom, living room, basement or garage. There are a few easy ways to get studio acoustic results, at home. (See our home recording feature in the November issue of Stuff Magazine, on stands now!)
Take your at-home recordings to the next level-
Recording environment: (#1 factor that impacts your recordings)
1. Avoid hard surfaces: Hard surfaces can be your biggest enemy for home recording. Hardwood floors, concrete walls, tiled walls and counter tops are all reflective, bouncing sound around the room like Flubber, creating an echo that can be noticeable in your recordings. Carpet, curtains, rounded/fabric furniture and even inside of clothes closets can help to deaden” the room and create a more acoustically sound environment. Any hard surface is reflective, including slat blinds and windows (glass is extremely reflective). Close those curtains!
2. Reflection shields can be purchased or made to help minimize sounds being picked up from the back and sides of the mic (best if you are using a strictly omni-directional mic).
However, most at-home recording happens with a cardioid (forward directional) microphone. This type of mic is rejecting most noise from the sides and back. However, a cardioid microphone is most sensitive to sounds reflecting from behind the vocalist (see next tip for ways to reduce those reflections).
3. DIY acoustical treatment: The best at-home treatment is to hang a thick blanket on the wall or shelf or bookcase that is directly behind the vocalist, covering as much of the surface as possible. Staying away from desks or other reflective surfaces can be beneficial (especially if you aren't getting the recording results you desire). Did you know? Bass frequencies are notorious for building up under desks.
4. The place not to record: in the middle of the room. This is where frequencies build up and you get standing waves.”
5. Where to record: Back yourself closer to the wall with the hanging blanket and further from the opposite wall. Without sticking yourself in the middle. Clothes closets can also make for great vocal booths. Clothes naturally absorb sounds; they are typically carpeted and there is less room for echo.
6. Shhhhh! Make sure that background noise is minimal or nonexistent. Turn off the AC, and the TV, and the washing machine, and the microwave, and the fan and your fish tank…well maybe just move the poor fish into another room.
Headphones and Monitors:
7. Monitors are great for playback. Headphones are great for recording and direct monitoring.
8. For at-home recording, closed-back headphones are best so that the sound from your headphones doesn't bleed into your microphone. Zero-latency, direct monitoring is critical for multi-tracking (featured on Spark Digital , Nessie , Yeti and Yeti Pro ). If there are multiple people recording or even listening in, consider getting a headphone splitter box.
9. Monitors are basically fancy speakers that playback a little differently. Speakers give color to sound (deeper bass, sharper mids, etc) and are better for the average listener of a mastered track. Monitors give you uncolored sound. This will give you an accurate sound for mixing and editing. Then use your headphones for referencing (aka listening to the audio as it will be heard in the real world).
10. Setting up your monitors: Set up your monitors so that you are one of the points in an equilateral triangle. Measure the distance between your monitors, example: 45 inches, then make sure that you are 45 inches from each monitor. This will be the sweet spot for listening to your monitors.
11. Set your levels correctly. If you are direct monitoring through headphones, be sure to set your headphone volume levels correctly before adjusting the gain. If your headphone volume is too low, you risk overcompensating with the gain and causing distortion or an overly saturated recording.
Microphones Technique
12. Popping P” plosives: Pop filters help to catch these annoying bursts of air that defile your recording (Check out The Pop which can be used with most all of our mics, including USB mics like Yeti ) But if you don't have a pop filter, angle your vocals to the side of the microphone to reduce the direct burst of air away from the most sensitive part of the mic.
Found out how to attach The Pop to your USB mic here
13. Distance from the mic: The proximity effect occurs as you get closer to the microphone, the louder and more saturated your audio will become. Positioning your vocalist approximately six inches from the microphone is a good rule of thumb. Podcasters can be a little farther away, but we wouldn't recommend anything past a foot to start out.
Experimenting to find your best sound is always encouraged.
14. Pattern: Be sure to select the appropriate pattern (on multi-pattern microphones both XLR and USB ). For a single person recording, the cardioid pattern is a good default choice. Omnidirectional will pick up sounds from all around the room, which is great for a chorus or group, but likely not best for one person recording. Here are examples of use cases for various patterns:
Showing posts with label Recording Techniques. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Recording Techniques. Show all posts
Tuesday, 27 December 2016
Thursday, 8 September 2016
5 Unconventional Recording Techniques That Actually Sound Amazing
When most artists venture into the world of DIY recording, they tend to be concerned with how to do everything properly. People ask questions like, "What's the right place to put a mic on a kick drum?" or, "What type of mic should I use on a male rock vocalist?" While playing by the rules is a good place to start when you're learning to record, there's a time and a place for breaking the rules as well. Here are a few ideas to inspire you to break the rules when the time is right.
1. The trash mic
Usually when setting up a mic, you want to make sure the placement will capture the best possible sound from the instrument. Sometimes, however, you just want to capture a sound that you can mess around with later. The "trash mic" is an extra mic (usually a dynamic mic like an SM57) that you use to capture the overall sound of an instrument in order to manipulate that sound later. This is not a room mic, where you try to capture the sound of the instrument in its purest form; instead, this is a simple mono mic that you set up close to the instrument, which gives the instrument a lo-fi sound.
The concept of the trash mic is similar to the concept of parallel processing in the mixing phase: by heavily compressing, distorting, or otherwise affecting the trash mic, you can create a parallel version of the recording that doesn't necessarily sound good on its own, but when added to the mix, gives the instrument a fuller or more interesting tone. This is a good technique to try on drums, but it could work well on any other acoustic instrument as well.
2. The underwater mic
Placing a mic in a tub of water is one of the strangest recording techniques out there, but it's not a new one - John Lennon famously sang into an underwater microphone (protected by a condom) for "Yellow Submarine" (although that vocal take wasn't used in the final mix). Aside from making you sound like you're in a submarine, an underwater mic can also be good for capturing low, wobbly sounds from kick drums. Of course, you'll need to make sure the mic is fully encased in some sort of waterproof material so you don't electrocute anyone. The most common technique is to put a mic in a bucket of water right in front of the kick drum. This will give you another type lo-fi sound that ebbs and flows just like waves of the ocean.
3. Prepared instruments
Experimental recording techniques don't have to be limited to mic placement; sometimes the best way to modify a sound is to change the instrument itself. Since Erik Satie first started experimenting with placing objects on his piano strings in the early 20th century, pianists like John Cage and Hauschka have popularized the concept of the prepared piano as an instrument all of its own. Usually objects taped to a piano's strings are used to create percussive sounds, but they can also be used to dampen the sound, create more sustain, and really create any other type of sound you can imagine.
Pianos aren't the only instruments that can be prepared, too - you can get interesting sounds from guitars, drums, even orchestral strings by preparing them with simple household objects. Sometimes all it takes is a little coin taped to the front of a kick drum to help the drums cut through in the mix.
4. The gear mix-up
Just because a certain piece of gear was designed for a particular instrument doesn't mean it can't work on another instrument as well. Have you ever run a vocal through a guitar distortion pedal to give it some crunch? How about running a drum loop through a guitar amp to give it more life? When you take the limitations off of your gear, you open up new possibilities all over the place.
5. Taking matters into your own hands
Sometimes innovation in the studio can also come from a lack of gear. If you have a sound in your head that you want to capture, but you can't achieve it with the gear you have, maybe there's another way you could make that sound come to life.
1. The trash mic
Usually when setting up a mic, you want to make sure the placement will capture the best possible sound from the instrument. Sometimes, however, you just want to capture a sound that you can mess around with later. The "trash mic" is an extra mic (usually a dynamic mic like an SM57) that you use to capture the overall sound of an instrument in order to manipulate that sound later. This is not a room mic, where you try to capture the sound of the instrument in its purest form; instead, this is a simple mono mic that you set up close to the instrument, which gives the instrument a lo-fi sound.
The concept of the trash mic is similar to the concept of parallel processing in the mixing phase: by heavily compressing, distorting, or otherwise affecting the trash mic, you can create a parallel version of the recording that doesn't necessarily sound good on its own, but when added to the mix, gives the instrument a fuller or more interesting tone. This is a good technique to try on drums, but it could work well on any other acoustic instrument as well.
2. The underwater mic
Placing a mic in a tub of water is one of the strangest recording techniques out there, but it's not a new one - John Lennon famously sang into an underwater microphone (protected by a condom) for "Yellow Submarine" (although that vocal take wasn't used in the final mix). Aside from making you sound like you're in a submarine, an underwater mic can also be good for capturing low, wobbly sounds from kick drums. Of course, you'll need to make sure the mic is fully encased in some sort of waterproof material so you don't electrocute anyone. The most common technique is to put a mic in a bucket of water right in front of the kick drum. This will give you another type lo-fi sound that ebbs and flows just like waves of the ocean.
3. Prepared instruments
Experimental recording techniques don't have to be limited to mic placement; sometimes the best way to modify a sound is to change the instrument itself. Since Erik Satie first started experimenting with placing objects on his piano strings in the early 20th century, pianists like John Cage and Hauschka have popularized the concept of the prepared piano as an instrument all of its own. Usually objects taped to a piano's strings are used to create percussive sounds, but they can also be used to dampen the sound, create more sustain, and really create any other type of sound you can imagine.
Pianos aren't the only instruments that can be prepared, too - you can get interesting sounds from guitars, drums, even orchestral strings by preparing them with simple household objects. Sometimes all it takes is a little coin taped to the front of a kick drum to help the drums cut through in the mix.
4. The gear mix-up
Just because a certain piece of gear was designed for a particular instrument doesn't mean it can't work on another instrument as well. Have you ever run a vocal through a guitar distortion pedal to give it some crunch? How about running a drum loop through a guitar amp to give it more life? When you take the limitations off of your gear, you open up new possibilities all over the place.
5. Taking matters into your own hands
Sometimes innovation in the studio can also come from a lack of gear. If you have a sound in your head that you want to capture, but you can't achieve it with the gear you have, maybe there's another way you could make that sound come to life.
Wednesday, 31 August 2016
Recording Loud Bands In The Studio
Recording a rock band playing 'live' in the studio presents a unique set of challenges, but it is still possible to achieve a good result.
Most recording techniques are easy enough to put into practice when you're only faced with the task of working with one instrument or voice at a time, but life gets more complicated when you come to record a rock band playing 'live' in the studio. The main problem in this scenario is spill, specifically from the louder instruments to the mics used on quieter sound sources. In a typical guitar-based rock band, the most vulnerable mics are those used by vocalists and the drum overheads, but acoustic instruments such as acoustic guitars or hand percussion can also present challenges.
Spill can be reduced by the careful setting up of the microphones and sound sources, though in a small studio you'll never get rid of it entirely, not even if you put up acoustic screens.
There may also be other problems, such as snare drums resonating and buzzing along with the bass guitar part where, even though you can gate the close snare-mic to get rid of it there, some buzzing may still be audible in the overhead mics. Fortunately, some drum-kit rattle and buzz currently seems acceptable as part of the natural sound of the kit, whereas, for example, in the '80s it was fashionable to try to keep the kit sounding as clean and sterile as possible.
Let's assume that you have the entire band set up in a lounge-sized room. What can you do to cut down on spill? Guitar amplifiers are obvious culprits, and rock guitarists still seem to like to have big amps turned well up. For recording, though, a small amp cranked hard will often give you a much bigger sound than a stage amp used in a confined space. I'm currently using one of the little Vox AD30VTs for recording, as they sound good at just about any level, but small tube amps such as the Fender Blues Junior are also ideal: if all those early Led Zeppelin tracks were recorded using a 6W tube amp, small amps have to be OK! Where you must use a high-powered stage amplifier, particularly a tube model, I'd seriously recommend investing in a good power soak to plug between the power amp and speaker, so that you can run the power amp hard while attenuating the amount of power reaching the speaker. Even five watts can sound pretty loud in a small room, so choose a model with switchable attenuation settings, such as the THD Hot Plate (see SOS June 2006 for more about power soaks).
You don't need a large stage amp to get a big sound. If you can persuade the guitarist to use a cranked-up small tube amp, you will probably get a better tone and reduce unwanted spillage into other 're only going to put the mic in front of one speaker, so using a 4 x 12 cabinet isn't really necessary unless you're recording in a very large space, where you can also make use of a distant mic to augment the sound. In a typical project or home studio, it is pretty universally accepted wisdom that you put the mic fairly close in, in front of the best-sounding speaker — though using a smaller cabinet with a single speaker might give you just as good a sound, while also reducing spill. As regular readers will already know, the choice of mic and its position across the front of the speaker cone have a dramatic effect on the sound you ultimately capture, so try everything you have and make notes on what works. My personal favourites from my own mic collection are an SE ribbon mic and an Audio Technica AT4050 capacitor mic, though many engineers still swear by the Shure SM57 dynamic mic. There are no real rules and every combination will sound different, so please take the time to try a few different options. Getting the right sound at source is invariably better than struggling with EQ after you've made the recording.
There are various strategies that can really help reduce spill from guitar amplifiers, one of which is to point the guitar amplifiers (this is simpler with closed-back models) away from the drum kit and other vulnerable mics, and to place a thick sound-absorber a couple of feet in front of the amplifier to soak up some of the sound once it has gone past the microphone (which will usually be no more than six inches from the speaker grille cloth). We've tried mattresses, soft furnishing such as sofas, heavy folded blankets and, of course, folded duvets. They all help, but there'll still be some spill. With open-backed amplifiers, it is worth experimenting by pointing the side of the amplifier towards vulnerable mics, as open-backed cabinets have a modified dipole (figure-of-eight) polar pattern, which means that more sound comes out of the front and back than out of the sides. This time you may wish to improvise sound absorbers between the amp and the other vulnerable mics in the room, as well as behind the microphone.
If you think something might work, don't be afraid to give it a try: you might just stumble across something really effective. If you're recording in your living room, for example, try sticking the guitar amps behind the sofa to get more separation. For one project, I got the sound I was looking for by putting a 4 x 12 cabinet flat on its back, then draping blankets, sleeping bags and duvets directly over the cabinet and microphone stand.
If you must use a large tube amp, a power soak such as the THD Hot Plate pictured here will allow you to drive the amp harder without increasing the overall another approach, which has been used on many records, is to have the guitarists playing in the same room as the rest of the band, monitoring via headphones in the usual way, but with the amp miked up in a separate room, or even in a cupboard. Many a classic album has been recorded with the guitar amp in the studio toilet!
Because guitar amps are traditionally miked very close to the speaker grille, spill from other amplifiers or from drums should be at such a low level as not to be a problem. However, whenever you're recording multiple sources at once, using a separate mic for each source, you should always observe the 5:1 rule. That is, you should always ensure that the microphones are separated from each other by at least five times the distance between the microphones and the sources they are recording. This helps avoid phase-cancellation coloration, which is caused by the same source being picked up strongly by two or more microphones.
Where everyone is playing in the same room, a practical setup is to have the players arranged in a horseshoe shape, with the singer in the centre facing the drummer, and the amplifiers facing outwards, screened as well as possible. Remember that using improvised sound absorbers to provide separation and to deaden room coloration is essential for optimum sound quality, so don't skimp in this vital area.
With the exception of the rattling snare drum problem mentioned earlier, close-miked drums don't suffer too much from spill, as drums are basically loud and the mic is usually very close to the drum head. The room acoustics also have little influence on either close-mic'd drums or close-mic'd electric guitar amplifiers, simply because of the proximity of the microphone to the sound source. The overheads are, however, rather more vulnerable, as they are further from the kit and consequently likely to pick up more spill and room ambience. A useful strategy here is to position the overheads slightly in front of the kit and lower them to just above cymbal level. Try to position them so they are not too close to or far away from any individual cymbal, and aim the mics down towards the snare drum, trying to keep them both the same distance from the snare drum if possible. Hanging a duvet or other acoustic absorber behind the kit can stop the overheads picking up reflections from the rear wall and, if at all possible, it is worth using foam collars (such as those made by Auralex) or SE's Instrument Reflexion Filters directly behind the mics, to reduce the impact of sound approaching from the rear and sides of the mics. Even cardioids are only 'deaf' to sound directly on the rear axis — sounds coming from the sides are picked up relatively strongly. If you can improvise more substantial acoustic absorbers between the overhead mics and the guitar amplifiers, so much the better. However, remember that eye contact is often an important part of a good performance, so make sure the drummer can still see the other band members.
As well as considering mic patterns, you should consider those of the sound sources. An open-backed amp, such as the one pictured here, for example, will emit sound to the rear. You should therefore consider how best to position the amp to avoid spill into the mics used elsewhere in the you're still suffering more spill than you'd like when you come to mix, you may need to rely a little more on the close mics, and a little less on the overheads. However, the overheads do need to be loud enough to provide a credible balance for the cymbals, so a useful compromise is to apply some low cut to the overheads at around 250Hz, to clean up the sound and focus on the cymbal component. When this signal is added to those from the close mics, you should still get all the punch you need, but without the muddying effect produced by all that low-frequency and lower-mid spill.
Because I've assumed that this recording is being made in a typical home studio environment, where the acoustics are unlikely to be conducive to a great drum sound, you will need to add in some artificial ambience using a reverb device or plug-in of some kind. Short ambience treatments work well to provide a sense of space without making the sound seem too muddy or washy. This approach can be very successful, providing you've used acoustic absorbers to reduce the amount of off-axis sound getting into the overhead mics, as adding artificial reverb to unpleasant room coloration rarely works. Also bear in mind that any compression you add to the overhead mics will also emphasise spill and room coloration, so if you need to create a punchier sound it may be safer to apply compression mainly to the close drum mics, rather than to the overheads or the overall drum mix. Overall EQ lift in the 12kHz region will add sparkle to the cymbals, and you may also find you need some lower-mid cut in the 200 to 400Hz range, to tame any boxiness that has crept into the sound due to the room acoustics.
The bass guitar itself is easy to record — either via microphone or DI — but it can cause problems elsewhere in the room, as low frequencies are not so easily contained as mid-range and high frequencies. Low bass also tends to cause snare-drum vibration problems. One compromise is to simply play the bass at a lower volume, which shouldn't affect the feel of the performance if everyone hears a decent headphone balance. Another useful tactic is to record the output of the bass amp, either via a mic or by DI'ing from the preamp, but at the same time to record a clean DI directly from the bass itself, using an active DI box to split the signal. You can then EQ out some of the low bass from the amplifier to reduce drum rattling, adding this back in when you mix from the direct (non-EQ'd) DI. The thinking behind this is that most of the character of a bass sound resides in the mid-range frequencies, so it shouldn't make the sound any less characterful if you exclude the deep bass from the amp and then replace it with the low-pass-filtered direct DI.
When it comes to live recording, DI boxes are your friends! For bass, you can filter out the lowest frequencies from the amp and add them back in from the DI signal when mixing. In this way you get the character of the amp during the recording, but minimise unwanted vibration of other instruments, such as drums, caused by the low course, you can lose the spill altogether by using a recording preamp such as Line 6's Bass Pod, which will give a good account of itself for just about any musical style, but don't forget that you need to have a good headphone mix set up to recreate the experience of playing at a realistic level.
As with acoustic guitar, the human voice versus a 100W Marshall stack is a no-contest scenario, so to have any chance of recording usable vocals at the same time as the other instruments, you need either to moderate the sound levels in the room or move the singer to an adjoining room. The latter is preferable from the separation point of view, but less than ideal from a performance perspective. Most often, the singer will record a guide vocal in the room with the band and then replace this later as an overdub but, where it is imperative that the performance be captured live, a substantial expanse of duvet behind the singer and an SE Reflexion filter or similar screen behind and to the sides of the mic will help a lot. Providing the amps are pointing away from the vocal mic, and that the singer works very close to the mic, as they would in live performance, you might just get away with it.
Working this close invariably means using either a stage dynamic mic, normally designed for hand-held use, or a stage hand-held capacitor mic, such as the Neumann KMS105 or the Rode S2. If you use a conventional side-address studio microphone you're unlikely to be able to get close enough to eliminate the worst of the spill without serious popping problems, as any effective pop screen needs to be located a couple of inches from the mic to be effective. Even using a stage mic you'll probably still need good mic technique to avoid popping and, if at all possible, you should get the singer to leave the mic on the stand rather than holding it, as the relative position of the mic and acoustic screens is important.
As with any recording session, remember to consult the singer as to what headphone monitor balance they need and how much reverb they'd like to hear on their own voice while performing.
Keyboards can usually be DI'd without causing any problems, unless you're miking a real rotary speaker cabinet — not a common occurrence in project studios, due to the large physical size of the things! In the event you do have an old Leslie lying around that you wish to use for the recording, there's no reason not to DI the keyboard dry, then feed the track back out through the Leslie prior to mixing, recording the result onto a new stereo track.
For vocal recordings, a studio side-address mic will usually pick up too much spill. If you need to record the vocals live, a stage mic is probably a better option. You don't have to settle for a dynamic mic, though, as there are now plenty of stage condensers around, such as the Neumann KMS105 (pictured) and the Rode S2.Brass and woodwind instruments are generally fairly loud, and a rock sax sound can be achieved by miking close to the bell, even though this doesn't give the most accurate representation of the instrument. Again, relative position of the mic to the instrument is important, and clip-on mics can be useful here if the player tends to move around a lot. In terms of separation, you can apply the same rules when recording quieter wind instruments as when recording vocals — that is, putting absorbers behind both the player and the mic.
Acoustic pianos can be a problem, but in a rock band context you're unlikely to be trying to create a classical concert piano sound, so you can afford to use a pair of mics just a few inches from the strings. If there's enough room, you may even be able to close the piano lid to give you better isolation. This will produce a harder, more assertive sound than classical miking at a distance, but many pop and rock producers prefer this sound in any case, as it cuts through well in a mix. The simplest solution, of course, is to use a good electronic piano, but not every player is happy to make that compromise.
In my experience, a lot of bands try to play their studio set just as they would live, which often results in a guitar tone that is far too dirty to mix comfortably. A practical solution is to use an active DI box to split the guitar signal, so that the Thru signal feeds the amp and the buffered signal is recorded clean to a separate track. If you find the original mic'd amp sound isn't working in the mix, you then have the option of re-amping the clean DI'd track by feeding it out into a guitar amp that has been mic'd in the usual way, or using a plug-in amp simulator to turn the DI'd sound into a plausible rock sound. You may even be able to combine the processed DI'd sound with the original amp recording to achieve a satisfactory result. If you're not convinced the band has got it right, this is a very easy way to cover yourself.
On the subject of setting levels, you should remember to leave plenty of headroom, as sound levels invariably creep up as the players get into their stride during the session. If you are recording at 24-bit resolution, then you can easily afford to leave 12dB of headroom, which will normally give you a viable safety margin against 'level-creep'.
Most of what I've discussed here would seem, in hindsight, to be largely common sense, but it is surprising how many seemingly obvious factors can get overlooked when your prime concern is getting your music down. Moderating the level of guitar and bass amplifiers, either by choosing smaller amplifiers or using power soaks, not only reduces spill but often produces a better sound. Recording with less amplifier distortion than you use live is also a good thing to try if you can: you can always add more distortion or compression later, but you can't clean up a sound that has been over-distorted, which is why I suggested the 'safety' straight DI.
The other important factor is the use of acoustic screens (or mattresses, duvets, sleeping bags and so on). These make a huge difference in minimising spill and taming unwanted room reflections, and you should not under-estimate their importance. The new generation of screens designed to go behind mics are also very effective, and if you do a lot of recording as a band, these are well worth considering. However, you should always remember to balance the use of screens with the need for visual communication between the members of the band while performing.
Finally, the better your source sounds, and the less spill you have, the easier your song will be to mix. By now you will probably have learned that the phrase 'fix it in the mix' is somewhat over-optimistic and that a great mix starts with a great recording of a great performance.
SOS
Most recording techniques are easy enough to put into practice when you're only faced with the task of working with one instrument or voice at a time, but life gets more complicated when you come to record a rock band playing 'live' in the studio. The main problem in this scenario is spill, specifically from the louder instruments to the mics used on quieter sound sources. In a typical guitar-based rock band, the most vulnerable mics are those used by vocalists and the drum overheads, but acoustic instruments such as acoustic guitars or hand percussion can also present challenges.
Spill can be reduced by the careful setting up of the microphones and sound sources, though in a small studio you'll never get rid of it entirely, not even if you put up acoustic screens.
There may also be other problems, such as snare drums resonating and buzzing along with the bass guitar part where, even though you can gate the close snare-mic to get rid of it there, some buzzing may still be audible in the overhead mics. Fortunately, some drum-kit rattle and buzz currently seems acceptable as part of the natural sound of the kit, whereas, for example, in the '80s it was fashionable to try to keep the kit sounding as clean and sterile as possible.
Let's assume that you have the entire band set up in a lounge-sized room. What can you do to cut down on spill? Guitar amplifiers are obvious culprits, and rock guitarists still seem to like to have big amps turned well up. For recording, though, a small amp cranked hard will often give you a much bigger sound than a stage amp used in a confined space. I'm currently using one of the little Vox AD30VTs for recording, as they sound good at just about any level, but small tube amps such as the Fender Blues Junior are also ideal: if all those early Led Zeppelin tracks were recorded using a 6W tube amp, small amps have to be OK! Where you must use a high-powered stage amplifier, particularly a tube model, I'd seriously recommend investing in a good power soak to plug between the power amp and speaker, so that you can run the power amp hard while attenuating the amount of power reaching the speaker. Even five watts can sound pretty loud in a small room, so choose a model with switchable attenuation settings, such as the THD Hot Plate (see SOS June 2006 for more about power soaks).
You don't need a large stage amp to get a big sound. If you can persuade the guitarist to use a cranked-up small tube amp, you will probably get a better tone and reduce unwanted spillage into other 're only going to put the mic in front of one speaker, so using a 4 x 12 cabinet isn't really necessary unless you're recording in a very large space, where you can also make use of a distant mic to augment the sound. In a typical project or home studio, it is pretty universally accepted wisdom that you put the mic fairly close in, in front of the best-sounding speaker — though using a smaller cabinet with a single speaker might give you just as good a sound, while also reducing spill. As regular readers will already know, the choice of mic and its position across the front of the speaker cone have a dramatic effect on the sound you ultimately capture, so try everything you have and make notes on what works. My personal favourites from my own mic collection are an SE ribbon mic and an Audio Technica AT4050 capacitor mic, though many engineers still swear by the Shure SM57 dynamic mic. There are no real rules and every combination will sound different, so please take the time to try a few different options. Getting the right sound at source is invariably better than struggling with EQ after you've made the recording.
There are various strategies that can really help reduce spill from guitar amplifiers, one of which is to point the guitar amplifiers (this is simpler with closed-back models) away from the drum kit and other vulnerable mics, and to place a thick sound-absorber a couple of feet in front of the amplifier to soak up some of the sound once it has gone past the microphone (which will usually be no more than six inches from the speaker grille cloth). We've tried mattresses, soft furnishing such as sofas, heavy folded blankets and, of course, folded duvets. They all help, but there'll still be some spill. With open-backed amplifiers, it is worth experimenting by pointing the side of the amplifier towards vulnerable mics, as open-backed cabinets have a modified dipole (figure-of-eight) polar pattern, which means that more sound comes out of the front and back than out of the sides. This time you may wish to improvise sound absorbers between the amp and the other vulnerable mics in the room, as well as behind the microphone.
If you think something might work, don't be afraid to give it a try: you might just stumble across something really effective. If you're recording in your living room, for example, try sticking the guitar amps behind the sofa to get more separation. For one project, I got the sound I was looking for by putting a 4 x 12 cabinet flat on its back, then draping blankets, sleeping bags and duvets directly over the cabinet and microphone stand.
If you must use a large tube amp, a power soak such as the THD Hot Plate pictured here will allow you to drive the amp harder without increasing the overall another approach, which has been used on many records, is to have the guitarists playing in the same room as the rest of the band, monitoring via headphones in the usual way, but with the amp miked up in a separate room, or even in a cupboard. Many a classic album has been recorded with the guitar amp in the studio toilet!
Because guitar amps are traditionally miked very close to the speaker grille, spill from other amplifiers or from drums should be at such a low level as not to be a problem. However, whenever you're recording multiple sources at once, using a separate mic for each source, you should always observe the 5:1 rule. That is, you should always ensure that the microphones are separated from each other by at least five times the distance between the microphones and the sources they are recording. This helps avoid phase-cancellation coloration, which is caused by the same source being picked up strongly by two or more microphones.
Where everyone is playing in the same room, a practical setup is to have the players arranged in a horseshoe shape, with the singer in the centre facing the drummer, and the amplifiers facing outwards, screened as well as possible. Remember that using improvised sound absorbers to provide separation and to deaden room coloration is essential for optimum sound quality, so don't skimp in this vital area.
With the exception of the rattling snare drum problem mentioned earlier, close-miked drums don't suffer too much from spill, as drums are basically loud and the mic is usually very close to the drum head. The room acoustics also have little influence on either close-mic'd drums or close-mic'd electric guitar amplifiers, simply because of the proximity of the microphone to the sound source. The overheads are, however, rather more vulnerable, as they are further from the kit and consequently likely to pick up more spill and room ambience. A useful strategy here is to position the overheads slightly in front of the kit and lower them to just above cymbal level. Try to position them so they are not too close to or far away from any individual cymbal, and aim the mics down towards the snare drum, trying to keep them both the same distance from the snare drum if possible. Hanging a duvet or other acoustic absorber behind the kit can stop the overheads picking up reflections from the rear wall and, if at all possible, it is worth using foam collars (such as those made by Auralex) or SE's Instrument Reflexion Filters directly behind the mics, to reduce the impact of sound approaching from the rear and sides of the mics. Even cardioids are only 'deaf' to sound directly on the rear axis — sounds coming from the sides are picked up relatively strongly. If you can improvise more substantial acoustic absorbers between the overhead mics and the guitar amplifiers, so much the better. However, remember that eye contact is often an important part of a good performance, so make sure the drummer can still see the other band members.
As well as considering mic patterns, you should consider those of the sound sources. An open-backed amp, such as the one pictured here, for example, will emit sound to the rear. You should therefore consider how best to position the amp to avoid spill into the mics used elsewhere in the you're still suffering more spill than you'd like when you come to mix, you may need to rely a little more on the close mics, and a little less on the overheads. However, the overheads do need to be loud enough to provide a credible balance for the cymbals, so a useful compromise is to apply some low cut to the overheads at around 250Hz, to clean up the sound and focus on the cymbal component. When this signal is added to those from the close mics, you should still get all the punch you need, but without the muddying effect produced by all that low-frequency and lower-mid spill.
Because I've assumed that this recording is being made in a typical home studio environment, where the acoustics are unlikely to be conducive to a great drum sound, you will need to add in some artificial ambience using a reverb device or plug-in of some kind. Short ambience treatments work well to provide a sense of space without making the sound seem too muddy or washy. This approach can be very successful, providing you've used acoustic absorbers to reduce the amount of off-axis sound getting into the overhead mics, as adding artificial reverb to unpleasant room coloration rarely works. Also bear in mind that any compression you add to the overhead mics will also emphasise spill and room coloration, so if you need to create a punchier sound it may be safer to apply compression mainly to the close drum mics, rather than to the overheads or the overall drum mix. Overall EQ lift in the 12kHz region will add sparkle to the cymbals, and you may also find you need some lower-mid cut in the 200 to 400Hz range, to tame any boxiness that has crept into the sound due to the room acoustics.
The bass guitar itself is easy to record — either via microphone or DI — but it can cause problems elsewhere in the room, as low frequencies are not so easily contained as mid-range and high frequencies. Low bass also tends to cause snare-drum vibration problems. One compromise is to simply play the bass at a lower volume, which shouldn't affect the feel of the performance if everyone hears a decent headphone balance. Another useful tactic is to record the output of the bass amp, either via a mic or by DI'ing from the preamp, but at the same time to record a clean DI directly from the bass itself, using an active DI box to split the signal. You can then EQ out some of the low bass from the amplifier to reduce drum rattling, adding this back in when you mix from the direct (non-EQ'd) DI. The thinking behind this is that most of the character of a bass sound resides in the mid-range frequencies, so it shouldn't make the sound any less characterful if you exclude the deep bass from the amp and then replace it with the low-pass-filtered direct DI.
When it comes to live recording, DI boxes are your friends! For bass, you can filter out the lowest frequencies from the amp and add them back in from the DI signal when mixing. In this way you get the character of the amp during the recording, but minimise unwanted vibration of other instruments, such as drums, caused by the low course, you can lose the spill altogether by using a recording preamp such as Line 6's Bass Pod, which will give a good account of itself for just about any musical style, but don't forget that you need to have a good headphone mix set up to recreate the experience of playing at a realistic level.
As with acoustic guitar, the human voice versus a 100W Marshall stack is a no-contest scenario, so to have any chance of recording usable vocals at the same time as the other instruments, you need either to moderate the sound levels in the room or move the singer to an adjoining room. The latter is preferable from the separation point of view, but less than ideal from a performance perspective. Most often, the singer will record a guide vocal in the room with the band and then replace this later as an overdub but, where it is imperative that the performance be captured live, a substantial expanse of duvet behind the singer and an SE Reflexion filter or similar screen behind and to the sides of the mic will help a lot. Providing the amps are pointing away from the vocal mic, and that the singer works very close to the mic, as they would in live performance, you might just get away with it.
Working this close invariably means using either a stage dynamic mic, normally designed for hand-held use, or a stage hand-held capacitor mic, such as the Neumann KMS105 or the Rode S2. If you use a conventional side-address studio microphone you're unlikely to be able to get close enough to eliminate the worst of the spill without serious popping problems, as any effective pop screen needs to be located a couple of inches from the mic to be effective. Even using a stage mic you'll probably still need good mic technique to avoid popping and, if at all possible, you should get the singer to leave the mic on the stand rather than holding it, as the relative position of the mic and acoustic screens is important.
As with any recording session, remember to consult the singer as to what headphone monitor balance they need and how much reverb they'd like to hear on their own voice while performing.
Keyboards can usually be DI'd without causing any problems, unless you're miking a real rotary speaker cabinet — not a common occurrence in project studios, due to the large physical size of the things! In the event you do have an old Leslie lying around that you wish to use for the recording, there's no reason not to DI the keyboard dry, then feed the track back out through the Leslie prior to mixing, recording the result onto a new stereo track.
For vocal recordings, a studio side-address mic will usually pick up too much spill. If you need to record the vocals live, a stage mic is probably a better option. You don't have to settle for a dynamic mic, though, as there are now plenty of stage condensers around, such as the Neumann KMS105 (pictured) and the Rode S2.Brass and woodwind instruments are generally fairly loud, and a rock sax sound can be achieved by miking close to the bell, even though this doesn't give the most accurate representation of the instrument. Again, relative position of the mic to the instrument is important, and clip-on mics can be useful here if the player tends to move around a lot. In terms of separation, you can apply the same rules when recording quieter wind instruments as when recording vocals — that is, putting absorbers behind both the player and the mic.
Acoustic pianos can be a problem, but in a rock band context you're unlikely to be trying to create a classical concert piano sound, so you can afford to use a pair of mics just a few inches from the strings. If there's enough room, you may even be able to close the piano lid to give you better isolation. This will produce a harder, more assertive sound than classical miking at a distance, but many pop and rock producers prefer this sound in any case, as it cuts through well in a mix. The simplest solution, of course, is to use a good electronic piano, but not every player is happy to make that compromise.
In my experience, a lot of bands try to play their studio set just as they would live, which often results in a guitar tone that is far too dirty to mix comfortably. A practical solution is to use an active DI box to split the guitar signal, so that the Thru signal feeds the amp and the buffered signal is recorded clean to a separate track. If you find the original mic'd amp sound isn't working in the mix, you then have the option of re-amping the clean DI'd track by feeding it out into a guitar amp that has been mic'd in the usual way, or using a plug-in amp simulator to turn the DI'd sound into a plausible rock sound. You may even be able to combine the processed DI'd sound with the original amp recording to achieve a satisfactory result. If you're not convinced the band has got it right, this is a very easy way to cover yourself.
On the subject of setting levels, you should remember to leave plenty of headroom, as sound levels invariably creep up as the players get into their stride during the session. If you are recording at 24-bit resolution, then you can easily afford to leave 12dB of headroom, which will normally give you a viable safety margin against 'level-creep'.
Most of what I've discussed here would seem, in hindsight, to be largely common sense, but it is surprising how many seemingly obvious factors can get overlooked when your prime concern is getting your music down. Moderating the level of guitar and bass amplifiers, either by choosing smaller amplifiers or using power soaks, not only reduces spill but often produces a better sound. Recording with less amplifier distortion than you use live is also a good thing to try if you can: you can always add more distortion or compression later, but you can't clean up a sound that has been over-distorted, which is why I suggested the 'safety' straight DI.
The other important factor is the use of acoustic screens (or mattresses, duvets, sleeping bags and so on). These make a huge difference in minimising spill and taming unwanted room reflections, and you should not under-estimate their importance. The new generation of screens designed to go behind mics are also very effective, and if you do a lot of recording as a band, these are well worth considering. However, you should always remember to balance the use of screens with the need for visual communication between the members of the band while performing.
Finally, the better your source sounds, and the less spill you have, the easier your song will be to mix. By now you will probably have learned that the phrase 'fix it in the mix' is somewhat over-optimistic and that a great mix starts with a great recording of a great performance.
SOS
Friday, 26 August 2016
Practical Recording Techniques
by Bruce Bartlett
We can't afford to record in your studio, so we'll record at home and you can mix it”. Sound familiar?
In a tough economy, an increasing number of musicians don't have the money to spend several days or weeks in a studio at the hourly rate. What's more, a lot of artists need time to develop sonic ideas by trial and error, and can't afford to do that on studio time.
Some performers shun the studio for other reasons. I get too nervous in the studio… I'll just record myself with a portable recorder and let you overdub the other instruments.”
Many musicians own DAW setups — or flash recorders — and can do their own tracking at home. But some lack the expertise and equipment to make clean recordings in the first place.
They might hand you a load of barely usable tracks, and expect you to make them sound good.
While a number of musicians have mastered recording skills and can produce great-sounding tracks, some don't know what they're doing. They need your help. If you want to put your name on their album or demo, you want to work with them so they'll record the cleanest tracks possible. Then you'll spend less time fixing sonic errors and more time being creative.
We'll look at two approaches to improve the end product:
teach your customers how to record at home effectively
use plug-ins and editing to improve their recordings.
Offer Advice to Record-at-Home Musicians: Talk with your clients to make sure they can supply you clean tracks. Try to find out their skill level so you don't insult them by telling them stuff they already know.
The advice you give home recordists is the same as you'd give to a novice recording engineer in a pro studio. You can discuss the following points wIth the band members, or simply give them this article to read.
First tell your customer that it's difficult or impossible to remove reverb, compression and distortion, so make sure to keep those under control. The same goes for background noise.
I'll describe specifically how to keep a handle on those problems.
Listed below are some suggestions for musicians to follow when recording. These tips apply both to 2-track and multitrack recordings.
Get rid of noise sources: Turn off the furnace or air-conditioning when you record. Maybe record in the basement — it tends to be quiet because it's surrounded by earth and cement blocks. Wait for trains and planes to pass. Seal cracks under doors with towels; maybe cover windows temporarily with plywood sheets. Have an electric guitarist rotate or move around to find a spot where hum stops.
Improve room acoustics: Hang some mattress foam, packing blankets, sleeping bags or comforters on the walls or on mic-stand booms. Put a roll of fiberglass insulation in each room corner to act as a bass trap. Or buy some pressed fiberglass panels and put one across each corner. One source is
Mike fairly close: If you place a mic or stereo recorder too far from the instruments, it will pick up lots of muddy-sounding room acoustics which can't be removed in the mix. Try to stay no farther than 1 foot from the mics or recorder.
Don't clip the signal: Check the recording levels not only during regular playing, but also during loud accents. Aim for -6 dB maximum level on peak-reading level meters. Some keyboard patches are louder than others — try all of them when setting levels.
Monitor the recording: Put on headphones and listen to what the mics are picking up. Often you can hear background noises much easier with headphones than without. Play back recordings to check balances between instruments and vocals.
Turn off effects: Some recorder-mixers automatically insert compression or other effects when you record. Make sure they are disabled.
Suggestions for Better Multitrack Recordings
Avoid ground loops: Connect recording equipment, keyboards and instrument amps to the same outlet strips. First make sure that the outlet's circuit breaker can handle the current of all that equipment. Use direct boxes between electric instruments and the mixer, and flip the ground-lift switch to the position where you monitor the least hum.
Use good mics: Borrow or rent some if you don't have any. A basic mic collection includes a cardioid dynamic mic for guitar amps and drums (like a Shure SM57), a small-diaphragm cardioid condenser mic for cymbals and acoustic instruments, and a large-diaphragm cardioid condenser for vocals.
Minimize leakage: In other words, try to make each mic pick up only its own instrument. To do that, mike close with cardioid or supercardioid mics — about 8 inches away or less.
Record bass and keys direct. Overdub quiet instruments and vocals after recording the loud instruments. You might place the band members in a circle so that adjacent mics aim away from each other.
Use effective mic placement: Ask your recording engineer how to mike various instruments, or refer to articles and books about that topic. (I've received acoustic-guitar tracks made with the mic close to the sound hole, and had to EQ like crazy to get rid of the boomy sound.)
Suggest that the drummer remove the front head of the kick drum, put a pillow or blanket inside, and use a hard beater to get a tight, snappy beat.
Figure 2. One method of miking a kick drum.
Use a pop filter on vocal mics: To prevent breath pops, place a hoop-type pop filter a few inches in front of a vocal mic. You can improvise one: try a coat-hanger wire curved like a shepherd's crook, with a nylon stocking stretched over the loop. You might use a foam windscreen as a last resort.
Solo and export each recorded track starting from time zero: That way, all the tracks should line up when imported into the studio's mixing software. Disable any effects plug-ins when you export the tracks so that the studio can use only their own plug-ins.
Name each track's wave file by the song and instrument: For example, Road Runner Blues-lead ”. Or Soul Spice-high harmony 2nd ”. That avoids confusion in the studio when it comes time to sort out the tracks.
Ways to Minimize Time in the Studio
Some musicians do want to record in the studio because the sound they get is so much better than they can get at home. They need to know how to make the recording process as efficient as possible so they don't run up a huge bill. You might offer these suggestions:
Record yourself with a simple DAW or recorder-mixer to work out production ideas at home. See what works and what doesn't so you don't need to experiment in the pro studio.
Bring lyric sheets and charts with each song's arrangement. Work it out at home, then bring in charts as a memory aid in the studio. Make copies of the lyrics and arrangements for the engineer.
Consider recording fewer songs. A 10-song album costs about half as much to record as a 20-song album. 10 great songs are better than 20 songs with filler.
Practice until you can play without mistakes. Obviously, that saves studio time that is spent fixing errors.
Consider punching-in rather than fixing problem spots with editing. Often it's faster to re-record a botched musical phrase than to correct it with copy-paste edits or volume changes.
If you have changes you want to make in a mix that you auditioned at home, note the time of each change. Finding a time location is a lot quicker than finding a particular lyric in the second bridge!
Fixing It In the Mix
So far you have advised the band on ways to record well at home. Eventually they will hand you a hard drive, flash card or CD s containing their tracks. It's your job to take those raw recordings, clean them up, and add EQ and effects to make a super mix. Let's go over some tricks to achieve that goal. First we'll clean up the individual tracks.
Delete or mute parts of each track where nothing is playing: Those sections contain leakage and noise. Either slip-edit the beginning and end of each clip, or highlight unwanted sections and delete them. Another method is to use volume envelopes or automated mutes to silence the parts you don't need.
Gate drum tracks to reduce leakage or to tighten up the sound: Here's a typical procedure. Play and solo a tom-tom track that has a gate inserted. Gradually increase the gate threshold until the background leakage goes away, but you still hear the tom hits. Set the attack time fast, like 1 msec, and set the hold time for the desired amount of sustain on each note.
Some gate plug-ins have a setting called lookahead time”. If you set it to 10 msec, for example, the gate opens 10 msec before the transient hit occurs. That lets you use a longer attack time (rise time) without losing the transient's attack.
Highpass filter every track: Insert a highpass (low-cut) filter in a track. Set Q to 1.7 and play the track. Start with the filter frequency at 20 Hz , gradually raise it until the sound thins out, then back off a bit. That removes noise and leakage below the lowest fundamental frequency of each instrument and vocal.
Fix clipped notes: Suppose a kick-drum hit is clipped and sounds crackly. Find the full-amplitude spike where the clipping occurred. Zoom way into the waveform until you can see the individual waves.
One solution is to delete the clipped waveforms and add short fades into and out of the hole" that is left.
Another solution is to create a clip (region) of those waveforms and lowpass filter the highs in that region. Some DAWs let you redraw the waveform in a smooth curve to remove the clipping.
Here are audio samples of a clipped kick-drum signal before and after editing:
Filter out hum and hiss: Some EQ plug-ins have a hum-filter preset which inserts a comb filter starting at 50 or 60 Hz Others have de-noise processing. A simple lowpass (high-cut) filter works well to remove hiss in a guitar-amp track. Try a Q of 1.7, and gradually bring down the filter frequency to the point where the sound gets dull, then back off.
Delete breath pops: Find a pop or thump in the vocal track. Zoom far into the waveform there until you can see the longer wavelength of the pop signal. Then highlight and delete it.
Add short fades into and out of the deleted section. It's amazing how well this works.
Enhancing Stereo Recordings
Some musicians record themselves with a portable stereo recorder. Here are some tips to improve a recording made on such a device.
Use an analyzer/ EQ program such as Harmonic Balancer: This program can work wonders on stereo mixes that have a bad tonal balance. Har-Bal analyzes and displays the spectrum of a mix so you can pull down any over-emphasized frequencies that color the sound ().
Cut frequencies below 40 Hz : There might be low-frequency rumble from trucks or air conditioning in the stereo mix.
Maybe add reverb: Homes don't have reverb with a long decay time, so you might add just a little reverb with 1.5 - 2.0 seconds RT60. That gives a more commercial" feel. Try to filter the lows out of the reverb signal so the bass and kick don't get muddy.
Add compression: If a singer really belts the loud notes, tame them with compression.
Widen or narrow the stereo stage: Plug-ins are available that create mid/side (sum/difference) signals from the left-and-right stereo signals. You can vary the amount of difference signal to expand or shrink the stereo image.
There you have a number of tips to enhance your customers' tracks and to optimize those tracks when they record them. Recording at home and mixing in the studio is becoming more common, so it helps to develop skills for this type of record production.
We can't afford to record in your studio, so we'll record at home and you can mix it”. Sound familiar?
In a tough economy, an increasing number of musicians don't have the money to spend several days or weeks in a studio at the hourly rate. What's more, a lot of artists need time to develop sonic ideas by trial and error, and can't afford to do that on studio time.
Some performers shun the studio for other reasons. I get too nervous in the studio… I'll just record myself with a portable recorder and let you overdub the other instruments.”
Many musicians own DAW setups — or flash recorders — and can do their own tracking at home. But some lack the expertise and equipment to make clean recordings in the first place.
They might hand you a load of barely usable tracks, and expect you to make them sound good.
While a number of musicians have mastered recording skills and can produce great-sounding tracks, some don't know what they're doing. They need your help. If you want to put your name on their album or demo, you want to work with them so they'll record the cleanest tracks possible. Then you'll spend less time fixing sonic errors and more time being creative.
We'll look at two approaches to improve the end product:
teach your customers how to record at home effectively
use plug-ins and editing to improve their recordings.
Offer Advice to Record-at-Home Musicians: Talk with your clients to make sure they can supply you clean tracks. Try to find out their skill level so you don't insult them by telling them stuff they already know.
The advice you give home recordists is the same as you'd give to a novice recording engineer in a pro studio. You can discuss the following points wIth the band members, or simply give them this article to read.
First tell your customer that it's difficult or impossible to remove reverb, compression and distortion, so make sure to keep those under control. The same goes for background noise.
I'll describe specifically how to keep a handle on those problems.
Listed below are some suggestions for musicians to follow when recording. These tips apply both to 2-track and multitrack recordings.
Get rid of noise sources: Turn off the furnace or air-conditioning when you record. Maybe record in the basement — it tends to be quiet because it's surrounded by earth and cement blocks. Wait for trains and planes to pass. Seal cracks under doors with towels; maybe cover windows temporarily with plywood sheets. Have an electric guitarist rotate or move around to find a spot where hum stops.
Improve room acoustics: Hang some mattress foam, packing blankets, sleeping bags or comforters on the walls or on mic-stand booms. Put a roll of fiberglass insulation in each room corner to act as a bass trap. Or buy some pressed fiberglass panels and put one across each corner. One source is
Mike fairly close: If you place a mic or stereo recorder too far from the instruments, it will pick up lots of muddy-sounding room acoustics which can't be removed in the mix. Try to stay no farther than 1 foot from the mics or recorder.
Don't clip the signal: Check the recording levels not only during regular playing, but also during loud accents. Aim for -6 dB maximum level on peak-reading level meters. Some keyboard patches are louder than others — try all of them when setting levels.
Monitor the recording: Put on headphones and listen to what the mics are picking up. Often you can hear background noises much easier with headphones than without. Play back recordings to check balances between instruments and vocals.
Turn off effects: Some recorder-mixers automatically insert compression or other effects when you record. Make sure they are disabled.
Suggestions for Better Multitrack Recordings
Avoid ground loops: Connect recording equipment, keyboards and instrument amps to the same outlet strips. First make sure that the outlet's circuit breaker can handle the current of all that equipment. Use direct boxes between electric instruments and the mixer, and flip the ground-lift switch to the position where you monitor the least hum.
Use good mics: Borrow or rent some if you don't have any. A basic mic collection includes a cardioid dynamic mic for guitar amps and drums (like a Shure SM57), a small-diaphragm cardioid condenser mic for cymbals and acoustic instruments, and a large-diaphragm cardioid condenser for vocals.
Minimize leakage: In other words, try to make each mic pick up only its own instrument. To do that, mike close with cardioid or supercardioid mics — about 8 inches away or less.
Record bass and keys direct. Overdub quiet instruments and vocals after recording the loud instruments. You might place the band members in a circle so that adjacent mics aim away from each other.
Use effective mic placement: Ask your recording engineer how to mike various instruments, or refer to articles and books about that topic. (I've received acoustic-guitar tracks made with the mic close to the sound hole, and had to EQ like crazy to get rid of the boomy sound.)
Suggest that the drummer remove the front head of the kick drum, put a pillow or blanket inside, and use a hard beater to get a tight, snappy beat.
Figure 2. One method of miking a kick drum.
Use a pop filter on vocal mics: To prevent breath pops, place a hoop-type pop filter a few inches in front of a vocal mic. You can improvise one: try a coat-hanger wire curved like a shepherd's crook, with a nylon stocking stretched over the loop. You might use a foam windscreen as a last resort.
Solo and export each recorded track starting from time zero: That way, all the tracks should line up when imported into the studio's mixing software. Disable any effects plug-ins when you export the tracks so that the studio can use only their own plug-ins.
Name each track's wave file by the song and instrument: For example, Road Runner Blues-lead ”. Or Soul Spice-high harmony 2nd ”. That avoids confusion in the studio when it comes time to sort out the tracks.
Ways to Minimize Time in the Studio
Some musicians do want to record in the studio because the sound they get is so much better than they can get at home. They need to know how to make the recording process as efficient as possible so they don't run up a huge bill. You might offer these suggestions:
Record yourself with a simple DAW or recorder-mixer to work out production ideas at home. See what works and what doesn't so you don't need to experiment in the pro studio.
Bring lyric sheets and charts with each song's arrangement. Work it out at home, then bring in charts as a memory aid in the studio. Make copies of the lyrics and arrangements for the engineer.
Consider recording fewer songs. A 10-song album costs about half as much to record as a 20-song album. 10 great songs are better than 20 songs with filler.
Practice until you can play without mistakes. Obviously, that saves studio time that is spent fixing errors.
Consider punching-in rather than fixing problem spots with editing. Often it's faster to re-record a botched musical phrase than to correct it with copy-paste edits or volume changes.
If you have changes you want to make in a mix that you auditioned at home, note the time of each change. Finding a time location is a lot quicker than finding a particular lyric in the second bridge!
Fixing It In the Mix
So far you have advised the band on ways to record well at home. Eventually they will hand you a hard drive, flash card or CD s containing their tracks. It's your job to take those raw recordings, clean them up, and add EQ and effects to make a super mix. Let's go over some tricks to achieve that goal. First we'll clean up the individual tracks.
Delete or mute parts of each track where nothing is playing: Those sections contain leakage and noise. Either slip-edit the beginning and end of each clip, or highlight unwanted sections and delete them. Another method is to use volume envelopes or automated mutes to silence the parts you don't need.
Gate drum tracks to reduce leakage or to tighten up the sound: Here's a typical procedure. Play and solo a tom-tom track that has a gate inserted. Gradually increase the gate threshold until the background leakage goes away, but you still hear the tom hits. Set the attack time fast, like 1 msec, and set the hold time for the desired amount of sustain on each note.
Some gate plug-ins have a setting called lookahead time”. If you set it to 10 msec, for example, the gate opens 10 msec before the transient hit occurs. That lets you use a longer attack time (rise time) without losing the transient's attack.
Highpass filter every track: Insert a highpass (low-cut) filter in a track. Set Q to 1.7 and play the track. Start with the filter frequency at 20 Hz , gradually raise it until the sound thins out, then back off a bit. That removes noise and leakage below the lowest fundamental frequency of each instrument and vocal.
Fix clipped notes: Suppose a kick-drum hit is clipped and sounds crackly. Find the full-amplitude spike where the clipping occurred. Zoom way into the waveform until you can see the individual waves.
One solution is to delete the clipped waveforms and add short fades into and out of the hole" that is left.
Another solution is to create a clip (region) of those waveforms and lowpass filter the highs in that region. Some DAWs let you redraw the waveform in a smooth curve to remove the clipping.
Here are audio samples of a clipped kick-drum signal before and after editing:
Filter out hum and hiss: Some EQ plug-ins have a hum-filter preset which inserts a comb filter starting at 50 or 60 Hz Others have de-noise processing. A simple lowpass (high-cut) filter works well to remove hiss in a guitar-amp track. Try a Q of 1.7, and gradually bring down the filter frequency to the point where the sound gets dull, then back off.
Delete breath pops: Find a pop or thump in the vocal track. Zoom far into the waveform there until you can see the longer wavelength of the pop signal. Then highlight and delete it.
Add short fades into and out of the deleted section. It's amazing how well this works.
Enhancing Stereo Recordings
Some musicians record themselves with a portable stereo recorder. Here are some tips to improve a recording made on such a device.
Use an analyzer/ EQ program such as Harmonic Balancer: This program can work wonders on stereo mixes that have a bad tonal balance. Har-Bal analyzes and displays the spectrum of a mix so you can pull down any over-emphasized frequencies that color the sound ().
Cut frequencies below 40 Hz : There might be low-frequency rumble from trucks or air conditioning in the stereo mix.
Maybe add reverb: Homes don't have reverb with a long decay time, so you might add just a little reverb with 1.5 - 2.0 seconds RT60. That gives a more commercial" feel. Try to filter the lows out of the reverb signal so the bass and kick don't get muddy.
Add compression: If a singer really belts the loud notes, tame them with compression.
Widen or narrow the stereo stage: Plug-ins are available that create mid/side (sum/difference) signals from the left-and-right stereo signals. You can vary the amount of difference signal to expand or shrink the stereo image.
There you have a number of tips to enhance your customers' tracks and to optimize those tracks when they record them. Recording at home and mixing in the studio is becoming more common, so it helps to develop skills for this type of record production.
Tuesday, 23 August 2016
Microphone Placement
Microphone placement is the foundation for any solid recording. Placement is usually dictated by musical genre but most engineers place microphones to capture a good overall balance of the instrument. This article proves to present some different placement techniques for a simple acoustic guitar recording.
1. Blumlein Configuration
Blumlein requires the use of two Bi-Directional Microphones placed at a 90º angle. Bi-Directional microphones capture the signal in front of them and behind so the room ambience plays a significant factor in the sound. Most microphones have a setting that looks like a figure 8” and can be switched easily into this mode. As you can see by the above image it takes a bit of setup to get the capsules of the microphones as close to one another as possible without having them touch. The next step is getting the 90º angle to face the sound source.
In this case the microphones were moderately close to the acoustic guitar player and the 90º angle was pointing at the highest fret of the guitar which was just past the sound hole.
The outcome was a wide and clear signal that could accommodate most recordings for general acoustic guitar tracking. This worked well because the signal was within a small and somewhat quiet room. I found that the signal could be routed in stereo or mono and still work well in most mix situations.
2. One Large Diaphragm Condenser Close Mic
This placement used a single Large Diaphragm Condenser facing the area between the soundhole and the top of the fretboard. The microphone was switched into the Cardioid polar pattern setting to reduce any room ambience from behind the microphone. Cardioid focus the microphone to only retain signals from mostly in front of the microphone. This setting is much more narrow in comparison to a stereo configuration and would be perfect for double-tracking purposes where the player would strum two different performances of the same chord progression and pan them hard left and hard right. By nature the microphone is very sensitive and picks up much of the low end of the acoustic giving it a thick and chunky sound. This caveat makes it the perfect candidate for Acoustic Guitar driven music where the acoustic guitar upholds much of the harmony for track.
3. Spaced Pair
This configuration uses two Small Condenser Microphones set about 2.5ft away from one another. One is pointed towards the 8th fret of the acoustic guitar and the other is pointed directly at the12th fret just past where most of the strumming is happening. I set these closer to the player because the microphones retain fewer lower frequencies that the large diaphragm microphones. They also tend to register the high end of the frequency spectrum with more detail.
A substantial part of the placement is how far the microphones are placed from the source. Placing the microphones any further from the source would have resulted in a thin sound and any closer would have choked the sound.
I am a fan of this configuration because it captures the fret noise as well as the body of the guitar. You could use this for many applications especially if the acoustic guitarist has a lot of busy left handed hammer-ons and pull-offs. The microphone that points at the neck of the guitar is there to capture these small intricacies that are lost down by the sound hole.
4. Mid-Side
This technique is used by some and hated by others. The Mid-Side microphone placement requires the use of two microphones and three signals. First one must set up the microphones in the configuration shown in the example. The Large Diaphragm Condenser is set to Figure 8” or Bi-Directional” (same thing) and placed so that the capsule of the microphone is perpendicular to the sound source. The Small Condenser Microphone is placed above it directly facing the sound source. The Small Condenser is the Mid” and the Large
Condenser is the Side”.
Special Routing
When processing these tracks I was able to extract just the single Small Condenser microphone from the Mid-Side placement. If you review example two of this article you can hear how severely different the tone, body, and clarity of a LDC vs the SDC mono signals. The brightness of the Small Condenser microphone would be useful in a track with dense and complex instrumentation.
6. Vertical Spaced Pair
This is my favorite configuration out of all the ones listed in this article. In the above picture I have placed two SDC microphones in a vertical spaced pairing about seven inches apart.
The bottom microphone's capsule is pointed directly at the lower three strings of the acoustic and the top microphone is pointed at the top three strings. Angling them inward balances both the high and low end so that there aren't very many holes in the fidelity of the signal.
When panning these signals extreme left and right the stereo image is very interesting. Depending on strum direction you can almost feel the attack of the guitar pick on the high and low strings moving from left to right and right to left. This may not be every engineers ideal microphone placement but it does lend itself to some interesting mix options. I would experiment with this placement specifically on a singer/songwriter act that had only acoustic guitar and vocal. The quality of the recording is very intimate and would be fitting for that style. Most of those types of acts rely heavily on the acoustic guitar for a controlled low end, present midrange, clear shimmering high end, without taking away from the vocal.
7. XY
The XY configuration is a stereo option for many different applications. For this you must have the two microphones placed at 90º angle with the capsules as close to one another as possible without having them touch. The angle is then pointed towards the sound source. For this placement I pointed the angle towards the sound hole of the guitar. The idea was to get a somewhat wide stereo image of the guitar but I feel that having the microphones where they were narrowed the signal out. Typically I use this configuration in a situation where there is not an ample amount of time to set up a wide stereo configuration.
Phasing Issues? Stereo bar to the rescue!
Capturing an accurate stereo recording can be derailed by phasing issues easier than you would think. If a stereo microphone configuration has one microphone slightly closer to the sound source than the other then the recorded waveforms will begin to cancel themselves out. To alleviate this many engineers will use a stereo bar like the one shown in examples 7 and 8.
8. Room
This configuration is typically used in conjunction with some closer microphones. In listening to this example you can get an idea of how thin the signal can become the farther away it is. Also, general room ambience becomes far more noticeable when using a set of room microphones. Many engineers will always put up room microphones when the chance presents itself. Next time you have spare inputs try it out and you may or may not find it useful later in the mix.
9. Dual Dynamic
Using two dynamic microphones on an acoustic leads to some interesting choices for panning later in the techniques comes from placement used on guitar amps and bass amps. In those situations you can experiment with the tone of the speaker by angling one of the microphones off-axis so the microphone retains resonating frequencies that a flush microphone would not pick up. I feel that it is important to experiment with off-axis placements because after all we never have our ears flush against an instrument while we are listening to it. To some degree we are always listening in an off axis setting so why not try it out?
One microphones capsule is facing directly at the sound source while the other is underneath it at an angle facing the exact same area. This variation of axis allows you pan these two microphones moderately left and right in the mix. It will feel a bit uneasy if they are panned too hard, but it does make for a wider signal than just straight mono. I've used this technique with great results when engineering for groups where the guitar is more of a rhythmic instrument and plays short percussive chords instead of heavily strummed open chords. If you are in a situation where the vocalists wants to play and sing then you could use this to reduce the amount of vocal in the microphones while capturing a great performance on the vocal with a more detailed condenser microphone.
10. Single Dynamic
1. Blumlein Configuration
Blumlein requires the use of two Bi-Directional Microphones placed at a 90º angle. Bi-Directional microphones capture the signal in front of them and behind so the room ambience plays a significant factor in the sound. Most microphones have a setting that looks like a figure 8” and can be switched easily into this mode. As you can see by the above image it takes a bit of setup to get the capsules of the microphones as close to one another as possible without having them touch. The next step is getting the 90º angle to face the sound source.
In this case the microphones were moderately close to the acoustic guitar player and the 90º angle was pointing at the highest fret of the guitar which was just past the sound hole.
The outcome was a wide and clear signal that could accommodate most recordings for general acoustic guitar tracking. This worked well because the signal was within a small and somewhat quiet room. I found that the signal could be routed in stereo or mono and still work well in most mix situations.
2. One Large Diaphragm Condenser Close Mic
This placement used a single Large Diaphragm Condenser facing the area between the soundhole and the top of the fretboard. The microphone was switched into the Cardioid polar pattern setting to reduce any room ambience from behind the microphone. Cardioid focus the microphone to only retain signals from mostly in front of the microphone. This setting is much more narrow in comparison to a stereo configuration and would be perfect for double-tracking purposes where the player would strum two different performances of the same chord progression and pan them hard left and hard right. By nature the microphone is very sensitive and picks up much of the low end of the acoustic giving it a thick and chunky sound. This caveat makes it the perfect candidate for Acoustic Guitar driven music where the acoustic guitar upholds much of the harmony for track.
3. Spaced Pair
This configuration uses two Small Condenser Microphones set about 2.5ft away from one another. One is pointed towards the 8th fret of the acoustic guitar and the other is pointed directly at the12th fret just past where most of the strumming is happening. I set these closer to the player because the microphones retain fewer lower frequencies that the large diaphragm microphones. They also tend to register the high end of the frequency spectrum with more detail.
A substantial part of the placement is how far the microphones are placed from the source. Placing the microphones any further from the source would have resulted in a thin sound and any closer would have choked the sound.
I am a fan of this configuration because it captures the fret noise as well as the body of the guitar. You could use this for many applications especially if the acoustic guitarist has a lot of busy left handed hammer-ons and pull-offs. The microphone that points at the neck of the guitar is there to capture these small intricacies that are lost down by the sound hole.
4. Mid-Side
This technique is used by some and hated by others. The Mid-Side microphone placement requires the use of two microphones and three signals. First one must set up the microphones in the configuration shown in the example. The Large Diaphragm Condenser is set to Figure 8” or Bi-Directional” (same thing) and placed so that the capsule of the microphone is perpendicular to the sound source. The Small Condenser Microphone is placed above it directly facing the sound source. The Small Condenser is the Mid” and the Large
Condenser is the Side”.
Special Routing
When processing these tracks I was able to extract just the single Small Condenser microphone from the Mid-Side placement. If you review example two of this article you can hear how severely different the tone, body, and clarity of a LDC vs the SDC mono signals. The brightness of the Small Condenser microphone would be useful in a track with dense and complex instrumentation.
6. Vertical Spaced Pair
This is my favorite configuration out of all the ones listed in this article. In the above picture I have placed two SDC microphones in a vertical spaced pairing about seven inches apart.
The bottom microphone's capsule is pointed directly at the lower three strings of the acoustic and the top microphone is pointed at the top three strings. Angling them inward balances both the high and low end so that there aren't very many holes in the fidelity of the signal.
When panning these signals extreme left and right the stereo image is very interesting. Depending on strum direction you can almost feel the attack of the guitar pick on the high and low strings moving from left to right and right to left. This may not be every engineers ideal microphone placement but it does lend itself to some interesting mix options. I would experiment with this placement specifically on a singer/songwriter act that had only acoustic guitar and vocal. The quality of the recording is very intimate and would be fitting for that style. Most of those types of acts rely heavily on the acoustic guitar for a controlled low end, present midrange, clear shimmering high end, without taking away from the vocal.
7. XY
The XY configuration is a stereo option for many different applications. For this you must have the two microphones placed at 90º angle with the capsules as close to one another as possible without having them touch. The angle is then pointed towards the sound source. For this placement I pointed the angle towards the sound hole of the guitar. The idea was to get a somewhat wide stereo image of the guitar but I feel that having the microphones where they were narrowed the signal out. Typically I use this configuration in a situation where there is not an ample amount of time to set up a wide stereo configuration.
Phasing Issues? Stereo bar to the rescue!
Capturing an accurate stereo recording can be derailed by phasing issues easier than you would think. If a stereo microphone configuration has one microphone slightly closer to the sound source than the other then the recorded waveforms will begin to cancel themselves out. To alleviate this many engineers will use a stereo bar like the one shown in examples 7 and 8.
8. Room
This configuration is typically used in conjunction with some closer microphones. In listening to this example you can get an idea of how thin the signal can become the farther away it is. Also, general room ambience becomes far more noticeable when using a set of room microphones. Many engineers will always put up room microphones when the chance presents itself. Next time you have spare inputs try it out and you may or may not find it useful later in the mix.
9. Dual Dynamic
Using two dynamic microphones on an acoustic leads to some interesting choices for panning later in the techniques comes from placement used on guitar amps and bass amps. In those situations you can experiment with the tone of the speaker by angling one of the microphones off-axis so the microphone retains resonating frequencies that a flush microphone would not pick up. I feel that it is important to experiment with off-axis placements because after all we never have our ears flush against an instrument while we are listening to it. To some degree we are always listening in an off axis setting so why not try it out?
One microphones capsule is facing directly at the sound source while the other is underneath it at an angle facing the exact same area. This variation of axis allows you pan these two microphones moderately left and right in the mix. It will feel a bit uneasy if they are panned too hard, but it does make for a wider signal than just straight mono. I've used this technique with great results when engineering for groups where the guitar is more of a rhythmic instrument and plays short percussive chords instead of heavily strummed open chords. If you are in a situation where the vocalists wants to play and sing then you could use this to reduce the amount of vocal in the microphones while capturing a great performance on the vocal with a more detailed condenser microphone.
10. Single Dynamic
Thursday, 18 August 2016
Microphone Techniques
© 2008 Dave Luepke, Carrollton, TX
The purpose of this paper is to provide information, in a straightforward manner, to people who want to gain a better understanding of microphone placement for recording music, whether instrumental or vocal, in an effort to make better recordings. This paper focuses on stereo recording techniques, and will not address surround sound recording.
There are thousands of people making recordings who have never gotten any basic information about microphone placement techniques, and so they simply set up a couple mics in what they think is a good place. Often, the recordings have too much or too little bass, poor or exaggerated left/right stereo imaging, or poor depth (front/back) balance among various sections of the instruments or voices, or too much or too little room "ambience". But to those folks, I say, take heart!, you're not alone! Many commercially released recordings from major labels have obvious deficiencies as well. Classical music listeners have no doubt heard orchestral recordings where the violins sound "on mic" and the brass or percussion sounds like they're at the other end of the concert hall. Hopefully, the following information will help to reduce such deficiencies, and improve your recording quality.
For music recording which is intended for stereo playback, a variety of microphone placement techniques have become well-established over many decades. Among them are A/B, Decca tree, MS, ORTF, X-Y, close miking, and others. Each of these techniques have proven to possess certain useful and desirable characteristics in various situations. Each of them also possess characteristics which are undesirable in certain situations. A knowledge of these characteristics will help a person to make better recordings.
First, let's go over some basics of how we hear. Our two ears and the head which is between them is more than just a nice-looking way to design a human. It's fundamental to how we determine the direction from which a sound is coming, in other words: to locate a sound source. This ability is called "localization". Two fundamental and dominant abilities allow this to happen: the difference in a sound's "arrival time" at each ear, and the difference in sound level and quality at each ear. If a sound is produced directly in front, behind, above, or below a person (or anywhere else in that plane), there is no difference in arrival time or level between the two ears. In these cases, our brain is able to use other information to determine the source direction - above, front, back and below all have their own unique characteristics, but, in general, they are more subtle than the lateral differences. As a result, our localization ability is much more acute in the horizontal plane than in the vertical plane.
For sounds which come from some "off-axis" direction (i.e., left or right), it arrives at one ear before the other (arrival time difference), and, because the head acts as a barrier, there is also a level difference (which varies with frequency) between the two ears. Our brain processes these differences and determines the direction of the sound source. An everyday example of this is when somebody somewhere in a room talks to us, we are able to determine in what direction that person is.
On the other hand, our ability to process arrival time and level differences becomes seriously degraded at low frequencies. This is why, in stereo systems, it is sometimes acceptable to have only one sub-woofer rather than two. For very low tones (lower than about 70 Hz), we have a hard time knowing where the sound is coming from.
Intimately related to the level difference phenomenon is the fact that that difference becomes more significant as the frequency of the tone is raised. In other words, higher frequency tones will experience a greater loss of level as they diffract around the head and to the ear on the other side, than lower frequency tones.
The key point here is that differences in "arrival time" and sound "level" account for the majority of our sound localization ability.
However, the shape of the ear also plays an important role. Because the ear is not symmetrical, sound which arrives from different directions is passed to the middle and inner ear with different "transfer" characteristics. In the course of reflecting off the various curves and shapes of the outer ear (the pinna), some frequencies are accentuated and some are attenuated. Thus, each source direction has its own unique "signature" by the time it reaches the eardrum. Our brain is very familiar with these differences, and uses them to help determine the direction of the sound. This, along with head/neck/body shape, is the main clue which helps us to determine source direction for above/front/behind/below sound sources.
We can also determine if a sound source is close to us, or farther away. In a nutshell, this is dependent on two main factors: the overtone structure of the sound, and the relative amounts of "direct" sound and "reflected" (or "reverberant") sound. Reflected sound is sound which has impinged upon a surface and reflects toward the listener. For example, when a person is standing near you and talking, you can hear more detail in their voice than if they are some distance away, and the direct sound from their mouth significantly dominates over the sound reflected from the rooms surfaces. This is why, especially in a very "live" room or very noisy room, it's easier to understand a person that is close to you than one which is far away the farther away, the more significant is the reflected, or "reverberant" sound, causing "smearing" of the details and a loss of clarity.
You may ask: What does all of this have to do with stereo recording techniques? First, in order to make a high quality stereo recording, a person needs an understanding of how we hear and and how we determine where a sound originates and how far away it is. Secondly, and this is where it really hits home: with a stereo system, both ears hear both speakers (two sources), and those speakers are a fixed distance from the listener, with a fixed spacing between the speakers.
Two goals of producing good stereo recordings are to convince our brains that various musical instruments or voices are located across a space from one speaker to the other and places in between, and to make them sound closer or farther away than the speakers really are. A big part of the recording engineers ability to make that happen depends on his understanding of human hearing, and then to apply it when deciding on microphone placement.
The size and acoustics of the room and the ensemble also play an important role in deciding what mic technique and placement is best, but that's a topic for a little farther down the road. Before that, let's look at some well-established techniques. Later, Ill give some examples of why one technique may work better than another in a particular situation.
ORTF. (See photo.) This technique was developed by the French government broadcasting organization, "Office de Radiodiffusion Television Francaise", which accounts for the acronym name. The technique consists of using a pair of directional microphones with their capsules (the business end of the mic) placed anywhere from about 8 inches to as much as 15 inches apart and angled away from each other by anywhere from about 45 degrees to as much as 180 degrees. Note that the specifics of the technique were developed in concert with the standardization of microphones used by ORTF, and that the use of other microphones, along with various ensemble and room sizes, accounts for the wide latitude of placement and angle in common usage. Variations in specific microphone choice, spacing and angle aside, the concept is generally referred to as ORTF.
This technique delivers both of the primary aspects of directional localization: Level differences due to the angled orientation, (the mic which is aimed more toward a source will pick up that source louder than the one which is aimed more away from it); and time differences due to the distance between the two microphone capsules. By changing the distance between the capsules, and the angle between them, a skilled engineer has a great deal of control over the resulting stereo image.
The pickup pattern (cardioid, hypercardioid, etc.) of the specific microphones used, along with the angle between them, will determine how subtle or obvious the level differences will be, and will also play a role in the relative quality and quantity of ambient sound picked up. It should be noted that a microphone's pickup pattern varies with frequency, and different microphones have different characteristics in this regard. So, for example, not all cardioid microphones have the same pickup pattern characteristics. This has a definite and important effect on the quality of "off-axis" sound.
X-Y. (See photo.) This consists of a pair of directional microphones, one placed immediately above the other, with their capsules aligned horizontally and angled anywhere from 45 to as much as 150 degrees to each other, depending on the specific mics and the situation. In other words, two mics are positioned at essentially the same place, but one is pointed more to the left and the other is pointed more to the right. This is also often referred to as a "coincident" mic technique.
Because the capsules are as close to being in the same place as is practical, there is no difference in the time that a sound reaches one or the other. As a result, this technique relies solely on level differences resulting from the fact that the mics are aimed in different directions.
A potential shortcoming of this technique is that there is no "uncorrelated" sound recorded. ("Uncorrelated sound", in this context, is sound which arrives at one microphone at a different time, and with a different pattern of reverberant sound, as compared to the other microphone.) So, because both mics are picking up the same sound, just at different levels, the impression of "spaciousness" can be noticeably lacking (as a result of the lack of uncorrelated sound). However, that can often be remedied by adding a little artificial stereo reverberation during editing.
A/B. This technique generally uses two omnidirectional mics, although directional mics can be used. They are spaced anywhere from about 2 feet to several yards apart and are usually oriented parallel to each other, although they may be angled outward. This technique is often referred to as "spaced omnis". The technique often provides a very "spacious" sounding recording, and, because omni's are often used, low frequency (bass) quality is often better than with directional microphones. A potential downside is placing the mics too far apart, resulting in an "echo" effect between the two playback speakers, although this is rare except for very large spacing (greater than several yards, or in certain rooms with side wall reflection issues).
Because omnidirectional mics are generally used for this technique, most of the directional information is created by arrival time differences (which are significant when the mics are spaced several yards apart). Also, when using omni's, although one mic is closer to some sound sources than the other mic, sound level differences don't play a major role in the directional information, because even with a large distance between them, it is often not enough to result in more than a few dB difference in level between them. As a result, the impression of "spaciousness" can be quite noticeable, but source localization is often indistinct.
M/S (Mid/Side). This is actually a combination of mic placement and electronic signal processing. A bi-directional mic is placed so that it faces directly to the left and the right, and a directional mic (e.g., a cardioid) is placed immediately above or below it, pointed straight forward. This technique has the advantage of allowing the mixing engineer to vary the amount of "blend" between the two mics in a manner which provides more or less ambient sound, along with a broader or narrower stereo image. In effect, at mix time, the ratio between the direct sound from the source and the ambient sound from the room can be controlled.
Since it involves some basic signal processing, additional equipment is needed, along with a person who understands how to use it. Unless a purpose-built M/S mic is used (and there are several), it can also be an unsightly mic mounting for live performances. However, these factors should not deter a person from using the technique when it is warranted, because it can produce a very nice stereo image. It should be noted that, as with the X-Y technique, there is no uncorrelated sound, so the ambient quality (not quantity) can still be very lacking in spaciousness.
Summary of "stereo pair" techniques: Through placement and choice of microphones, the ORTF, X-Y, and A/B techniques all provide the opportunity to control the relative amounts of direct sound and reverberant sound, and to control the apparent horizontal spread and near/far placement of the ensemble in the stereo "stage". The M/S technique also provides this, but requires more equipment. Choosing the best technique and finding just the right place to put the mics is a combination of the science explained here, the ensemble being recorded, the sound qualities of the room, and experience. So, especially for live location recording, knowing something about the science is essential to getting off to a good start, but to become highly skilled at it, a person will need to gain experience by recording a wide variety of ensembles in a wide variety of venues, and objectively analyze and critique each recording in an effort to improve one's skill.
Close miking. This is just as the name implies: microphones placed close to the various sound sources, as a means of achieving some isolation of their sound from the sound of other sources in the ensemble, and from the ambient sound in the room. Whether it is a jazz quartet, or a 100 piece orchestra, close miking allows the engineer to have more control over the balance of the various instruments, and to create a stereo image which differs from the actual conditions in the recording venue. This can be advantageous when recording outdoors, or in a room which doesn't have the most desirable acoustics, or when a particular "sound stage" is desired for the reproduced sound.
However, it also requires many more mics and associated equipment, and more time to set up. For high quality results, it also requires the engineer to have a solid understanding of instrument sound radiation patterns, sound pressure levels, and the characteristics of the specific mics which are used. When doing the final mix, it will also require some artificial reverberation and EQ-ing, as well as a skilled mixing engineer, in order to achieve a believable audio balance and perspective.
There are other techniques, typically which are combinations of the ones noted above, but this overview will allow us to discuss the usage of each of these popular basic techniques.
In the next section of this paper, which I hope to finish soon, Ill take a few example scenarios and discuss the pros and cons of various techniques in those situations.
The purpose of this paper is to provide information, in a straightforward manner, to people who want to gain a better understanding of microphone placement for recording music, whether instrumental or vocal, in an effort to make better recordings. This paper focuses on stereo recording techniques, and will not address surround sound recording.
There are thousands of people making recordings who have never gotten any basic information about microphone placement techniques, and so they simply set up a couple mics in what they think is a good place. Often, the recordings have too much or too little bass, poor or exaggerated left/right stereo imaging, or poor depth (front/back) balance among various sections of the instruments or voices, or too much or too little room "ambience". But to those folks, I say, take heart!, you're not alone! Many commercially released recordings from major labels have obvious deficiencies as well. Classical music listeners have no doubt heard orchestral recordings where the violins sound "on mic" and the brass or percussion sounds like they're at the other end of the concert hall. Hopefully, the following information will help to reduce such deficiencies, and improve your recording quality.
For music recording which is intended for stereo playback, a variety of microphone placement techniques have become well-established over many decades. Among them are A/B, Decca tree, MS, ORTF, X-Y, close miking, and others. Each of these techniques have proven to possess certain useful and desirable characteristics in various situations. Each of them also possess characteristics which are undesirable in certain situations. A knowledge of these characteristics will help a person to make better recordings.
First, let's go over some basics of how we hear. Our two ears and the head which is between them is more than just a nice-looking way to design a human. It's fundamental to how we determine the direction from which a sound is coming, in other words: to locate a sound source. This ability is called "localization". Two fundamental and dominant abilities allow this to happen: the difference in a sound's "arrival time" at each ear, and the difference in sound level and quality at each ear. If a sound is produced directly in front, behind, above, or below a person (or anywhere else in that plane), there is no difference in arrival time or level between the two ears. In these cases, our brain is able to use other information to determine the source direction - above, front, back and below all have their own unique characteristics, but, in general, they are more subtle than the lateral differences. As a result, our localization ability is much more acute in the horizontal plane than in the vertical plane.
For sounds which come from some "off-axis" direction (i.e., left or right), it arrives at one ear before the other (arrival time difference), and, because the head acts as a barrier, there is also a level difference (which varies with frequency) between the two ears. Our brain processes these differences and determines the direction of the sound source. An everyday example of this is when somebody somewhere in a room talks to us, we are able to determine in what direction that person is.
On the other hand, our ability to process arrival time and level differences becomes seriously degraded at low frequencies. This is why, in stereo systems, it is sometimes acceptable to have only one sub-woofer rather than two. For very low tones (lower than about 70 Hz), we have a hard time knowing where the sound is coming from.
Intimately related to the level difference phenomenon is the fact that that difference becomes more significant as the frequency of the tone is raised. In other words, higher frequency tones will experience a greater loss of level as they diffract around the head and to the ear on the other side, than lower frequency tones.
The key point here is that differences in "arrival time" and sound "level" account for the majority of our sound localization ability.
However, the shape of the ear also plays an important role. Because the ear is not symmetrical, sound which arrives from different directions is passed to the middle and inner ear with different "transfer" characteristics. In the course of reflecting off the various curves and shapes of the outer ear (the pinna), some frequencies are accentuated and some are attenuated. Thus, each source direction has its own unique "signature" by the time it reaches the eardrum. Our brain is very familiar with these differences, and uses them to help determine the direction of the sound. This, along with head/neck/body shape, is the main clue which helps us to determine source direction for above/front/behind/below sound sources.
We can also determine if a sound source is close to us, or farther away. In a nutshell, this is dependent on two main factors: the overtone structure of the sound, and the relative amounts of "direct" sound and "reflected" (or "reverberant") sound. Reflected sound is sound which has impinged upon a surface and reflects toward the listener. For example, when a person is standing near you and talking, you can hear more detail in their voice than if they are some distance away, and the direct sound from their mouth significantly dominates over the sound reflected from the rooms surfaces. This is why, especially in a very "live" room or very noisy room, it's easier to understand a person that is close to you than one which is far away the farther away, the more significant is the reflected, or "reverberant" sound, causing "smearing" of the details and a loss of clarity.
You may ask: What does all of this have to do with stereo recording techniques? First, in order to make a high quality stereo recording, a person needs an understanding of how we hear and and how we determine where a sound originates and how far away it is. Secondly, and this is where it really hits home: with a stereo system, both ears hear both speakers (two sources), and those speakers are a fixed distance from the listener, with a fixed spacing between the speakers.
Two goals of producing good stereo recordings are to convince our brains that various musical instruments or voices are located across a space from one speaker to the other and places in between, and to make them sound closer or farther away than the speakers really are. A big part of the recording engineers ability to make that happen depends on his understanding of human hearing, and then to apply it when deciding on microphone placement.
The size and acoustics of the room and the ensemble also play an important role in deciding what mic technique and placement is best, but that's a topic for a little farther down the road. Before that, let's look at some well-established techniques. Later, Ill give some examples of why one technique may work better than another in a particular situation.
ORTF. (See photo.) This technique was developed by the French government broadcasting organization, "Office de Radiodiffusion Television Francaise", which accounts for the acronym name. The technique consists of using a pair of directional microphones with their capsules (the business end of the mic) placed anywhere from about 8 inches to as much as 15 inches apart and angled away from each other by anywhere from about 45 degrees to as much as 180 degrees. Note that the specifics of the technique were developed in concert with the standardization of microphones used by ORTF, and that the use of other microphones, along with various ensemble and room sizes, accounts for the wide latitude of placement and angle in common usage. Variations in specific microphone choice, spacing and angle aside, the concept is generally referred to as ORTF.
This technique delivers both of the primary aspects of directional localization: Level differences due to the angled orientation, (the mic which is aimed more toward a source will pick up that source louder than the one which is aimed more away from it); and time differences due to the distance between the two microphone capsules. By changing the distance between the capsules, and the angle between them, a skilled engineer has a great deal of control over the resulting stereo image.
The pickup pattern (cardioid, hypercardioid, etc.) of the specific microphones used, along with the angle between them, will determine how subtle or obvious the level differences will be, and will also play a role in the relative quality and quantity of ambient sound picked up. It should be noted that a microphone's pickup pattern varies with frequency, and different microphones have different characteristics in this regard. So, for example, not all cardioid microphones have the same pickup pattern characteristics. This has a definite and important effect on the quality of "off-axis" sound.
X-Y. (See photo.) This consists of a pair of directional microphones, one placed immediately above the other, with their capsules aligned horizontally and angled anywhere from 45 to as much as 150 degrees to each other, depending on the specific mics and the situation. In other words, two mics are positioned at essentially the same place, but one is pointed more to the left and the other is pointed more to the right. This is also often referred to as a "coincident" mic technique.
Because the capsules are as close to being in the same place as is practical, there is no difference in the time that a sound reaches one or the other. As a result, this technique relies solely on level differences resulting from the fact that the mics are aimed in different directions.
A potential shortcoming of this technique is that there is no "uncorrelated" sound recorded. ("Uncorrelated sound", in this context, is sound which arrives at one microphone at a different time, and with a different pattern of reverberant sound, as compared to the other microphone.) So, because both mics are picking up the same sound, just at different levels, the impression of "spaciousness" can be noticeably lacking (as a result of the lack of uncorrelated sound). However, that can often be remedied by adding a little artificial stereo reverberation during editing.
A/B. This technique generally uses two omnidirectional mics, although directional mics can be used. They are spaced anywhere from about 2 feet to several yards apart and are usually oriented parallel to each other, although they may be angled outward. This technique is often referred to as "spaced omnis". The technique often provides a very "spacious" sounding recording, and, because omni's are often used, low frequency (bass) quality is often better than with directional microphones. A potential downside is placing the mics too far apart, resulting in an "echo" effect between the two playback speakers, although this is rare except for very large spacing (greater than several yards, or in certain rooms with side wall reflection issues).
Because omnidirectional mics are generally used for this technique, most of the directional information is created by arrival time differences (which are significant when the mics are spaced several yards apart). Also, when using omni's, although one mic is closer to some sound sources than the other mic, sound level differences don't play a major role in the directional information, because even with a large distance between them, it is often not enough to result in more than a few dB difference in level between them. As a result, the impression of "spaciousness" can be quite noticeable, but source localization is often indistinct.
M/S (Mid/Side). This is actually a combination of mic placement and electronic signal processing. A bi-directional mic is placed so that it faces directly to the left and the right, and a directional mic (e.g., a cardioid) is placed immediately above or below it, pointed straight forward. This technique has the advantage of allowing the mixing engineer to vary the amount of "blend" between the two mics in a manner which provides more or less ambient sound, along with a broader or narrower stereo image. In effect, at mix time, the ratio between the direct sound from the source and the ambient sound from the room can be controlled.
Since it involves some basic signal processing, additional equipment is needed, along with a person who understands how to use it. Unless a purpose-built M/S mic is used (and there are several), it can also be an unsightly mic mounting for live performances. However, these factors should not deter a person from using the technique when it is warranted, because it can produce a very nice stereo image. It should be noted that, as with the X-Y technique, there is no uncorrelated sound, so the ambient quality (not quantity) can still be very lacking in spaciousness.
Summary of "stereo pair" techniques: Through placement and choice of microphones, the ORTF, X-Y, and A/B techniques all provide the opportunity to control the relative amounts of direct sound and reverberant sound, and to control the apparent horizontal spread and near/far placement of the ensemble in the stereo "stage". The M/S technique also provides this, but requires more equipment. Choosing the best technique and finding just the right place to put the mics is a combination of the science explained here, the ensemble being recorded, the sound qualities of the room, and experience. So, especially for live location recording, knowing something about the science is essential to getting off to a good start, but to become highly skilled at it, a person will need to gain experience by recording a wide variety of ensembles in a wide variety of venues, and objectively analyze and critique each recording in an effort to improve one's skill.
Close miking. This is just as the name implies: microphones placed close to the various sound sources, as a means of achieving some isolation of their sound from the sound of other sources in the ensemble, and from the ambient sound in the room. Whether it is a jazz quartet, or a 100 piece orchestra, close miking allows the engineer to have more control over the balance of the various instruments, and to create a stereo image which differs from the actual conditions in the recording venue. This can be advantageous when recording outdoors, or in a room which doesn't have the most desirable acoustics, or when a particular "sound stage" is desired for the reproduced sound.
However, it also requires many more mics and associated equipment, and more time to set up. For high quality results, it also requires the engineer to have a solid understanding of instrument sound radiation patterns, sound pressure levels, and the characteristics of the specific mics which are used. When doing the final mix, it will also require some artificial reverberation and EQ-ing, as well as a skilled mixing engineer, in order to achieve a believable audio balance and perspective.
There are other techniques, typically which are combinations of the ones noted above, but this overview will allow us to discuss the usage of each of these popular basic techniques.
In the next section of this paper, which I hope to finish soon, Ill take a few example scenarios and discuss the pros and cons of various techniques in those situations.
Tuesday, 16 August 2016
The 5 Useful Techniques
When you first learn about the power of microphone positioning, you're instantly fascinated.
Could a difference of an inch in positioning really make that much a difference in sound?
As you eventually come to find out…absolutely it does.
And once you discovered that, you start to wonder - what else have I been missing out on all this time?
Well, I'll tell you. It's called stereo recording. And it's the real secret professionals use to create that awesome sound that's had you baffled up until now.
What is it?
Stereo recording is a technique involving the use of two microphones to simultaneously record one instrument. The mono signals from each microphone are assigned to the left and right channels of a stereo track to create a sense of width in the recording.
The stereo effect is created in this technique from the slight difference in sound between the left and right channels of the monitors. This difference in sound is observed in the following two ways:
Difference in timing - By placing the microphones at different locations, the sound from the instrument will arrive at each microphone at a slightly different time. A difference of just a few milliseconds is enough to create a stereo effect.
Difference in frequency balance - By angling the microphone in different directions in relation to the instrument, each microphone will pick up a slightly different balance of frequencies. The greater the angle, the more exaggerated the stereo effect will be.
When one mic is heard through the left monitor, and the other mic through the right, it creates a pleasant sense of width that is absent in a mono recording.
So how do you do it?
The 5 Most Useful Techniques to Know
Here is a list of the 5 most useful stereo recording techniques you should know. For each one, I'll explain:
the type of mic required, (including the microphone polar pattern )
how to position them for recording
how to mix the two signals together
how it should sound once completed
Let's start off with the simplest and most common of the four techniques:
1. A/B Stereo Recording
Mics used: Two omnidirectional mics, usually small diaphragm condensers
Positioning: Point both mics toward the instrument, at a distance of a foot, and spaced two feet apart.
When experimenting with this technique, try making adjustments to both the distance of the mics from the instrument, as well as the distance of the mics from each other.
How to mix the signals: The mono signals from each microphone are assigned to the left and right channels of a stereo track to create a sense of width in the recording.
How it should sound: The stereo image is created because of the time of arrival at each microphone is slightly staggered. The frequency balance is different as well, which will provided an added level of stereo width.
The downside of A/B stereo recording is that because of the timing offset between each microphone, you will be likely to have issues with phase cancellation when combining the stereo signal to mono.
2. X/Y Stereo Recording
Mics used: Two directional mics, usually small diaphragm condensers
Positioning: at an angle between 90-135 degrees so that their capsules coincide at a single point. The wider the angle, the wider the stereo image.
How to Mix the Signals: (same as A/B stereo recording)
How it should sound: Compared to A/B stereo recording, this technique will have less of a stereo effect. The reason is that since both microphones are positioned at the same point in space, there will be no differences in timing.
The entire stereo effect will be created from the differences in frequency balance. The upside to this is there are no issues with mono phase cancellation either.
3. ORTF Stereo Recording
Mics used: Two directional mics, usually small diaphragm condensers
Positioning: Spread outward at an angle of about 110 degrees, with the capsules spaced 17cm apart.
How to mix the signals: (same as A/B stereo recording)
How it should sound: The technique is basically a combination of the previous two. The microphones are physical spaced apart, like with A/B recording, which will yield a wider stereo image. Then it uses directional mics, like with X/Y recording, so it should pick up less of the ambient room sound.
4. Blumlein Pair
Positioning: (same as X/Y technique)
How to mix the signals: (same as X/Y technique)
How it should sound: Compared to the X/Y technique, the Blumlein Pair technique captures a greater portion of the room sound and adds a bit more ambience to the stereo image, thanks to the use of the figure 8 mics.
5. Mid/Side Stereo Recording
Mics used: One small diaphragm condenser mic - either cardioid OR omnidirectional.
One large diaphragm condenser mic - MUST BE FIGURE 8
Positioning: The figure 8 mic is placed sideways at a 90 degree angle from instrument. This mic will record sound on both sides and will function as the side” in the term mid/side.
The other mic is positioned on top or below the figure 8 mic, and is pointed directly toward the instrument. It will function as the mid” in the term mid/side.
How to mix the signals: This part is complicated. Follow the steps carefully.
Duplicate the side” channel
Combine the two side channels onto one stereo track
Mix in the mid channel with stereo side channels to adjust the width. The greater level of the sides compared to the mid, the greater the stereo width.
How it should sound: Mid side recording may be complicated, but it offers all the advantages of the other 3 techniques, without the downsides.
It offers the added stereo width of the A/B technique
It offers the mono compatibility of the X/Y technique
And it allows you (if you want) to increase the room ambiance to something resembling the Blumlein Pair technique.
When Mono is More Appropriate than Stereo
While stereo recording applied in the right situations can improve the quality and interest of your mixes by leaps and bounds, there are some situations when it is simply not appropriate. Certain instruments that you record will sound better in mono almost 100 percent of the time.
And here are the most common 4:
Lead Vocals - The lead vocal is simply expected to be located at center stage. For that reason, it is typically recorded in mono.
Snare Drum - The snare drum is also expected to be at center stage. It would sound quite odd if it was located off to one side of the stereo image.
Kick Drum - A kick drum should be recorded in mono because its heavy low frequency content requires a lot of power to reproduce on speakers. In order to get the maximum output from the mix, it's best that the work be shared equally by both the left and right channels.
Bass - The bass guitar is also made up mainly of low frequencies so it generally works better in mono as well. Another reason for this rule is that our ears are not good at obtaining directional information from low frequencies, so it makes little sense to create a stereo image for any low frequency instrument.
Could a difference of an inch in positioning really make that much a difference in sound?
As you eventually come to find out…absolutely it does.
And once you discovered that, you start to wonder - what else have I been missing out on all this time?
Well, I'll tell you. It's called stereo recording. And it's the real secret professionals use to create that awesome sound that's had you baffled up until now.
What is it?
Stereo recording is a technique involving the use of two microphones to simultaneously record one instrument. The mono signals from each microphone are assigned to the left and right channels of a stereo track to create a sense of width in the recording.
The stereo effect is created in this technique from the slight difference in sound between the left and right channels of the monitors. This difference in sound is observed in the following two ways:
Difference in timing - By placing the microphones at different locations, the sound from the instrument will arrive at each microphone at a slightly different time. A difference of just a few milliseconds is enough to create a stereo effect.
Difference in frequency balance - By angling the microphone in different directions in relation to the instrument, each microphone will pick up a slightly different balance of frequencies. The greater the angle, the more exaggerated the stereo effect will be.
When one mic is heard through the left monitor, and the other mic through the right, it creates a pleasant sense of width that is absent in a mono recording.
So how do you do it?
The 5 Most Useful Techniques to Know
Here is a list of the 5 most useful stereo recording techniques you should know. For each one, I'll explain:
the type of mic required, (including the microphone polar pattern )
how to position them for recording
how to mix the two signals together
how it should sound once completed
Let's start off with the simplest and most common of the four techniques:
1. A/B Stereo Recording
Mics used: Two omnidirectional mics, usually small diaphragm condensers
Positioning: Point both mics toward the instrument, at a distance of a foot, and spaced two feet apart.
When experimenting with this technique, try making adjustments to both the distance of the mics from the instrument, as well as the distance of the mics from each other.
How to mix the signals: The mono signals from each microphone are assigned to the left and right channels of a stereo track to create a sense of width in the recording.
How it should sound: The stereo image is created because of the time of arrival at each microphone is slightly staggered. The frequency balance is different as well, which will provided an added level of stereo width.
The downside of A/B stereo recording is that because of the timing offset between each microphone, you will be likely to have issues with phase cancellation when combining the stereo signal to mono.
2. X/Y Stereo Recording
Mics used: Two directional mics, usually small diaphragm condensers
Positioning: at an angle between 90-135 degrees so that their capsules coincide at a single point. The wider the angle, the wider the stereo image.
How to Mix the Signals: (same as A/B stereo recording)
How it should sound: Compared to A/B stereo recording, this technique will have less of a stereo effect. The reason is that since both microphones are positioned at the same point in space, there will be no differences in timing.
The entire stereo effect will be created from the differences in frequency balance. The upside to this is there are no issues with mono phase cancellation either.
3. ORTF Stereo Recording
Mics used: Two directional mics, usually small diaphragm condensers
Positioning: Spread outward at an angle of about 110 degrees, with the capsules spaced 17cm apart.
How to mix the signals: (same as A/B stereo recording)
How it should sound: The technique is basically a combination of the previous two. The microphones are physical spaced apart, like with A/B recording, which will yield a wider stereo image. Then it uses directional mics, like with X/Y recording, so it should pick up less of the ambient room sound.
4. Blumlein Pair
Positioning: (same as X/Y technique)
How to mix the signals: (same as X/Y technique)
How it should sound: Compared to the X/Y technique, the Blumlein Pair technique captures a greater portion of the room sound and adds a bit more ambience to the stereo image, thanks to the use of the figure 8 mics.
5. Mid/Side Stereo Recording
Mics used: One small diaphragm condenser mic - either cardioid OR omnidirectional.
One large diaphragm condenser mic - MUST BE FIGURE 8
Positioning: The figure 8 mic is placed sideways at a 90 degree angle from instrument. This mic will record sound on both sides and will function as the side” in the term mid/side.
The other mic is positioned on top or below the figure 8 mic, and is pointed directly toward the instrument. It will function as the mid” in the term mid/side.
How to mix the signals: This part is complicated. Follow the steps carefully.
Duplicate the side” channel
Combine the two side channels onto one stereo track
Mix in the mid channel with stereo side channels to adjust the width. The greater level of the sides compared to the mid, the greater the stereo width.
How it should sound: Mid side recording may be complicated, but it offers all the advantages of the other 3 techniques, without the downsides.
It offers the added stereo width of the A/B technique
It offers the mono compatibility of the X/Y technique
And it allows you (if you want) to increase the room ambiance to something resembling the Blumlein Pair technique.
When Mono is More Appropriate than Stereo
While stereo recording applied in the right situations can improve the quality and interest of your mixes by leaps and bounds, there are some situations when it is simply not appropriate. Certain instruments that you record will sound better in mono almost 100 percent of the time.
And here are the most common 4:
Lead Vocals - The lead vocal is simply expected to be located at center stage. For that reason, it is typically recorded in mono.
Snare Drum - The snare drum is also expected to be at center stage. It would sound quite odd if it was located off to one side of the stereo image.
Kick Drum - A kick drum should be recorded in mono because its heavy low frequency content requires a lot of power to reproduce on speakers. In order to get the maximum output from the mix, it's best that the work be shared equally by both the left and right channels.
Bass - The bass guitar is also made up mainly of low frequencies so it generally works better in mono as well. Another reason for this rule is that our ears are not good at obtaining directional information from low frequencies, so it makes little sense to create a stereo image for any low frequency instrument.
Thursday, 28 July 2016
6 Stereo Miking Techniques You Can Use Today
Twice a month we revisit some of our reader favorite posts from throughout the history of Audiotuts+. This tutorial was first published in August 2008.
Stereo miking is a great way to increase the sense of depth in your recording of an instrument. Here are six stereo miking techniques you can try out today. We'll start with the basics and then move to some more exciting options.
Before You Get Started
One thing to be careful of in stereo recording is phase cancellation. When using a spaced pair this can be a concern. Phase cancellation occurs when two versions of the same sound, which occur at slightly different times, are mixed together. The result is that when one signal is going into positive amplitude and the other is going into negative amplitude they will cancel each other out and when they are both going the same way they will boost each other.
When two signals are out of phase you will notice a warble in your sound or, if the two signals are 180 degrees out of phase, you will get silence. You will not notice this when the two signals are panned hard left and right. So, to avoid any surprises always check in mono.
The way to minimize your chance of running into phase problems is to use coincident pairs (where the two mics are very close together) or to use the 3:1 rule (place the mics 3 times as far from each other as they are from the sound source).
Spaced Pair
Spaced pair miking is exactly what the name implies. Two cardioid microphones are placed apart from each other to produce two different recordings of the same instrument. I suggest trying two places on the instrument that produce different tonalities. For example, on a guitar you may want to have one mic on the bridge and one on the nut.
X-Y
The X-Y configuration takes two cardioid microphones and places them with heads together at 90 degree angles. The result is that the mic on the left will pickup the right side of the room and the mic on the right will pickup the left side of the room.
Blumlein Pair
The Blumlein Pair is much like the X-Y technique with one variation. Two bi-directional mics are used at 90 degree angles. The result of this technique is that one mic will pickup the front left and back right of the room while the other picks up the front right and back left of the room. This technique is best if you have a nice sounding room to record in.
ORTF
The ORTF technique is named after the French television and radio commission who invented it (Office de Radiodiffusion-Télévision Française). This is a binaural mic technique which means it is meant to approximate the response of your two ears. In the ORTF technique two cardioid mics are placed at an angle of 110 degrees with the heads 17cm (7”) apart. The beauty of this technique is that mic placement can be as simple as moving around the room until it sounds good and then placing the mics where your head was.
Mid-side
In this technique a cardioid mic is placed facing the sound source and a bi-directional mic is placed perpendicular to the cardioid mic (so it is picking up the sides of the room). They are each recorded onto one track. The track with the bidirectional microphone is then copied and the phase is inverted on the copy. The two bi-directional tracks are then panned hard left and right while the cardioid mic is panned center. By adjusting the relative volume of the cardioid mic we can control how close or far away the recorded instrument sounds.
Note: This technique only works in stereo. If this is played back in mono the two bi-directional tracks will cancel each other out.
Decca Tree
The Decca Tree is used mainly for recording orchestras and large ensembles. It was developed in the 1950s by engineers at Decca Records. The Decca Tree uses a special T-shaped mic stand suspended above the conductor's head. On the T-shaped stand are 3 cardioid microphones facing left, right and centre which are then panned to match their configuration.
There are no fixed measurements for the distance between the microphones but the standard seems to be around 5-7 feet. The mics are usually placed closer together for smaller orchestras and further apart for larger ones.
Stereo miking is a great way to increase the sense of depth in your recording of an instrument. Here are six stereo miking techniques you can try out today. We'll start with the basics and then move to some more exciting options.
Before You Get Started
One thing to be careful of in stereo recording is phase cancellation. When using a spaced pair this can be a concern. Phase cancellation occurs when two versions of the same sound, which occur at slightly different times, are mixed together. The result is that when one signal is going into positive amplitude and the other is going into negative amplitude they will cancel each other out and when they are both going the same way they will boost each other.
When two signals are out of phase you will notice a warble in your sound or, if the two signals are 180 degrees out of phase, you will get silence. You will not notice this when the two signals are panned hard left and right. So, to avoid any surprises always check in mono.
The way to minimize your chance of running into phase problems is to use coincident pairs (where the two mics are very close together) or to use the 3:1 rule (place the mics 3 times as far from each other as they are from the sound source).
Spaced Pair
Spaced pair miking is exactly what the name implies. Two cardioid microphones are placed apart from each other to produce two different recordings of the same instrument. I suggest trying two places on the instrument that produce different tonalities. For example, on a guitar you may want to have one mic on the bridge and one on the nut.
X-Y
The X-Y configuration takes two cardioid microphones and places them with heads together at 90 degree angles. The result is that the mic on the left will pickup the right side of the room and the mic on the right will pickup the left side of the room.
Blumlein Pair
The Blumlein Pair is much like the X-Y technique with one variation. Two bi-directional mics are used at 90 degree angles. The result of this technique is that one mic will pickup the front left and back right of the room while the other picks up the front right and back left of the room. This technique is best if you have a nice sounding room to record in.
ORTF
The ORTF technique is named after the French television and radio commission who invented it (Office de Radiodiffusion-Télévision Française). This is a binaural mic technique which means it is meant to approximate the response of your two ears. In the ORTF technique two cardioid mics are placed at an angle of 110 degrees with the heads 17cm (7”) apart. The beauty of this technique is that mic placement can be as simple as moving around the room until it sounds good and then placing the mics where your head was.
Mid-side
In this technique a cardioid mic is placed facing the sound source and a bi-directional mic is placed perpendicular to the cardioid mic (so it is picking up the sides of the room). They are each recorded onto one track. The track with the bidirectional microphone is then copied and the phase is inverted on the copy. The two bi-directional tracks are then panned hard left and right while the cardioid mic is panned center. By adjusting the relative volume of the cardioid mic we can control how close or far away the recorded instrument sounds.
Note: This technique only works in stereo. If this is played back in mono the two bi-directional tracks will cancel each other out.
Decca Tree
The Decca Tree is used mainly for recording orchestras and large ensembles. It was developed in the 1950s by engineers at Decca Records. The Decca Tree uses a special T-shaped mic stand suspended above the conductor's head. On the T-shaped stand are 3 cardioid microphones facing left, right and centre which are then panned to match their configuration.
There are no fixed measurements for the distance between the microphones but the standard seems to be around 5-7 feet. The mics are usually placed closer together for smaller orchestras and further apart for larger ones.
Thursday, 21 July 2016
Microphone Practice
There exist a number of well-developed microphone techniques used for miking musical, film, or voice sources. Choice of technique depends on a number of factors, including:
The collection of extraneous noise. This can be a concern, especially in amplified performances, where audio feedback can be a significant problem. Alternatively, it can be a desired outcome, in situations where ambient noise is useful (hall reverberation, audience reaction).
Choice of a signal type: Mono , stereo or multi-channel.
Type of sound-source: Acoustic instruments produce a sound very different from electric instruments, which are again different from the human voice.
Situational circumstances: Sometimes a microphone should not be visible, or having a microphone nearby is not appropriate. In scenes for a movie the microphone may be held above the pictureframe, just out of sight. In this way there is always a certain distance between the actor and the microphone.
Processing: If the signal is destined to be heavily processed, or "mixed down", a different type of input may be required.
The use of a windshield as well as a pop shield , designed to reduce vocal plosives.
There are several classes of microphone placement for recording and amplification.
In close miking, a microphone is placed relatively close to an instrument or sound source, within three to twelve inches, producing a dry or non-reverberant sound. 1 This serves to reduce extraneous noise, including room reverberation, and is commonly used when attempting to record a number of separate instruments while keeping the signals separate, or when trying to avoid feedback in an amplified performance. Close miking often affects the frequency response of the microphone, especially for directional mics which exhibit bass boost from the proximity effect Ubiquitous in the tracking of instruments used in pop and popular music , examples of close-mic vocal tracks include many songs on Elliott Smith 's Elliott Smith and Either/Or , Lily Allen 's " The Fear ", the chorus of Fergie 's " Glamorous ", Imogen Heap 's lead on " Hide and Seek ", and Madonna 's spoken verses on " Erotica ". 2
In ambient or distant miking, a microphone — typically a sensitive one — is placed at some distance from the sound source. The goal of this technique is to get a broader, natural mix of the sound source or sources, along with ambient sound, including reverberation from the room or hall. Example include The Jesus and Mary Chain 's Psychocandy (excepting the vocals), Robert Plant 's vocals on songs from Physical Graffiti , Tom Waits 's lead vocals on his "junkyard" records, and Mick Jagger 's lead-vocals on songs from Exile On Main Street 3
In room miking a distant mic, referred to as the room mic, is used in conjunction with a close mic, "typically placed far enough past the critical distance in a room that the room's ambience and reverberations transduce at an equivalent, if not greater, volume than the sound source itself." 4 Ubiquitous in pop, it is the industry standard for tracking rhythm guitars in rock. A "celebrated" example is the rhythm guitar on Led Zeppelin 's " Communication Breakdown " 4 while other examples include John Frusciante 's electric guitar parts on BloodSugarSexMagik , Noel Gallagher 's lead-guitar on " Champagne Supernova ", and Billy Corgan 's guitar on " Cherub Rock ", " Today ", " Bullet With Butterfly Wings ", " Zero ", and " Fuck You (An Ode To No One) ". 5
Accent (or Spot) Microphone Placement. Often, the tonal and ambient qualities will sound very different between a distant- and close-miked pickup. Under certain circumstances, it's difficult to obtain a naturally recorded balance when mixing the two together. For example, if a solo instrument within an orchestra needs an extra mic for added volume and presence, placing the mic too close would result in a pickup that sounds overly present, unnatural and out of context with the distant, overall orchestral pickup. To avoid this pitfall, a compromise in distance should be struck. A microphone that has been placed within a reasonably close range to an instrument or section within a larger ensemble (but not so close as to have an unnatural sound) is known as an accent (or spot) pickup Whenever accent miking is used, care should be exercised in placement and pickup choices. The amount of accent signal that's introduced into the mix should sound natural relative to the overall pickup, and a good accent mic should only add presence to a solo passage and not stick out as separate, identifiable pickup. 6 7 8
Often each instrument or vocalist is miked separately, with one or more microphones recording to separate channels (tracks). At a later stage, the channels are combined ('mixed-down') to two channels for stereo or more for surround sound The artists need not perform in the same place at the same time, and individual tracks (or sections of tracks) can be re-recorded to correct errors. Generally effects such as reverberation are added to each recorded channel, and different levels sent to left and right final channels to position the artist in the stereo sound-stage. Microphones may also be used to record the overall effect, or just the effect of the performance room.
This permits greater control over the final sound, but recording two channels (stereo recording) is simpler and cheaper, and can give a sound that is more natural.
There are two features of sound that the human brain uses to place objects in the stereo sound-field between the loudspeakers. These are the relative level (or loudness) difference between the two channels Δ L, and the time delay difference in arrival times for the same sound in each channel Δ t. The "interaural" signals (binaural ILD and ITD) at the ears are not the stereo microphone signals which are coming from the loudspeakers, and are called "interchannel" signals (Δ L and Δ t). These signals are normally not mixed. Loudspeaker signals are different from the sound arriving at the ear. See the article " Binaural recording for earphones ".
Various methods of stereo recording edit
X-Y technique: intensity stereophony edit
XY Stereo
Here there are two directional microphones at the same place, and typically placed at 90° or more to each other. 9 A stereo effect is achieved through differences in sound pressure level between two microphones. Due to the lack of differences in time-of-arrival and phase ambiguities, the sonic characteristic of X-Y recordings is generally less "spacey" and has less depth compared to recordings employing an AB setup.
Blumlein Stereo
When the microphones are bidirectional and placed facing +-45° with respect to the sound source, the X-Y-setup is called a Blumlein Pair The sonic image produced by this configuration is considered by many authorities to create a realistic, almost holographic soundstage.
A further refinement of the Blumlein Pair was developed by EMI in 1958, who called it "Stereosonic". They added a little in-phase crosstalk above 700 Hz to better align the mid and treble phantom sources with the bass ones. 10
A-B technique: time-of-arrival stereophony edit
This technique uses two parallel microphones, typically omnidirectional, some distance apart, capturing time-of-arrival stereo information as well as some level (amplitude) difference information, especially if employed close to the sound source(s). At a distance of about 50 cm (0.5 m) the time delay for a signal reaching first one and then the other microphone from the side is approximately 1.5 ms (1 to 2 ms). If the distance is increased between the microphones it effectively decreases the pickup angle. At 70 cm distance it is about equivalent to the pickup angle of the near-coincident ORTF setup.
M/S technique: Mid/Side stereophony edit
Mid-Side Stereo
This coincident technique employs a bidirectional microphone (with a Figure of 8 polar pattern) facing sideways and a cardioid (generally a variety of cardioid, although Alan Blumlein described the usage of an omnidirectional transducer in his original patent) facing the sound source. The capsules are stacked vertically and brought together as closely as possible, to minimize comb filtering caused by differences in arrival time.
The left and right channels are produced through a simple matrix: Left = Mid + Side, Right = Mid − Side ("minus" means you add the side signal with the polarity reversed). This configuration produces a completely mono-compatible signal and, if the Mid and Side signals are recorded (rather than the matrixed Left and Right), the stereo width (and with that, the perceived distance of the sound source) can be manipulated after the recording has taken place.
Jecklin Disk technique edit
The Jecklin Disk technique is similar to A/B recording, with 2 omni-directional microphones at 36 cm apart from each other. A sound absorbing Jecklin disk of 35cm is placed in the middle between the two microphones. The disk makes the apparent separation between the mics much larger than an equivalent A/B recording.
Choosing a technique edit
If a stereo signal is to be reproduced in mono, out-of-phase parts of the signal will cancel, which may cause the unwanted reduction or loss of some parts of the signal. This can be an important factor in choosing which technique to use.
Since the A-B techniques use phase differences to give the stereo image, they are the least compatible with mono.
Jecklin disk has a relatively small distance between the mics. Frequencies coming in sideways can reach only one microphone and will not interfere. Therefore Jecklin disk works reasonably well when converted to mono. Jecklin disk also gives phase shifts and amplitude differences matching good with what a real pair of ears would hear at this position and therefore is well suited for headphone playback.
In the X-Y techniques, the microphones would ideally be in exactly the same place, which is not possible - if they are slightly separated left to right, there may be some loss of high frequencies when played back in mono, so they are often separated vertically. This only causes problems with sound from above or below the height of the microphones.
The M/S technique is ideal for mono compatibility, since summing Left+Right just gives the Mid signal back.
The equipment for the techniques also varies from the bulky to the small and convenient. A-B techniques generally use two separate microphone units, often mounted on a bar to define the separation. X-Y microphone capsules can be mounted in one unit, or even on the top of a handheld digital recorder.
M/S arrays can be very compact and fit easily into a standard blimp windscreen, which makes boom-operated stereo recordings possible. They provide a variable soundstage width to match a zoom lens , which can be manipulated in post-production. This makes M/S is a very popular stereo technique for film location recording. They are often used in small 'pencil microphones' to mount on video cameras, sometimes even coupled to the zoom.
The collection of extraneous noise. This can be a concern, especially in amplified performances, where audio feedback can be a significant problem. Alternatively, it can be a desired outcome, in situations where ambient noise is useful (hall reverberation, audience reaction).
Choice of a signal type: Mono , stereo or multi-channel.
Type of sound-source: Acoustic instruments produce a sound very different from electric instruments, which are again different from the human voice.
Situational circumstances: Sometimes a microphone should not be visible, or having a microphone nearby is not appropriate. In scenes for a movie the microphone may be held above the pictureframe, just out of sight. In this way there is always a certain distance between the actor and the microphone.
Processing: If the signal is destined to be heavily processed, or "mixed down", a different type of input may be required.
The use of a windshield as well as a pop shield , designed to reduce vocal plosives.
There are several classes of microphone placement for recording and amplification.
In close miking, a microphone is placed relatively close to an instrument or sound source, within three to twelve inches, producing a dry or non-reverberant sound. 1 This serves to reduce extraneous noise, including room reverberation, and is commonly used when attempting to record a number of separate instruments while keeping the signals separate, or when trying to avoid feedback in an amplified performance. Close miking often affects the frequency response of the microphone, especially for directional mics which exhibit bass boost from the proximity effect Ubiquitous in the tracking of instruments used in pop and popular music , examples of close-mic vocal tracks include many songs on Elliott Smith 's Elliott Smith and Either/Or , Lily Allen 's " The Fear ", the chorus of Fergie 's " Glamorous ", Imogen Heap 's lead on " Hide and Seek ", and Madonna 's spoken verses on " Erotica ". 2
In ambient or distant miking, a microphone — typically a sensitive one — is placed at some distance from the sound source. The goal of this technique is to get a broader, natural mix of the sound source or sources, along with ambient sound, including reverberation from the room or hall. Example include The Jesus and Mary Chain 's Psychocandy (excepting the vocals), Robert Plant 's vocals on songs from Physical Graffiti , Tom Waits 's lead vocals on his "junkyard" records, and Mick Jagger 's lead-vocals on songs from Exile On Main Street 3
In room miking a distant mic, referred to as the room mic, is used in conjunction with a close mic, "typically placed far enough past the critical distance in a room that the room's ambience and reverberations transduce at an equivalent, if not greater, volume than the sound source itself." 4 Ubiquitous in pop, it is the industry standard for tracking rhythm guitars in rock. A "celebrated" example is the rhythm guitar on Led Zeppelin 's " Communication Breakdown " 4 while other examples include John Frusciante 's electric guitar parts on BloodSugarSexMagik , Noel Gallagher 's lead-guitar on " Champagne Supernova ", and Billy Corgan 's guitar on " Cherub Rock ", " Today ", " Bullet With Butterfly Wings ", " Zero ", and " Fuck You (An Ode To No One) ". 5
Accent (or Spot) Microphone Placement. Often, the tonal and ambient qualities will sound very different between a distant- and close-miked pickup. Under certain circumstances, it's difficult to obtain a naturally recorded balance when mixing the two together. For example, if a solo instrument within an orchestra needs an extra mic for added volume and presence, placing the mic too close would result in a pickup that sounds overly present, unnatural and out of context with the distant, overall orchestral pickup. To avoid this pitfall, a compromise in distance should be struck. A microphone that has been placed within a reasonably close range to an instrument or section within a larger ensemble (but not so close as to have an unnatural sound) is known as an accent (or spot) pickup Whenever accent miking is used, care should be exercised in placement and pickup choices. The amount of accent signal that's introduced into the mix should sound natural relative to the overall pickup, and a good accent mic should only add presence to a solo passage and not stick out as separate, identifiable pickup. 6 7 8
Often each instrument or vocalist is miked separately, with one or more microphones recording to separate channels (tracks). At a later stage, the channels are combined ('mixed-down') to two channels for stereo or more for surround sound The artists need not perform in the same place at the same time, and individual tracks (or sections of tracks) can be re-recorded to correct errors. Generally effects such as reverberation are added to each recorded channel, and different levels sent to left and right final channels to position the artist in the stereo sound-stage. Microphones may also be used to record the overall effect, or just the effect of the performance room.
This permits greater control over the final sound, but recording two channels (stereo recording) is simpler and cheaper, and can give a sound that is more natural.
There are two features of sound that the human brain uses to place objects in the stereo sound-field between the loudspeakers. These are the relative level (or loudness) difference between the two channels Δ L, and the time delay difference in arrival times for the same sound in each channel Δ t. The "interaural" signals (binaural ILD and ITD) at the ears are not the stereo microphone signals which are coming from the loudspeakers, and are called "interchannel" signals (Δ L and Δ t). These signals are normally not mixed. Loudspeaker signals are different from the sound arriving at the ear. See the article " Binaural recording for earphones ".
Various methods of stereo recording edit
X-Y technique: intensity stereophony edit
XY Stereo
Here there are two directional microphones at the same place, and typically placed at 90° or more to each other. 9 A stereo effect is achieved through differences in sound pressure level between two microphones. Due to the lack of differences in time-of-arrival and phase ambiguities, the sonic characteristic of X-Y recordings is generally less "spacey" and has less depth compared to recordings employing an AB setup.
Blumlein Stereo
When the microphones are bidirectional and placed facing +-45° with respect to the sound source, the X-Y-setup is called a Blumlein Pair The sonic image produced by this configuration is considered by many authorities to create a realistic, almost holographic soundstage.
A further refinement of the Blumlein Pair was developed by EMI in 1958, who called it "Stereosonic". They added a little in-phase crosstalk above 700 Hz to better align the mid and treble phantom sources with the bass ones. 10
A-B technique: time-of-arrival stereophony edit
This technique uses two parallel microphones, typically omnidirectional, some distance apart, capturing time-of-arrival stereo information as well as some level (amplitude) difference information, especially if employed close to the sound source(s). At a distance of about 50 cm (0.5 m) the time delay for a signal reaching first one and then the other microphone from the side is approximately 1.5 ms (1 to 2 ms). If the distance is increased between the microphones it effectively decreases the pickup angle. At 70 cm distance it is about equivalent to the pickup angle of the near-coincident ORTF setup.
M/S technique: Mid/Side stereophony edit
Mid-Side Stereo
This coincident technique employs a bidirectional microphone (with a Figure of 8 polar pattern) facing sideways and a cardioid (generally a variety of cardioid, although Alan Blumlein described the usage of an omnidirectional transducer in his original patent) facing the sound source. The capsules are stacked vertically and brought together as closely as possible, to minimize comb filtering caused by differences in arrival time.
The left and right channels are produced through a simple matrix: Left = Mid + Side, Right = Mid − Side ("minus" means you add the side signal with the polarity reversed). This configuration produces a completely mono-compatible signal and, if the Mid and Side signals are recorded (rather than the matrixed Left and Right), the stereo width (and with that, the perceived distance of the sound source) can be manipulated after the recording has taken place.
Jecklin Disk technique edit
The Jecklin Disk technique is similar to A/B recording, with 2 omni-directional microphones at 36 cm apart from each other. A sound absorbing Jecklin disk of 35cm is placed in the middle between the two microphones. The disk makes the apparent separation between the mics much larger than an equivalent A/B recording.
Choosing a technique edit
If a stereo signal is to be reproduced in mono, out-of-phase parts of the signal will cancel, which may cause the unwanted reduction or loss of some parts of the signal. This can be an important factor in choosing which technique to use.
Since the A-B techniques use phase differences to give the stereo image, they are the least compatible with mono.
Jecklin disk has a relatively small distance between the mics. Frequencies coming in sideways can reach only one microphone and will not interfere. Therefore Jecklin disk works reasonably well when converted to mono. Jecklin disk also gives phase shifts and amplitude differences matching good with what a real pair of ears would hear at this position and therefore is well suited for headphone playback.
In the X-Y techniques, the microphones would ideally be in exactly the same place, which is not possible - if they are slightly separated left to right, there may be some loss of high frequencies when played back in mono, so they are often separated vertically. This only causes problems with sound from above or below the height of the microphones.
The M/S technique is ideal for mono compatibility, since summing Left+Right just gives the Mid signal back.
The equipment for the techniques also varies from the bulky to the small and convenient. A-B techniques generally use two separate microphone units, often mounted on a bar to define the separation. X-Y microphone capsules can be mounted in one unit, or even on the top of a handheld digital recorder.
M/S arrays can be very compact and fit easily into a standard blimp windscreen, which makes boom-operated stereo recordings possible. They provide a variable soundstage width to match a zoom lens , which can be manipulated in post-production. This makes M/S is a very popular stereo technique for film location recording. They are often used in small 'pencil microphones' to mount on video cameras, sometimes even coupled to the zoom.
Sunday, 10 July 2016
20 Recording Tips
Here's 20 exclusive recording tips taken from Future Music's 20th anniversary issue Dig in and get your recording techniques in tip-top form. There are advanced techniques for making the most of your live performances, vocals and sampled sounds.
1. Always leave headroom on your input to allow for unexpected overshoots (extra loud snare hit, vocalist leans forward, etc.) - keep peaks below -6dBFS at least. Sacrificing a lift in the noise floor is a reasonable trade to prevent clipping that perfect vocal take.
2. Stereo or mono? Just because you can record something in stereo doesn't mean you should. Think about how you want it to be placed in the final mix and what the source requires. Does that acoustic guitar really need to be stereo when it's really just a rhythm part?
3. Commit if it sounds good. Don't worry about the technical details or what those know-it-alls online might think, just record it and move on. Fresh is best, even if it's a little rough around the edges. Experience is everything, so the faster you work the more experiences you get!
4. Don't use gear just because you've got it or want to try it out. This is particularly important with EQ and compression/limiting. If you're confident you want to commit them to tape or to disk then do so, but be sure they are providing the sound you want before you track through them, as you can't change it later.
It's amazing how much separation you can get in a room just by changing the angle of a microphone.
5. Keep it short. The shorter the analogue signal path the better the fidelity, so use the shortest and best cables you have. Remove any devices that are not being used, even if they are bypassed, as every connection and ground connection is a potential noise source.
6. Keep it simple. Only use mics you will need and sound good together, don't add things just because the drummer gets excited by attention. As we've said before, you can't fix it in the mix, so if it sounds bad now it will sound bad forever.
7. Pre-production is key. Have as clear an idea of what you want as possible, even if that's just a role or atmospheric 'place' for what is to be recorded. If you want to experiment then dedicate time to do so with the understanding that this may well produce nothing (except fun!).
8. Get the source right first. Make sure the instrument sounds its best (in tune, warmed up, or awake/sober in the case of a vocalist) and sounds good in the room before moving any mics into place. Start with a single mic and check it sounds good before adding any others.
9. Don't spend ages auditioning mics, unless you have time before the performer(s) arrives, as you don't want to wear them out with your technical whims. In fact, try and remove the performer from all technicalities as much as possible; they're their for art, not science.
10. The distance between a mic and source has a defining effect on your recording. You may be tempted to get really close to cut back on the room sound or aid separation, but be aware of the proximity effect (low frequency increase as distance is reduced) as it can quickly make for a muddy, woolly tone.
11. Often DIY efforts are called for to reduce echoes, resonances and increase seperation. Packing blankets, duvets and carpet all make great absorbers, while dense, rigid objects (e.g. timber panels or flight cases) make great reflective separators. Listen, apply and then listen again.
12. Use the HPF or low cut on mics and preamps whenever the source lackslow frequencies. Extraneous noises like foot taps, distant road rumble, and nearby bass amps (!) will eat the headroom on the preamp and add mud to your recording.
13. Use the mic's polar patterns to your advantage, whether it's to screen out other sounds in the room or reflections off walls and windows. Look at the polar pattern data for your mic(s) to see which angles are the most/least sensitive. It's amazing how much separation you can get in a room just by changing the angle of a microphone.
14. Make sure you can always see the meters as you never know when something will need to be trimmed. They will also alert you to things you may have missed, such as a kick drum mic falling into the drum, a foot tapping on the mic stand or an electrical fault causing spurious noise.
15. Multiple microphone setups will always exhibit phase incoherencies, the challenge is to minimise them to achieve the most coherent and pleasing sound. Your ears are the best tool for identifying phase issues so use them as you add in mics. Use the phase (polarity) flip switch when auditioning mics to hear what frequencies are most affected.
Decide on takes there and then. Don't leave these decisions until later if you can help it.
16. Monitoring is key. Whether it's headphones or speakers, the performer(s) must have the best and most flexible foldback you can achieve as the better they can hear the better they will perform. Obviously you need a good monitoring environment to get the best sound setup and hear any problems.
17. You will always set out to do more than you achieve, so be realistic and be prepared to adjust your expectations. Whether it's vocal overdubs or tracking a whole band be prepared to lose time to technical hiccups, toilet breaks, losses of confidence, etc.
18. Decide on takes there and then. Don't leave these decisions until later if you can help it.
19. Label everything you record. Use mic types in the track name if you want, make use of the marker tracks and track note pads in DAWs to keep notes of anything you may want to know later (alternate vocal takes, mic positions moved, etc.). Take photos of your setups too - they're often also useful for promo material.
20. Backup, backup, backup. Make sure you save your project files regularly and backup at the end of every session. When you leave the recording venue take a backup with you, or if you're taking it away make sure someone else has a copy.
1. Always leave headroom on your input to allow for unexpected overshoots (extra loud snare hit, vocalist leans forward, etc.) - keep peaks below -6dBFS at least. Sacrificing a lift in the noise floor is a reasonable trade to prevent clipping that perfect vocal take.
2. Stereo or mono? Just because you can record something in stereo doesn't mean you should. Think about how you want it to be placed in the final mix and what the source requires. Does that acoustic guitar really need to be stereo when it's really just a rhythm part?
3. Commit if it sounds good. Don't worry about the technical details or what those know-it-alls online might think, just record it and move on. Fresh is best, even if it's a little rough around the edges. Experience is everything, so the faster you work the more experiences you get!
4. Don't use gear just because you've got it or want to try it out. This is particularly important with EQ and compression/limiting. If you're confident you want to commit them to tape or to disk then do so, but be sure they are providing the sound you want before you track through them, as you can't change it later.
It's amazing how much separation you can get in a room just by changing the angle of a microphone.
5. Keep it short. The shorter the analogue signal path the better the fidelity, so use the shortest and best cables you have. Remove any devices that are not being used, even if they are bypassed, as every connection and ground connection is a potential noise source.
6. Keep it simple. Only use mics you will need and sound good together, don't add things just because the drummer gets excited by attention. As we've said before, you can't fix it in the mix, so if it sounds bad now it will sound bad forever.
7. Pre-production is key. Have as clear an idea of what you want as possible, even if that's just a role or atmospheric 'place' for what is to be recorded. If you want to experiment then dedicate time to do so with the understanding that this may well produce nothing (except fun!).
8. Get the source right first. Make sure the instrument sounds its best (in tune, warmed up, or awake/sober in the case of a vocalist) and sounds good in the room before moving any mics into place. Start with a single mic and check it sounds good before adding any others.
9. Don't spend ages auditioning mics, unless you have time before the performer(s) arrives, as you don't want to wear them out with your technical whims. In fact, try and remove the performer from all technicalities as much as possible; they're their for art, not science.
10. The distance between a mic and source has a defining effect on your recording. You may be tempted to get really close to cut back on the room sound or aid separation, but be aware of the proximity effect (low frequency increase as distance is reduced) as it can quickly make for a muddy, woolly tone.
11. Often DIY efforts are called for to reduce echoes, resonances and increase seperation. Packing blankets, duvets and carpet all make great absorbers, while dense, rigid objects (e.g. timber panels or flight cases) make great reflective separators. Listen, apply and then listen again.
12. Use the HPF or low cut on mics and preamps whenever the source lackslow frequencies. Extraneous noises like foot taps, distant road rumble, and nearby bass amps (!) will eat the headroom on the preamp and add mud to your recording.
13. Use the mic's polar patterns to your advantage, whether it's to screen out other sounds in the room or reflections off walls and windows. Look at the polar pattern data for your mic(s) to see which angles are the most/least sensitive. It's amazing how much separation you can get in a room just by changing the angle of a microphone.
14. Make sure you can always see the meters as you never know when something will need to be trimmed. They will also alert you to things you may have missed, such as a kick drum mic falling into the drum, a foot tapping on the mic stand or an electrical fault causing spurious noise.
15. Multiple microphone setups will always exhibit phase incoherencies, the challenge is to minimise them to achieve the most coherent and pleasing sound. Your ears are the best tool for identifying phase issues so use them as you add in mics. Use the phase (polarity) flip switch when auditioning mics to hear what frequencies are most affected.
Decide on takes there and then. Don't leave these decisions until later if you can help it.
16. Monitoring is key. Whether it's headphones or speakers, the performer(s) must have the best and most flexible foldback you can achieve as the better they can hear the better they will perform. Obviously you need a good monitoring environment to get the best sound setup and hear any problems.
17. You will always set out to do more than you achieve, so be realistic and be prepared to adjust your expectations. Whether it's vocal overdubs or tracking a whole band be prepared to lose time to technical hiccups, toilet breaks, losses of confidence, etc.
18. Decide on takes there and then. Don't leave these decisions until later if you can help it.
19. Label everything you record. Use mic types in the track name if you want, make use of the marker tracks and track note pads in DAWs to keep notes of anything you may want to know later (alternate vocal takes, mic positions moved, etc.). Take photos of your setups too - they're often also useful for promo material.
20. Backup, backup, backup. Make sure you save your project files regularly and backup at the end of every session. When you leave the recording venue take a backup with you, or if you're taking it away make sure someone else has a copy.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)